指南与共识流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

对COVID-19推荐意见地图的评估发现临床与公共卫生指南存在分歧

An evaluation of the COVID-19 recommendation map identified diverging clinical and public health guidance.
指南 / 共识 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2022-03-24

该研究基于「COVID-19推荐与情境化门户」平台,分析138部COVID-19指南中可操作声明的分歧情况,定义分歧为至少两条可比声明在推荐强度、方向或人群/干预亚组考虑上存在明确判断差异。结果显示85部(62%)指南至少含一条与另一指南分歧的声明,共识别223条分歧声明,归为66个聚类。临床实践声明较公共卫生声明更易在推荐强度或方向上出现分歧,声明在强度上的分歧多于方向,发表时间、所用证据、证据解读及情境化考虑与分歧相关。

要点

  • 138部指南中85部(62%)至少含一条与另一指南分歧的可操作声明。
  • 共识别223条分歧声明,归为66个聚类。
  • 临床实践声明较公共卫生声明更易在强度或方向上分歧,强度分歧多于方向分歧。

核心结论

  • 超过半数(85/138,62%)的受评估指南发布了至少一条分歧声明。
  • 本研究有助于理解发布可比声明的指南间差异类型及与分歧相关的因素。

研究设计与样本

  • 对「COVID-19推荐与情境化门户」平台上 cataloged 的COVID-19指南开发者发布的可操作声明进行内容分析。
  • 分歧定义为至少两条可比可操作声明在推荐强度、方向或人群/干预亚组考虑上存在不同的明确判断。
  • 对分歧声明样本比较指南制定方法,并评估与分歧相关的因素。

主要发现

  • 138部受评估指南中,85部(62%)至少含一条与另一指南分歧的声明。
  • 在这85部指南中识别出223条分歧声明,归为66个聚类;每个聚类针对相同人群、干预和对照或仅相似干预。
  • 临床实践声明较公共卫生声明更易在推荐强度或方向的明确判断上出现分歧。
  • 声明在推荐强度上的分歧多于方向上的分歧。
  • 发表时间、所用证据、证据解读及情境化考虑与分歧相关。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To describe divergence between actionable statements issued by coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) guideline developers cataloged on the "COVID-19 Recommendations and Gateway to Contextualization" platform. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We defined divergence as at least two comparable actionable statements with different explicit judgments of strength, direction, or subgroup consideration of the population or intervention. We applied a content analysis to compare guideline development methods for a sample of diverging statements and to evaluate factors associated with divergence. RESULTS: Of the 138 guidelines evaluated, 85 (62%) contained at least one statement that diverged from another guideline. We identified 223 diverging statements in these 85 guidelines. We grouped statements into 66 clusters. Each cluster addressed the same population, intervention, and comparator group or just similar interventions. Clinical practice statements were more likely to diverge in an explicit judgment of strength or direction compared to public health statements. Statements were more likely to diverge in strength than direction. The date of publication, used evidence, interpretation of evidence, and contextualization considerations were associated with divergence. CONCLUSION: More than half of the assessed guidelines issued at least one diverging statement. This study helps in understanding the types of differences between guidelines issuing comparable statements and factors associated with their divergence.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nasir ZH, Mertz D, Nieuwlaat R, et al. An evaluation of the COVID-19 recommendation map identified diverging clinical and public health guidance. J Clin Epidemiol. 2022. PMID: 35339639. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.03.008

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。