文献速递医学教育与科研方法临床试验与 GCP

针对缺乏同意能力成年人试验的招募干预:设计试验内研究(SWAT)的方法学与伦理考量

Recruitment interventions for trials involving adults lacking capacity to consent: methodological and ethical considerations for designing Studies Within a Trial (SWATs).
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2022-09-06

本文以CONSULT SWAT为例,探讨在涉及缺乏同意能力成年人的非急诊试验中设计招募干预SWAT时遇到的方法学与伦理问题。CONSULT干预针对代决策者(家属)而非受试者本人,文章讨论了知情同意、数据收集与随访、随机化层级、资源使用及宿主试验完整性等挑战,并提出潜在解决思路,认为厘清这些挑战可为开展此类SWAT提供讨论起点。

要点

  • CONSULT SWAT评估面向代决策者的决策辅助工具,该代决策者非宿主试验受试者。
  • 设计此类SWAT需处理代决策者与宿主试验招募保留数据的链接问题。
  • 代决策者同意本身伦理复杂,旨在改变代决策的SWAT需额外伦理考量。

核心结论

  • 设计评估缺乏同意能力成年人非急诊试验招募干预的SWAT,提出了若干方法学与伦理考量。
  • 阐明这些挑战及部分潜在解决方式,为讨论开展这些可能更具挑战性的SWAT创造起点。
  • 增加涉及缺乏同意能力成年人试验实施的证据基础,旨在改善开展这些试验的能力及其质量,并帮助为这一服务不足人群建设研究能力。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为评论文章,以CONSULT SWAT为案例,探讨设计此类SWAT时遇到的方法学与伦理考量。
  • CONSULT SWAT旨在多个宿主试验中评估面向代决策者的决策辅助工具。

主要发现

  • 在知情同意、数据收集和随访方面遇到实际问题,涉及将干预接收者(代决策者)与宿主试验的招募和保留数据相链接。
  • 还遇到随机化层级、资源使用以及维持宿主试验完整性方面的问题。
  • 若未解决,关于招募差异和试验人群间异质性的方法学不确定性可能限制得出稳健推断和协调不同SWAT宿主试验数据的范围。
  • 代决策者同意本身伦理复杂,开展旨在改变和提升代决策者同意决定的SWAT时需考虑额外伦理问题。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The number of interventions to improve recruitment and retention of participants in trials is rising, with a corresponding growth in randomised Studies Within Trials (SWATs) to evaluate their (cost-)effectiveness. Despite recognised challenges in conducting trials involving adults who lack capacity to consent, until now, no individual-level recruitment interventions have focused on this population. Following the development of a decision aid for family members making non-emergency trial participation decisions on behalf of people with impaired capacity, we have designed a SWAT to evaluate the decision aid in a number of host trials (CONSULT). Unlike in recruitment SWATs to date, the CONSULT intervention is aimed at a 'proxy' decision-maker (a family member) who is not a participant in the host trial and does not receive the trial intervention. This commentary explores the methodological and ethical considerations encountered when designing such SWATs, using the CONSULT SWAT as a case example. Potential solutions to address these issues are also presented. DISCUSSION: We encountered practical issues around informed consent, data collection, and follow-up which involves linking the intervention receiver (the proxy) with recruitment and retention data from the host trial, as well as issues around randomisation level, resource use, and maintaining the integrity of the host trial. Unless addressed, methodological uncertainty about differential recruitment and heterogeneity between trial populations could potentially limit the scope for drawing robust inferences and harmonising data from different SWAT host trials. Proxy consent is itself ethically complex, and so when conducting a SWAT which aims to disrupt and enhance proxy consent decisions, there are additional ethical issues to be considered. CONCLUSIONS: Designing a SWAT to evaluate a recruitment intervention for non-emergency trials with adults lacking capacity to consent has raised a number of methodological and ethical considerations. Explicating these challenges, and some potential ways to address them, creates a starting point for discussions about conducting these potentially more challenging SWATs. Increasing the evidence base for the conduct of trials involving adults lacking capacity to consent is intended to improve both the ability to conduct these trials and their quality, and so help build research capacity for this under-served population.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Shepherd V, Wood F, Gillies K, et al. Recruitment interventions for trials involving adults lacking capacity to consent: methodological and ethical considerations for designing Studies Within a Trial (SWATs). Trials. 2022. PMID: 36068637. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06705-y

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。