系统评价方案对PRISMA-P 2015报告指南的依从性不足
该研究随机抽取2016年以来PubMed收录的50篇系统评价方案和PROSPERO注册的50篇方案,评估对PRISMA-P 26个条目的依从性。PubMed方案中4篇(8%)完全依从、45篇(90%)部分依从;PROSPERO方案中0篇完全依从、仅6篇(12%)部分依从。资助者角色、定性数据合成程序、发表偏倚评估等方法常未报告。
要点
- PubMed收录方案中4篇(8%)完全依从PRISMA-P,45篇(90%)部分依从。
- PROSPERO注册方案中0篇完全依从,仅6篇(12%)部分依从。
- 资助者角色、定性合成程序及偏倚评估方法常未报告。
核心结论
- PubMed收录的系统评价方案对PRISMA-P的依从性有些不足,PROSPERO注册方案则明显不足。
- 作者认为按PRISMA-P报告的系统评价方案作者应仔细核对指南所有条目,期刊编辑和同行评议者审稿时应考虑PRISMA-P依从性。
研究设计与样本
- 随机抽取2016年以来PubMed收录的50篇系统评价方案和上传至PROSPERO的50篇方案。
- 两名作者独立提取数据并评估对PRISMA-P 26个条目的依从性。
- 依从性分为完全依从(≥90%条目完全报告)和部分依从(≥60%条目完全报告)。
主要发现
- PubMed方案中4篇(8%)完全依从,45篇(90%)部分依从,但变异较大。
- PROSPERO方案中0篇(0%)完全依从,仅6篇(12%)部分依从。
- 两类方案中资助者角色、定量合成不适用时的定性数据合成程序、发表偏倚或结局报告偏倚评估方法及累积证据信心等条目常未报告。
关键数值与推荐
- 完全依从定义为≥90%的PRISMA-P条目完全报告。
- 部分依从定义为≥60%的PRISMA-P条目完全报告。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为决定按PRISMA-P报告的系统评价方案作者应仔细核对指南所有条目。
- 作者认为期刊编辑和同行评议者在审阅方案时应考虑PRISMA-P依从性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of the study was to investigate to which degree systematic review protocols adhere to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic review and Meta-Analysis Protocols (PRISMA-P) reporting guideline. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We randomly sampled 50 publications of systematic review protocols indexed in PubMed and 50 protocols uploaded to the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) from 2016 onward. Two authors independently extracted data and assessed adherence to the 26 items specified by PRISMA-P. For each protocol, we categorized adherence to PRISMA-P as complete (≥90% of PRISMA-P items were fully reported) or partial (≥60% of PRISMA-P items were fully reported). We also assessed adherence to each PRISMA-P item across the protocols. RESULTS: Four (8%) of the PubMed-indexed protocols adhered completely and 45 (90%) adhered partially to PRISMA-P but with considerable variation. None (0%) of the PROSPERO-uploaded protocols adhered completely and only 6 (12%) adhered partially to PRISMA-P. For both types of protocols, aspects related to the role of the sponsor, procedures for doing qualitative data synthesis if quantitative synthesis is not appropriate, and methods for assessing publication or outcome reporting biases and confidence in cumulative evidence were often not reported. CONCLUSION: Adherence to the PRISMA-P reporting guideline was somewhat inadequate in PubMed-indexed protocols and clearly inadequate in PROSPERO-uploaded protocols. Authors of systematic review protocols who decide to report according to PRISMA-P should carefully check all items included in the guideline, and journal editors and peer reviewers should consider PRISMA-P adherence when reviewing protocols for potential publication.
引用
- Frost AD, Hróbjartsson A, Nejstgaard CH, et al. Adherence to the PRISMA-P 2015 reporting guideline was inadequate in systematic review protocols. J Clin Epidemiol. 2022. PMID: 35820587. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.07.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。