文献速递流行病学与生物统计

纵向有序结局伴吸收态的模型辅助分析

Model-assisted analyses of longitudinal, ordinal outcomes with absorbing states.
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2022-03-07

针对危重住院患者纵向有序结局中吸收态导致比例优势假设可能不成立的问题,文章以VIOLET研究为动机,讨论并对比基于时变优势比参数的多种治疗效应估计量,详述现代建模方法。通过模拟和VIOLET数据分析,展示建模流程、基于模型与模型辅助估计量的相对精度及一致性可能差异。

要点

  • 纵向比例优势模型可简洁汇总患者组间与随时间差异,但吸收态可能违背比例优势假设。
  • 文章讨论并对比基于时变优势比参数的治疗效应估计量及现代建模方法。
  • VIOLET研究中结局为四级有序变量,最低「not alive」态为吸收态,最高「at-home」态近乎吸收。

核心结论

  • 纵向比例优势模型在吸收态存在时比例优势假设可能不成立,需更灵活的纵向模型。
  • 文章对比基于时变优势比参数的治疗效应估计量,并详述现代建模方法。
  • 聚焦累积概率模型参数直接估计,似然方法可自然处理吸收态。
  • 通过模拟和VIOLET数据分析展示建模流程、基于模型与模型辅助估计量的相对精度及一致性可能差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学文章,以VIOLET研究(危重患者维生素D3平行臂随机临床试验)为动机。
  • VIOLET研究结局为四级有序变量,最低「not alive」态为吸收态,最高「at-home」态近乎吸收。
  • 讨论并对比基于时变优势比参数的治疗效应估计量,详述现代建模方法。
  • 通过模拟和VIOLET研究数据分析展示建模流程与估计量性能。

主要发现

  • 纵向比例优势模型可简洁汇总患者组间与随时间差异。
  • 吸收态存在时随访时间参数的比例优势假设很可能被违背。
  • 提出比例优势模型灵活扩展,可用于基于模型推断或模型辅助推断。
  • 模型辅助推断对累积对数优势二分化的异质性建模并汇总获得总体优势比估计量。
  • 聚焦累积概率模型参数直接估计,似然方法自然处理吸收态。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Studies of critically ill, hospitalized patients often follow participants and characterize daily health status using an ordinal outcome variable. Statistically, longitudinal proportional odds models are a natural choice in these settings since such models can parsimoniously summarize differences across patient groups and over time. However, when one or more of the outcome states is absorbing, the proportional odds assumption for the follow-up time parameter will likely be violated, and more flexible longitudinal models are needed. Motivated by the VIOLET Study (Ginde et al), a parallel-arm, randomized clinical trial of Vitamin D3 in critically ill patients, we discuss and contrast several treatment effect estimands based on time-dependent odds ratio parameters, and we detail contemporary modeling approaches. In VIOLET, the outcome is a four-level ordinal variable where the lowest "not alive" state is absorbing and the highest "at-home" state is nearly absorbing. We discuss flexible extensions of the proportional odds model for longitudinal data that can be used for either model-based inference, where the odds ratio estimator is taken directly from the model fit, or for model-assisted inferences, where heterogeneity across cumulative log odds dichotomizations is modeled and results are summarized to obtain an overall odds ratio estimator. We focus on direct estimation of cumulative probability model (CPM) parameters using likelihood-based analysis procedures that naturally handle absorbing states. We illustrate the modeling procedures, the relative precision of model-based and model-assisted estimators, and the possible differences in the values for which the estimators are consistent through simulations and analysis of the VIOLET Study data.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Schildcrout JS, Harrell FE, Heagerty PJ, et al. Model-assisted analyses of longitudinal, ordinal outcomes with absorbing states. Stat Med. 2022. PMID: 35253265. doi:10.1002/sim.9366

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。