混合方法系统评价中的五个常见误区:经验教训
本文针对2020年JBI混合方法系统评价方法学修订后发表的17篇声称遵循该方法的系统评价进行前向引文追踪,对照JBI方法学识别偏离之处,归纳出五个常见误区,包括方法学选择依据、合成与整合方法、排除原始混合方法研究、数据转换细节缺失及定量与定性组分缺乏混合,并为未来评价者提供建议。
要点
- 前向引文追踪识别出JBI方法学修订后发表的17篇混合方法系统评价。
- 常见误区包括方法学选择依据不当、合成与整合方法错误、排除原始混合方法研究。
- 其他误区为数据转换过程细节缺失及定量与定性组分缺乏混合。
核心结论
- 本文归纳了混合方法系统评价中五个常见误区,并为未来评价者提供建议以识别和避免方法学偏离。
研究设计与样本
- 通过前向引文追踪识别自JBI混合方法方法学指南修订后发表的17篇系统评价,并对照JBI方法学检查这些评价的方法使用情况以识别偏离。
主要发现
- 识别出的问题涉及选择方法学方法的依据、为回答所提出的评价问题而选择错误的合成与整合方法、排除原始混合方法研究、数据转换过程缺乏细节以及定量与定性组分缺乏混合。
临床怎么用
- 本文旨在帮助考虑开展混合方法系统评价的系统评价者以及混合方法系统评价使用者识别作者倾向偏离方法学的潜在领域。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Mixed methods systematic reviews (MMSRs) combine quantitative and qualitative evidence within a single review. Since the revision of the JBI methodology for MMSRs in 2020, there has been an increasing number of reviews published that claim to follow this approach. A preliminary examination of these indicated that authors frequently deviated from the methodology. This article outlines five common 'pitfalls' associated with undertaking MMSR and provides direction for future reviewers attempting MMSR. METHODS: Forward citation tracking identified 17 reviews published since the revision of the JBI mixed methods methodological guidance. Methods used in these reviews were then examined against the JBI methodology to identify deviations. RESULTS: The issues identified related to the rationale for choosing the methodological approach, an incorrect synthesis and integration approach chosen to answer the review question/s posed, the exclusion of primary mixed methods studies in the review, the lack of detail regarding the process of data transformation, and a lack of 'mixing' of the quantitative and qualitative components. CONCLUSION: This exercise was undertaken to assist systematic reviewers considering conducting an MMSR and MMSR users to identify potential areas where authors tend to deviate from the methodological approach. Based on these findings a series of recommendations are provided.
引用
- Lizarondo L, Stern C, Apostolo J, et al. Five common pitfalls in mixed methods systematic reviews: lessons learned. J Clin Epidemiol. 2022. PMID: 35341946. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.03.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。