被撤稿的随机对照试验被系统综述和临床实践指南引用且未获更正
该 meta 流行病学研究从撤稿观察数据库纳入引用被撤稿随机对照试验(RCT)的系统综述(SR)和临床实践指南(CPG),共识别 587 篇文章(525 篇 SR 和 62 篇 CPG)。其中 252 篇(43%)在撤稿后发表,335 篇(57%)在撤稿前发表;在证据合成中无警示地引用已撤稿 RCT 的 127 篇文章均未在发表后自我更正。在撤稿前发表的 335 篇文章中,239 篇在证据合成中纳入了后来被撤稿的 RCT,其中仅 5% 的 SR(9/196)和 5% 的 CPG(2/43)更正或撤回了其结果。
要点
- 587 篇文献引用被撤稿 RCT,其中 43% 发表于撤稿后、57% 发表于撤稿前。
- 127 篇在证据合成中无警示地引用已撤稿 RCT,发表后无一自我更正。
- 撤稿前发表的 239 篇纳入后来被撤稿 RCT 的文献中,仅 5% 的 SR 和 5% 的 CPG 更正或撤回。
核心结论
- 许多 SR 和 CPG 无警示地纳入了已撤稿或后来被撤稿的 RCT,且大多数从未被更正。
- 科学界包括出版商和研究者应做出系统性和协同努力以消除被撤稿 RCT 的影响。
研究设计与样本
- meta 流行病学研究,从撤稿观察数据库纳入引用被撤稿 RCT 的 SR 和 CPG。
- 共识别 587 篇文章(525 篇 SR 和 62 篇 CPG),其中 252 篇(43%)发表于撤稿后、335 篇(57%)发表于撤稿前。
主要发现
- 587 篇引用被撤稿 RCT 的文章中,252 篇(43%)发表于撤稿后,335 篇(57%)发表于撤稿前。
- 127 篇在证据合成中无警示地引用已撤稿 RCT 的文章,发表后无一自我更正。
- 335 篇撤稿前发表的文章中,239 篇在证据合成中纳入了后来被撤稿的 RCT。
- 239 篇中仅 5% 的 SR(9/196)和 5% 的 CPG(2/43)更正或撤回了其结果。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether and when the correction is done in Systematic Reviews (SRs) and Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) when included Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) have been retracted. METHODS: In this meta-epidemiological study, we included SRs and CPGs citing the retracted RCTs from the Retraction Watch Database. We investigated how often the retracted RCTs were cited in SRs and CPGs. We also investigated whether and when such SRs and CPGs corrected themselves. RESULTS: We identified 587 articles (525 SRs and 62 CPGs) citing retracted RCTs. Among the 587 articles, 252 (43%) were published after retraction, and 335 (57%) were published before retraction. Among 127 articles published citing already retracted RCTs in their evidence synthesis without caution, none corrected themselves after publication. Of 335 articles published before retraction, 239 included RCTs that were later retracted in their evidence synthesis. Among them, only 5% of SRs (9/196) and 5% of CPGs (2/43) corrected or retracted their results. CONCLUSION: Many SRs and CPGs included already or later retracted RCTs without caution. Most of them were never corrected. The scientific community, including publishers and researchers, should make systematic and concerted efforts to remove the impact of retracted RCTs.
引用
- Kataoka Y, Banno M, Tsujimoto Y, et al. Retracted randomized controlled trials were cited and not corrected in systematic reviews and clinical practice guidelines. J Clin Epidemiol. 2022. PMID: 35779825. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.06.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。