文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

环境健康系统评价中的生物学合理性:GRADE概念论文

Biological plausibility in environmental health systematic reviews: a GRADE concept paper.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2022-02-24

本文分析生物学合理性概念在系统评价与GRADE证据确定性框架中的定位。作者认为该概念主要在直接证据缺失、偏倚风险高、不一致或受限时发挥作用,可分解为「泛化性方面」与「机制性方面」,两者均被GRADE的间接性域所容纳,但如何利用生物学机制知识评估证据间接性仍需进一步研究。

要点

  • 生物学合理性非GRADE证据确定性框架的独立域,主要在直接证据受限时起作用。
  • 生物学合理性包含泛化性方面(实验模型推断至人群的有效性)与机制性方面(生物学机制知识的确定性)。
  • 两方面均被GRADE间接性域容纳,但利用机制知识判断间接性的方法仍需进一步研究。

核心结论

  • 生物学合理性概念包含泛化性方面与机制性方面,两者均被GRADE证据确定性框架的间接性域所容纳,但如何利用生物学机制知识评估系统评价证据的间接性仍需进一步研究。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为GRADE概念论文,通过分析生物学合理性概念在系统评价过程及现有GRADE域下的容纳方式,并讨论10个实验替代示例提出上述概念框架。

主要发现

  • 作者认为生物学合理性主要在关于暴露对关注人群(通常为人类)效应的直接证据缺失、偏倚风险高、不一致或其他方面受限时发挥作用。
  • 在此情况下,研究者转向其他研究设计的证据以得出结论,可将实验动物与体外证据视为目标人群、暴露、对照与结局的「替代」。
  • 通过讨论10个实验替代示例,作者提出生物学合理性概念由「泛化性方面」与「机制性方面」两个主要方面构成。

关键数值与推荐

  • 泛化性方面关注从实验模型推断至人类情景的有效性,与系统评价中外部有效性或间接性评估所问问题相同。
  • 机制性方面关注生物学机制知识的确定性,将在GRADE下为间接性判断提供信息,从而影响总体证据确定性。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文指出,尽管泛化性方面与机制性方面均被GRADE证据确定性框架的间接性域所容纳,仍需进一步研究以确定如何在系统评价证据的间接性评估中使用生物学机制知识。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: "Biological plausibility" is a concept frequently referred to in environmental and public health when researchers are evaluating how confident they are in the results and inferences of a study or evidence review. Biological plausibility is not, however, a domain of one of the most widely used approaches for assessing the certainty of evidence (CoE) which underpins the findings of a systematic review, the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) CoE Framework. OBJECTIVES: Whether the omission of biological plausibility is a potential limitation of the GRADE CoE Framework is a topic that is regularly discussed, especially in the context of environmental health systematic reviews. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We analyze how the concept of "biological plausibility," as applied in the context of assessing certainty of the evidence that supports the findings of a systematic review, is accommodated under the processes of systematic review and the existing GRADE domains. RESULTS: We argue that "biological plausibility" is a concept which primarily comes into play when direct evidence about the effects of an exposure on a population of concern (usually humans) is absent, at high risk of bias, inconsistent, or limited in other ways. In such circumstances, researchers look toward evidence from other study designs to draw conclusions. In this respect, we can consider experimental animal and in vitro evidence as "surrogates" for the target populations, exposures, comparators, and outcomes of actual interest. Through discussion of 10 examples of experimental surrogates, we propose that the concept of biological plausibility consists of two principal aspects: a "generalizability aspect" and a "mechanistic aspect." CONCLUSIONS: The "generalizability aspect" concerns the validity of inferences from experimental models to human scenarios, and asks the same question as does the assessment of external validity or indirectness in systematic reviews. The "mechanistic aspect" concerns certainty in knowledge of biological mechanisms and would inform judgments of indirectness under GRADE, and thus the overall CoE. Although both aspects are accommodated under the indirectness domain of the GRADE CoE Framework, further research is needed to determine how to use knowledge of biological mechanisms in the assessment of indirectness of the evidence in systematic reviews.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Whaley P, Piggott T, Morgan RL, et al. Biological plausibility in environmental health systematic reviews: a GRADE concept paper. J Clin Epidemiol. 2022. PMID: 35219805. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.02.011

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。