干预性系统评价的数据与代码可及性声明常缺失或不准确:一项内容分析
该内容分析在2020年11月2日至12月2日期间检索多个数据库,随机抽取300篇聚合数据Meta分析的系统评价,评估数据与代码可及性声明的频率及内容。结果显示86篇(29%)有数据可及性声明,仅7篇(2%)同时有数据与代码声明;93份数据声明中12份(13%)声称可从期刊网站或数据仓库下载数据并经核实为真,39份(42%)称可应要求提供数据,37份(40%)暗示数据共享不必要或不适用。作者认为需要多种干预措施来提高系统评价者的数据与代码共享。
要点
- 300篇系统评价中仅86篇(29%)有数据可及性声明,7篇(2%)同时有数据与代码声明。
- 93份数据声明中仅12份(13%)声称可从期刊网站或数据仓库下载数据,经核实为真。
- 37/93(40%)的数据声明暗示数据共享不必要或不适用于系统评价。
核心结论
- 数据与代码可及性声明在系统评价稿件中出现频率低,提供声明的作者常错误暗示数据共享不适用于系统评价。
- 作者认为需要多种干预措施来提高系统评价者的数据与代码共享。
研究设计与样本
- 对聚合数据Meta分析的系统评价进行内容分析,检索PubMed、ProQuest教育合集、Scopus、Web of Science的Social Sciences Citation Index和Science Citation Index Expanded,检索期为2020年11月2日至12月2日共4周。
- 记录随机排序后由两名作者独立筛选,直至达到目标样本300篇系统评价。
- 两名作者独立记录每篇综述是否出现数据或代码可及性声明(或两者),并采用归纳法对声明内容进行编码。
主要发现
- 300篇纳入的Meta分析系统评价中,86篇(29%)有数据可及性声明,7篇(2%)同时有数据与代码可及性声明。
- 93份数据可及性声明中,12份(13%)作者称数据文件可从期刊网站或数据仓库下载,经核实为真。
- 93份数据可及性声明中,39份(42%)作者称数据可应要求提供。
- 93份数据可及性声明中,37份(40%)暗示共享数据文件不必要或不适用,最常见原因是「所有数据均出现在文章中」或「未生成或分析数据集」。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the frequency of data and code availability statements in a random sample of systematic reviews with meta-analysis of aggregate data, summarize the content of the statements and investigate how often data and code files were shared. METHODS: We searched for systematic reviews with meta-analysis of aggregate data on the effects of a health, social, behavioral, or educational intervention that were indexed in PubMed, Education Collection via ProQuest, Scopus via Elsevier, or Social Sciences Citation Index and Science Citation Index Expanded via Web of Science during a 4-week period (between November 2, and December 2, 2020). Records were randomly sorted and screened independently by two authors until our target sample of 300 systematic reviews was reached. Two authors independently recorded whether a data or code availability statement (or both) appeared in each review and coded the content of the statements using an inductive approach. RESULTS: Of the 300 included systematic reviews with meta-analysis, 86 (29%) had a data availability statement, and seven (2%) had both a data and code availability statement. In 12/93 (13%) data availability statements, authors stated that data files were available for download from the journal website or a data repository, which we verified as being true. While 39/93 (42%) authors stated data were available upon request, 37/93 (40%) implied that sharing of data files was not necessary or applicable to them, most often because "all data appear in the article" or "no datasets were generated or analyzed". DISCUSSION: Data and code availability statements appear infrequently in systematic review manuscripts. Authors who do provide a data availability statement often incorrectly imply that data sharing is not applicable to systematic reviews. Our results suggest the need for various interventions to increase data and code sharing by systematic reviewers.
引用
- Page MJ, Nguyen PY, Hamilton DG, et al. Data and code availability statements in systematic reviews of interventions were often missing or inaccurate: a content analysis. J Clin Epidemiol. 2022. PMID: 35278609. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.03.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。