病因学研究中的探索性分析及可信度评估考量:文献迷你综述
该迷你综述纳入2021年首期四本流行病学期刊的病因学观察性研究,统计暴露-结局关联数量:主要分析平均33个(范围1-120),敏感性分析30个(0-336),附加分析163个(0-1467)。文章提出评估探索性分析可信度的六项考量:研究问题、研究方案、统计标准、结果解释、报告完整性及对今后因果研究的影响。结论认为探索性分析的报告并不总是规范,呼吁研究者明确报告其探索性质并指明未来研究方向。
要点
- 病因学观察性研究报告中暴露-结局关联数量众多,附加分析平均达163个。
- 评估探索性分析可信度需考虑研究问题、方案、统计标准、解释、报告完整性及对未来研究影响六方面。
- 作者认为研究者应明确报告探索性分析的性质,并指明哪些发现需在未来研究中验证及如何验证。
核心结论
- 基于该迷你综述,病因学研究中的探索性分析并不总是得到规范报告。
- 作者提出六项报告考量以促进关于探索性分析处理和报告的讨论。
- 研究者应通过明确报告其探索性质并指明未来应研究哪些发现及如何研究,对探索性分析结果负责。
研究设计与样本
- 文献迷你综述及探索性研究原则阐述。
- 聚焦病因学因果研究,即研究一个或多个危险因素对特定健康结局或疾病的因果效应。
- 纳入2021年首期四本流行病学期刊(American Journal of Epidemiology、Epidemiology、European Journal of Epidemiology、International Journal of Epidemiology)的病因学研究文章,重点关注疾病的因果危险因素的观察性研究。
主要发现
- 主要分析报告的暴露-结局关联平均数为33个(范围1-120)。
- 敏感性分析报告的暴露-结局关联平均数为30个(范围0-336)。
- 附加分析报告的暴露-结局关联平均数为163个(范围0-1467)。
- 文章讨论了评估探索性分析可信度的六项考量:研究问题、研究方案、统计标准、结果解释、报告完整性以及探索性发现对未来因果研究的影响。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To provide considerations for reporting and interpretation that can improve assessment of the credibility of exploratory analyses in aetiologic research. DESIGN: Mini-review of the literature and account of exploratory research principles. SETTING: This study focuses on a particular type of causal research, namely aetiologic studies, which investigate the causal effect of one or multiple risk factors on a particular health outcome or disease. The mini review included aetiologic research articles published in four epidemiology journals in the first issue of 2021: American Journal of Epidemiology, Epidemiology, European Journal of Epidemiology, and International Journal of Epidemiology, specifically focusing on observational studies of causal risk factors of diseases. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Number of exposure-outcome associations reported, grouped by type of analysis (main, sensitivity, and additional). RESULTS: The journal articles reported many exposure-outcome associations: a mean number of 33 (range 1-120) exposure-outcome associations for the primary analysis, 30 (0-336) for sensitivity analyses, and 163 (0-1467) for additional analyses. Six considerations were discussed that are important in assessing the credibility of exploratory analyses: research problem, protocol, statistical criteria, interpretation of findings, completeness of reporting, and effect of exploratory findings on future causal research. CONCLUSIONS: Based on this mini-review, exploratory analyses in aetiologic research were not always reported properly. Six considerations for reporting of exploratory analyses in aetiologic research were provided to stimulate a discussion about their preferred handling and reporting. Researchers should take responsibility for the results of exploratory analyses by clearly reporting their exploratory nature and specifying which findings should be investigated in future research and how.
引用
- Luijken K, Dekkers OM, Rosendaal FR, et al. Exploratory analyses in aetiologic research and considerations for assessment of credibility: mini-review of literature. BMJ. 2022. PMID: 35504648. doi:10.1136/bmj-2021-070113
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。