简短团体行为干预对约旦叙利亚难民常见精神障碍的有效性:一项随机对照试验
该单盲平行随机对照试验在约旦阿兹拉克难民营筛查410名成年叙利亚难民,按1:1随机分配至团体问题管理加(gPM+)或强化常规照护(EUC)。随访时gPM+组抑郁症状较EUC组下降更多(均差3.69,95%CI 1.90至5.48,p=.001,效应量0.40),焦虑无差异;个人认定问题严重度和不一致管教行为亦改善,PTSD、残疾、悲痛、前驱症状及儿童心理健康无显著差异。
要点
- gPM+组随访时HSCL抑郁评分较EUC组下降更多(均差3.69,95%CI 1.90至5.48,p=.001,效应量0.40)。
- 焦虑评分两组无差异(均差-0.56,95%CI -2.09至0.96,p=.47,效应量-0.03)。
- gPM+组个人认定问题严重度(均差0.88,95%CI 0.07至1.69,p=.03)和不一致管教行为(均差1.54,95%CI 1.03至2.05,p<.001)下降更多。
核心结论
- 在营地叙利亚难民中,简短团体行为干预较常规照护降低抑郁症状、个人认定问题和不一致管教行为,并可能对难民儿童有间接益处。
- 干预对PTSD、残疾或儿童心理问题的作用有限,提示需为难民营环境中的难民开发更有效的治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 单盲、平行随机对照试验,在约旦阿兹拉克难民营筛查410名成年叙利亚难民(300名女性,110名男性)。
- 筛查标准为心理痛苦评分≥16(Kessler心理痛苦量表)和功能受损评分≥17(WHO残疾评估量表)。
- 参与者按1:1随机分配至gPM+或强化常规照护(EUC),EUC包括心理社会服务转介信息。
- 参与者知晓治疗分配,评估者盲法;主要结局为基线、6周和3个月随访时Hopkins症状 checklist-25(HSCL)抑郁和焦虑量表评分,3个月随访为主要结局时间点。
主要发现
- 2019年10月15日至2020年3月2日筛查624名难民,462名(74.0%)筛查阳性,204名分配至gPM+,206名至EUC。
- 随访时gPM+组168名(82.4%)和EUC组189名(91.7%)完成评估。
- 意向性分析显示随访时gPM+组HSCL抑郁量表下降大于EUC组(均差3.69,95%CI 1.90至5.48,p=.001;效应量0.40)。
- 焦虑无组间差异(均差-0.56,95%CI -2.09至0.96,p=.47;效应量-0.03)。
- gPM+组较EUC组个人认定问题严重度(均差0.88,95%CI 0.07至1.69,p=.03)和不一致管教行为(均差1.54,95%CI 1.03至2.05,p<.001)下降更多;PTSD、残疾、悲痛、前驱症状或儿童心理健康结局无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在营地叙利亚难民中,简短团体行为干预较常规照护降低抑郁症状、个人认定问题和不一致管教行为,并可能对难民儿童有间接益处。
- 作者指出,干预对PTSD、残疾或儿童心理问题的作用有限,提示需为难民营环境中的难民开发更有效的治疗。
局限性
- 仅四分之一参与者为男性。
- 个人认定问题、悲痛、前驱精神病性症状、不一致管教行为和儿童心理健康的测量工具尚未在叙利亚人中验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Common mental disorders are frequently experienced by refugees. This study evaluates the impact of a brief, lay provider delivered group-based psychological intervention [Group Problem Management Plus (gPM+)] on the mental health of refugees in a camp, as well as on parenting behavior and children's mental health. METHODS AND FINDINGS: In this single-blind, parallel, randomized controlled trial, 410 adult Syrian refugees (300 females, 110 males) in Azraq Refugee Camp (Jordan) were identified through screening of psychological distress (≥16 on the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale) and impaired functioning (≥17 on the WHO Disability Assessment Schedule). Participants were randomly allocated to gPM+ or enhanced usual care (EUC) involving referral information for psychosocial services on a 1:1 ratio. Participants were aware of treatment allocation, but assessors were blinded to treatment condition. Primary outcomes were scores on the Hopkins Symptom Checklist-25 (HSCL; depression and anxiety scales) assessed at baseline, 6 weeks, and 3 months follow-up as the primary outcome time point. It was hypothesized that gPM+ would result in greater reductions of scores on the HSCL than EUC. Secondary outcomes were disability, posttraumatic stress, personally identified problems, prolonged grief, prodromal psychotic symptoms, parenting behavior, and children's mental health. Between October 15, 2019 and March 2, 2020, 624 refugees were screened for eligibility, 462 (74.0%) screened positive, of whom 204 were assigned to gPM+ and 206 to EUC. There were 168 (82.4%) participants in gPM+ and 189 (91.7%) in EUC assessed at follow-up. Intent-to-treat analyses indicated that at follow-up, participants in gPM+ showed greater reduction on HSCL depression scale than those receiving EUC (mean difference, 3.69 [95% CI 1.90 to 5.48], p = .001; effect size, 0.40). There was no difference between conditions in anxiety (mean difference -0.56, 95% CI -2.09 to 0.96; p = .47; effect size, -0.03). Relative to EUC, participants in gPM+ had greater reductions in severity of personally identified problems (mean difference 0.88, 95% CI 0.07 to 1.69; p = .03), and inconsistent disciplinary parenting (mean difference 1.54, 95% CI 1.03 to 2.05; p < .001). There were no significant differences between conditions for changes in PTSD, disability, grief, prodromal symptoms, or childhood mental health outcomes. Mediation analysis indicated the change in inconsistent disciplinary parenting was associated with reduced attentional (β = 0.11, SE .07; 95% CI .003 to .274) and internalizing (β = 0.08, SE .05; 95% CI .003 to 0.19) problems in children. No adverse events were attributable to the interventions or the trial. Major limitations included only one-quarter of participants being male, and measures of personally identified problems, grief, prodromal psychotic symptoms, inconsistent parenting behavior, and children's mental health have not been validated with Syrians. CONCLUSIONS: In camp-based Syrian refugees, a brief group behavioral intervention led to reduced depressive symptoms, personally identified problems, and disciplinary parenting compared to usual care, and this may have indirect benefits for refugees' children. The limited capacity of the intervention to reduce PTSD, disability, or children's psychological problems points to the need for development of more effective treatments for refugees in camp settings. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Prospectively registered at Australian and New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry: ACTRN12619001386123.
引用
- Bryant RA, Bawaneh A, Awwad M, et al. Effectiveness of a brief group behavioral intervention for common mental disorders in Syrian refugees in Jordan: A randomized controlled trial. PLoS Med. 2022. PMID: 35298469. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1003949
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。