急诊环境下使用延迟同意的试验:利益相关者态度的系统综述与叙述性综合
该系统综述检索MEDLINE、EMCare、PsychINFO、Scopus和HMIC从1996年至2021年1月的文献,纳入27项关于成人急诊研究延迟同意过程的实证原始研究,采用叙述性方法进行主题编码。研究发现四个主题:延迟同意的可接受程度、影响可接受性的研究相关因素、影响个人观点的个人特征、以及拒绝同意或参与者死亡后的数据使用。结论认为在治疗窗口窄且患者可能从入组中获益的低风险急诊研究中,延迟同意对利益相关者最为可接受。
要点
- 27项研究中多数(n=19)调查患者观点,公众(n=5)和医护人员(n=5)观点也有报告。
- 在治疗窗口窄且患者可能获益的低风险急诊研究中,延迟同意可接受性最高。
- 异质性结局测量使研究结果差异无法可靠归因于不同试验特征。
核心结论
- 在治疗窗口窄且患者可能从入组中获益的低风险急诊研究中,延迟同意对利益相关者最为可接受。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与叙述性综合,检索MEDLINE、EMCare、PsychINFO、Scopus和HMIC从1996年至2021年1月的文献。
- 纳入27项仅针对成人的、英文发表的、报告实证原始研究的延迟同意过程研究,所有设计均纳入。
- 采用叙述性方法进行主题编码以「讲述故事」呈现发现。
主要发现
- 共纳入27项研究进行叙述性综合。
- 多数研究调查患者观点(n=19),公众(n=5)和医护人员(n=5)的数据也有报告。
- 识别出四个 overarching 主题:延迟同意的可接受程度、影响可接受性的研究相关因素、影响个人观点的个人特征、拒绝同意或参与者死亡后的数据使用。
局限性
- 叙述性综合虽允许评估纳入研究,但异质性结局测量使研究结果差异无法可靠归因于不同试验特征。
- 未来研究应致力于为研究伦理委员会在审查使用延迟同意的急诊研究试验时制定指南,并更充分地调查医护人员的观点,迄今为止对医护人员的探索少于患者和公众。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patients with acute conditions often lack the capacity to provide informed consent, and narrow therapeutic windows mean there is no time to seek consent from surrogates prior to treatment being commenced. One method to enable the inclusion of this study population in emergency research is through recruitment without prior consent, often known as 'deferred consent'. However, empirical studies have shown a large disparity in stakeholders' opinions regarding this enrolment method. This systematic review aimed to understand different stakeholder groups' attitudes to deferred consent, particularly in relation to the context in which deferred consent might occur. METHODS: Databases including MEDLINE, EMCare, PsychINFO, Scopus, and HMIC were searched from 1996 to January 2021. Eligible studies focussed on deferred consent processes for adults only, in the English language, and reported empirical primary research. Studies of all designs were included. Relevant data were extracted and thematically coded using a narrative approach to 'tell a story' of the findings. RESULTS: Twenty-seven studies were included in the narrative synthesis. The majority examined patient views (n = 19). Data from the members of the public (n = 5) and health care professionals (n =5) were also reported. Four overarching themes were identified: level of acceptability of deferred consent, research-related factors influencing acceptability, personal characteristics influencing views on deferred consent, and data use after refusal of consent or participant death. CONCLUSIONS: This review indicates that the use of deferred consent would be most acceptable to stakeholders during low-risk emergency research with a narrow therapeutic window and where there is potential for patients to benefit from their inclusion. While the use of narrative synthesis allowed assessment of the included studies, heterogeneous outcome measures meant that variations in study results could not be reliably attributed to the different trial characteristics. Future research should aim to develop guidance for research ethics committees when reviewing trials using deferred consent in emergency research and investigate more fully the views of healthcare professionals which to date have been explored less than patients and members of the public. Trial registration PROSPERO CRD42020223623.
引用
- Fitzpatrick A, Wood F, Shepherd V, et al. Trials using deferred consent in the emergency setting: a systematic review and narrative synthesis of stakeholders' attitudes. Trials. 2022. PMID: 35578362. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06304-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。