国家痴呆指南推荐中的反歧视保护:一项系统综述
该研究系统检索了截至2020年3月4日的多个数据库及2020年4月至9月的谷歌与196个国家卫生网站,纳入44个国家的46部国家痴呆指南。多数指南(39/46;85%)至少提及一项受保护特征,年龄最常被提及(31/46;67%),其次为种族(25/46;54%)。作者建议所有指南为少数群体提供具体循证推荐及实施示例。
要点
- 46部国家痴呆指南中39部(85%)至少提及一项受保护特征,年龄最常被提及(31/46;67%)。
- 指南建议对年轻痴呆患者进行专科评估与支持,评估时考虑文化因素并提供以人为中心的照护。
- 大多数与性别相关的推荐建议不使用性激素治疗男性和女性的认知障碍。
核心结论
- 各国痴呆指南对受保护特征的考虑程度不一,全球约五分之一的国家有痴呆指南。
- 作者建议所有指南为少数群体提供具体的循证推荐及实施示例,以促进痴呆照护的公平性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索CINAHL、PsycINFO、Medline数据库及Guideline International Network图书馆(从建库至2020年3月4日),并于2020年4月至9月检索谷歌及全部196个国家的卫生网站(英文及各官方语言)。
- 纳入标准为提供痴呆推荐、预期由医护人员遵循且经国家政策层面批准的指南,共纳入44个国家的46部指南,其中18部被评为较高质量。
- 采用iCAHE指南质量清单评价质量,对每项受保护特征所识别的推荐进行叙述性整合,优先采用较高质量指南的推荐。
主要发现
- 39/46(85%)的指南至少提及一项受保护特征,识别的推荐涉及年龄、残疾、种族(或文化、族裔、语言)、宗教、性别和性取向。
- 年龄是最常被提及的特征(31/46;67%),其次为种族(或文化、族裔、语言;25/46;54%)。
- 推荐包括对年轻痴呆患者进行专科评估与支持,以及在评估是否患痴呆和提供以人为中心的照护时考虑文化因素。
- 指南建议在提供以人为中心的照护和临终照护时考虑宗教。
- 对于残疾,建议医护人员在评估痴呆时考虑智力残疾和感觉障碍;大多数与性别相关的推荐建议不使用性激素治疗男性和女性的认知障碍;有一部指南提出了一条与性取向相关的推荐。
关键数值与推荐
- 39/46(85%)的指南至少提及一项受保护特征。
- 年龄是最常被提及的特征(31/46;67%),其次为种族(或文化、族裔、语言;25/46;54%)。
- 46部指南中18部被评为较高质量;共纳入44个国家的46部指南。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议所有指南为少数群体提供具体的循证推荐及实施示例。
- 作者认为这可促进痴呆照护的公平性,并有助于确保具有受保护特征的人群也能获得高质量临床服务。
局限性
- 本研究的主要局限性是仅纳入适用于整个国家的国家指南,因此国内存在不同医疗体系的国家的指南可能被排除。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: National dementia guidelines provide recommendations about the most effective approaches to diagnosis and interventions. Guidelines can improve care, but some groups such as people with minority characteristics may be disadvantaged if recommended approaches are the same for everyone. It is not known if dementia guidelines address specific needs related to patient characteristics. The objectives of this review are to identify which countries have national guidelines for dementia and synthesise recommendations relating to protected characteristics, as defined in the UK Equality Act 2010: age, disability, gender identity, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex, and sexual orientation. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We searched CINAHL, PsycINFO, and Medline databases and the Guideline International Network library from inception to March 4, 2020, for dementia guidelines in any language. We also searched, between April and September 2020, Google and the national health websites of all 196 countries in English and in each country's official languages. To be included, guidelines had to provide recommendations about dementia, which were expected to be followed by healthcare workers and be approved at a national policy level. We rated quality according to the iCAHE guideline quality checklist. We provide a narrative synthesis of recommendations identified for each protected characteristic, prioritising those from higher-quality guidelines. Forty-six guidelines from 44 countries met our criteria, of which 18 were rated as higher quality. Most guidelines (39/46; 85%) made at least one reference to protected characteristics, and we identified recommendations relating to age, disability, race (or culture, ethnicity, or language), religion, sex, and sexual orientation. Age was the most frequently referenced characteristic (31/46; 67%) followed by race (or culture, ethnicity, or language; 25/46; 54%). Recommendations included specialist investigation and support for younger people affected by dementia and consideration of culture when assessing whether someone had dementia and providing person-centred care. Guidelines recommended considering religion when providing person-centred and end-of-life care. For disability, it was recommended that healthcare workers consider intellectual disability and sensory impairment when assessing for dementia. Most recommendations related to sex recommended not using sex hormones to treat cognitive impairment in men and women. One guideline made one recommendation related to sexual orientation. The main limitation of this study is that we only included national guidelines applicable to a whole country meaning guidelines from countries with differing healthcare systems within the country may have been excluded. CONCLUSIONS: National guidelines for dementia vary in their consideration of protected characteristics. We found that around a fifth of the world's countries have guidelines for dementia. We have identified areas of good practice that can be considered for future guidelines and suggest that all guidelines provide specific evidence-based recommendations for minority groups with examples of how to implement them. This will promote equity in the care of people affected by dementia and help to ensure that people with protected characteristics also have high-quality clinical services.
引用
- James T, Mukadam N, Sommerlad A, et al. Protection against discrimination in national dementia guideline recommendations: A systematic review. PLoS Med. 2022. PMID: 35015760. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1003860
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。