电子烟公共卫生建议的制定过程在利益冲突管理方面缺乏透明度
本研究调查指南制定组在制定电子烟建议时如何收集和管理利益冲突。从世界卫生组织、英国、澳大利亚和美国四个辖区选取10个公共卫生机构,分析其利益冲突政策并访谈15名指南方法学家、政策制定者和学者。结果显示仅5个机构有公开的利益冲突政策,管理方式缺乏标准化和透明度。
要点
- 10个公共卫生机构中仅5个有公开的利益冲突政策。
- 利益冲突申报在申报主体、时间范围和申报方式上存在差异。
- 参与者认为当前利益冲突收集与管理流程因解释开放和部分申报可能而不充分。
核心结论
- 公共卫生机构对利益冲突的管理各不相同,缺乏标准化和透明度。
- 指南制定组应依据全面且可获取的利益冲突政策来改进利益冲突的收集与管理,并最终提高建议的可信度。
研究设计与样本
- 从四个 purposively 选定的辖区(世界卫生组织、英国、澳大利亚和美国)识别出曾制定电子烟建议的公共卫生机构。
- 分析了这些机构的利益冲突政策,并对指南制定组中的指南方法学家、政策制定者和学者进行了15次访谈。
主要发现
- 10个公共卫生机构中仅5个有公开可获取的利益冲突政策。
- 参与者讨论了参与制定过程者申报利益冲突的重要性。
- 在谁必须报告利益冲突、所询问的时间范围以及申报内容和方式上存在差异。
- 利益冲突政策和参与者讨论了一系列管理利益冲突的方法,从限制参与到取消参与建议制定过程的资格。
- 参与者认为当前收集和管理利益冲突的流程不充分,原因在于其解释开放和可能的部分利益申报。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate how guideline development groups collect and manage conflicts of interest (COI) when producing electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) recommendations. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Public health bodies that had produced e-cigarette recommendations were identified from four purposively selected jurisdictions (World Health Organization, United Kingdom, Australia, and United States). We analysed their COI policies and conducted 15 interviews with guideline methodologists, policymakers, and academics in guideline development groups. RESULTS: Only five of 10 public health bodies had a publicly available COI policy. Participants discussed the importance of those involved in the development process declaring COI. However, there were differences in who had to report COI, the time period asked about, and what and how declarations are made. COI policies and participants discussed a range of approaches for managing COI, from limiting involvement to disqualification from the recommendation development process. Participants considered the current processes for collecting and managing COI insufficient due to their open interpretation and possibility for partial declarations of interest. CONCLUSION: The management of COI varies across public health bodies, with little standardization and lack of transparency. To improve the collection and management of COI, and ultimately increase the trustworthiness of recommendations, guideline development groups should draw upon a comprehensive and accessible COI policy.
引用
- Smith MJ, Katikireddi SV, Hilton S, et al. Development processes for e-cigarette public health recommendations lacked transparency in managing conflicts of interest. J Clin Epidemiol. 2022. PMID: 36122822. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.09.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。