在空间聚类数据集中重获独立性:一系列数据驱动的空间权重矩阵
针对流行病学与环境研究中空间依赖呈现聚类或地理不连续时,基于地理学第一定律的经典空间权重矩阵(W)调整可能不适用的问题,作者提出一系列数据驱动空间权重矩阵(DDW),依据扫描统计量识别的空间模式构建,可借助SaTScan等现有工具实现,并同时考虑聚类(或不连续)与基于地理学第一定律的直观空间依赖。以估计解释变量X的效应值和疾病制图中各空间单元风险为目标,分别选用常用空间自回归模型与基于Leroux先验的条件自回归(CAR)模型评估DDW性能;模拟研究与案例研究均显示,在存在聚类(或不连续)空间依赖的数据集中,DDW表现明显优于经典W。
要点
- DDW依据扫描统计量识别的空间模式构建,可借助SaTScan等现有工具实现。
- DDW同时考虑聚类(或不连续)与基于地理学第一定律的直观空间依赖。
- 模拟与案例研究显示,在存在聚类(或不连续)空间依赖的数据集中DDW表现明显优于经典W。
核心结论
- 在存在聚类(或不连续)空间依赖的数据集中,DDW表现明显优于经典W。
- DDW纳入CAR模型后相较最新发表的基于密度的空间聚类模型仍显示明显优势,尤其在常见病数据集。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,提出一系列数据驱动空间权重矩阵(DDW),依据扫描统计量识别的空间模式构建,可借助SaTScan等现有工具实现。
- 以估计解释变量X的效应值为目标,选用常用空间自回归模型评估DDW性能。
- 以估计疾病制图中各空间单元风险为目标,选用基于Leroux先验的条件自回归(CAR)模型评估DDW性能。
- 通过模拟研究与案例研究评估DDW表现,并与经典W及最新发表的基于密度的空间聚类模型比较。
主要发现
- 模拟与案例研究均显示,在存在聚类(或不连续)空间依赖的数据集中,DDW表现明显优于经典W。
- DDW纳入CAR模型后,相较最新发表的基于密度的空间聚类模型仍显示明显优势,尤其在常见病数据集。
- 基于地理学第一定律的W在存在聚类(或不连续)空间依赖时可能不适用,并导致估计不准确与统计效能损失。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Most spatial models include a spatial weights matrix (W) derived from the first law of geography to adjust the spatial dependence to fulfill the independence assumption. In various fields such as epidemiological and environmental studies, the spatial dependence often shows clustering (or geographic discontinuity) due to natural or social factors. In such cases, adjustment using the first-law-of-geography-based W might be inappropriate and leads to inaccuracy estimations and loss of statistical power. In this work, we propose a series of data-driven Ws (DDWs) built following the spatial pattern identified by the scan statistic, which can be easily carried out using existing tools such as SaTScan software. The DDWs take both the clustering (or discontinuous) and the intuitive first-law-of-geographic-based spatial dependence into consideration. Aiming at two common purposes in epidemiology studies (ie, estimating the effect value of explanatory variable X and estimating the risk of each spatial unit in disease mapping), the common spatial autoregressive models and the Leroux-prior-based conditional autoregressive (CAR) models were selected to evaluate performance of DDWs, respectively. Both simulation and case studies show that our DDWs achieve considerably better performance than the classic W in datasets with clustering (or discontinuous) spatial dependence. Furthermore, the latest published density-based spatial clustering models, aiming at dealing with such clustering (or discontinuity) spatial dependence in disease mapping, were also compared as references. The DDWs, incorporated into the CAR models, still show considerable advantage, especially in the datasets for common diseases.
引用
- Wang W, Xiao X, Qian J, et al. Reclaiming independence in spatial-clustering datasets: A series of data-driven spatial weights matrices. Stat Med. 2022. PMID: 35347729. doi:10.1002/sim.9395
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。