急性感染性结膜炎患者是否患有细菌感染?:理性临床检查系统综述
该系统综述纳入32项研究(27项用微生物学参考标准,5项用临床参考标准),评估儿童和成人急性感染性结膜炎中病毒与细菌的患病率及提示病因的症状体征。儿童中细菌性结膜炎患病率高于病毒性(71% vs 16%,P=0.01),成人中病毒性高于细菌性(78% vs 16%,P<0.001)。咽炎、耳前淋巴结肿大和接触红眼患者提示病毒性可能,黏液脓性分泌物和中耳炎提示细菌性可能,但无单一症状或体征能高确定性区分两者。
要点
- 儿童急性感染性结膜炎中细菌性患病率高于病毒性(71% vs 16%,P=0.01)。
- 成人中病毒性患病率高于细菌性(78% vs 16%,P<0.001),但仅基于一项研究。
- 咽炎、耳前淋巴结肿大、接触红眼患者提示病毒性;黏液脓性分泌物、中耳炎提示细菌性。
核心结论
- 儿童中细菌性结膜炎比病毒性更常见,成人中病毒性比细菌性更常见,但患病率估计基于有限证据。
- 与病毒性结膜炎较高可能性相关的症状和体征包括合并咽炎、耳前淋巴结肿大和接触另一名红眼患者。
- 与细菌性结膜炎较高可能性相关的体征包括黏液脓性分泌物和中耳炎,但无单一症状或体征能高确定性区分两种疾病。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE(1946年1月至2022年3月),纳入1891篇文章中的32项研究进行Meta分析。
- 27项研究使用微生物学参考标准诊断,5项使用临床参考标准诊断;质量评分基于改良的理性临床检查分级系统,质量等级1至4要求微生物学参考标准,等级5使用临床参考标准。
- 纳入连续系列的急性感染性结膜炎患者以及单纯病毒性或细菌性结膜炎的病例系列。
主要发现
- 儿童研究(5项研究;881例患者;平均年龄4.7岁[年龄范围1个月至18岁])中,细菌性结膜炎患病率为71%,病毒性为16%(P=0.01)。
- 唯一一项成人研究(n=207例患者;平均年龄25.7岁)中,病毒性结膜炎患病率为78%,细菌性为16%(P<0.001)。
- 在质量等级1(n=6)和等级2(n=5)研究的主要分析(共1725例患者)中,区分病毒性与细菌性病因的临床发现包括:咽炎(敏感度范围0.55-0.58;特异度范围0.89-0.94;阳性似然比[LR]范围5.4-9.9)、耳前淋巴结肿大(敏感度范围0.17-0.31;特异度范围0.93-0.94;阳性LR范围2.5-5.6)、接触另一名红眼患者(敏感度0.18[95%CI,0.14-0.22];特异度0.93[95%CI,0.90-0.95];阳性LR 2.5[95%CI,1.6-3.7])。
- 与细菌性结膜炎相关的发现包括:黏液脓性眼分泌物(敏感度0.76[95%CI,0.60-0.87];特异度0.66[95%CI,0.58-0.73];阳性LR 2.1[95%CI,1.7-2.6])和中耳炎(敏感度0.24[95%CI,0.20-0.29];特异度0.91[95%CI,0.85-0.94];阳性LR 2.5[95%CI,1.5-4.4])。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 患病率估计基于有限证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Acute infectious conjunctivitis is characterized by ocular redness and discharge, and is a common clinical entity. Evidence-based tools to aid the clinical diagnosis of viral vs bacterial conjunctivitis are lacking and may contribute to overprescribing of topical antibiotics. OBJECTIVE: To determine the relative prevalence of viral vs bacterial conjunctivitis in adults and children, and to determine which symptoms or signs are suggestive of a viral vs bacterial etiology. DATA SOURCES: A MEDLINE search (January 1946-March 2022) yielded 1891 articles. Included articles were rated using a quality score based on a modified Rational Clinical Examination grading system. Methodological quality levels 1 through 4 required a microbiological reference standard for diagnosis, whereas quality level 5 (the lowest quality) used a clinical reference standard for diagnosis. STUDY SELECTION: Consecutive series of patients presenting with acute infectious conjunctivitis and case series of viral or bacterial conjunctivitis alone. Thirty-two studies were included in a meta-analysis to determine prevalence and diagnostic accuracy measures; 27 used a microbiological reference standard for diagnosis and 5 used a clinical reference standard for diagnosis. RESULTS: In studies involving children (5 studies; 881 patients; mean age, 4.7 years [age range, 1 month-18 years]), the prevalence of bacterial conjunctivitis was higher than viral conjunctivitis (71% vs 16%, respectively, P = .01). In the only study of adults (n = 207 patients; mean age, 25.7 years), the prevalence of viral conjunctivitis was higher than bacterial conjunctivitis (78% vs 16%, respectively, P < .001). For the primary analysis of level 1 (n = 6) and level 2 (n = 5) studies (1725 patients total), the clinical findings that best distinguished a viral etiology for conjunctivitis from a bacterial etiology included pharyngitis (sensitivity range, 0.55-0.58; specificity range, 0.89-0.94; positive likelihood ratio [LR] range, 5.4-9.9), preauricular lymphadenopathy (sensitivity range, 0.17-0.31; specificity range, 0.93-0.94; positive LR range, 2.5-5.6), and contact with another person with red eye (sensitivity, 0.18 [95% CI, 0.14-0.22]; specificity, 0.93 [95% CI, 0.90-0.95]; positive LR, 2.5 [95% CI, 1.6-3.7]). Mucopurulent ocular discharge (sensitivity, 0.76 [95% CI, 0.60-0.87); specificity, 0.66 [95% CI, 0.58-0.73]; positive LR, 2.1 [95% CI, 1.7-2.6]) and otitis media (sensitivity, 0.24 [95% CI, 0.20-0.29]; specificity, 0.91 [95% CI, 0.85-0.94]; positive LR, 2.5 [95% CI, 1.5-4.4]) were associated with the presence of bacterial conjunctivitis. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this review, bacterial conjunctivitis was more common than viral conjunctivitis in children and viral conjunctivitis was more common than bacterial conjunctivitis in adults, although the prevalence estimates were based on limited evidence. Symptoms and signs associated with a higher likelihood of viral conjunctivitis in adults and children included concomitant pharyngitis, an enlarged preauricular node, and contact with another person with red eye, and signs associated with a higher likelihood of bacterial conjunctivitis included the presence of mucopurulent discharge and otitis media, but no single symptom or sign differentiated the 2 conditions with high certainty.
引用
- Johnson D, Liu D, Simel D, et al. Does This Patient With Acute Infectious Conjunctivitis Have a Bacterial Infection?: The Rational Clinical Examination Systematic Review. JAMA. 2022. PMID: 35699701. doi:10.1001/jama.2022.7687
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。