成人桡骨远端骨折克氏针内固定与石膏固定的比较:DRAFFT2多中心随机临床试验
DRAFFT2多中心随机优效性试验在36家NHS医院纳入500例需手法复位的背侧移位桡骨远端骨折成人,比较手法复位后模制石膏与克氏针内固定加石膏。12个月时PRWE评分两组无统计学显著差异(石膏组n=200,均值21.2(SD 23.1);克氏针组n=195,均值20.7(22.3);校正均值差-0.34(95%CI -4.33至3.66),P=0.87)。结论为克氏针内固定未改善12个月腕功能。
要点
- 36家NHS医院、500例成人桡骨远端背侧移位骨折随机分组:石膏组255例,克氏针组245例。
- 12个月PRWE评分石膏组均值21.2 vs 克氏针组均值20.7,校正均值差-0.34(95%CI -4.33至3.66),P=0.87。
- 前6周因骨折位置丢失需手术固定:石膏组33例(13%)vs 克氏针组1例翻修手术(OR 0.02,95%CI 0.001至0.10)。
核心结论
- 在需手法复位的背侧移位桡骨远端骨折成人中,与石膏相比,克氏针内固定在12个月时未改善腕功能。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心随机临床优效性试验,在英国国家医疗服务体系(NHS)36家医院开展。
- 纳入500例16岁及以上背侧移位桡骨远端骨折成人,手法复位后随机分为模制石膏组255例与手术固定组245例。
- 干预为手法复位加模制石膏 vs 手法复位加克氏针内固定加石膏;石膏应用与克氏针置入细节由治疗外科医生按其常规临床实践决定。
- 主要结局为12个月时患者腕部评估(PRWE)评分(5个疼痛问题与10个功能与失能问题;总分0至100分,0分为最佳,100分为最差)。
主要发现
- 参与者平均年龄60岁,417例(83%)为女性;395例(79%)完成随访。
- 12个月PRWE评分:石膏组(n=200)均值21.2(SD 23.1);克氏针组(n=195)均值20.7(SD 22.3);校正均值差-0.34(95%CI -4.33至3.66),P=0.87,无统计学显著差异。
- 更早时间点未见差异。
- 前6周因骨折位置丢失需手术固定:石膏组33例(13%)vs 克氏针组1例翻修手术(OR 0.02,95%CI 0.001至0.10)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess wrist function, quality of life, and complications in adult patients with a dorsally displaced fracture of the distal radius, treated with either a moulded cast or surgical fixation with K-wires. DESIGN: Multicentre randomised clinical superiority trial, SETTING: 36 hospitals in the UK National Health Service (NHS). PARTICIPANTS: 500 adults aged 16 or over with a dorsally displaced fracture of the distal radius, randomised after manipulation of their fracture (255 to moulded cast; 245 to surgical fixation). INTERVENTIONS: Manipulation and moulded cast was compared with manipulation and surgical fixation with K-wires plus cast. Details of the application of the cast and the insertion of the K-wires were at the discretion of the treating surgeon, according to their normal clinical practice. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome measure was the Patient Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE) score at 12 months (five questions about pain and 10 about function and disability; overall score out of 100 (best score=0 and worst score=100)). Secondary outcomes were PRWE score at three and six months, quality of life, and complications, including the need for surgery due to loss of fracture position in the first six weeks. RESULTS: The mean age of participants was 60 years and 417 (83%) were women; 395 (79%) completed follow-up. No statistically significant difference in the PRWE score was seen at 12 months (cast group (n=200), mean 21.2 (SD 23.1); K-wire group (n=195), mean 20.7 (22.3); adjusted mean difference -0.34 (95% confidence interval -4.33 to 3.66), P=0.87). No difference was seen at earlier time points. In the cast group, 33 (13%) of participants needed surgical fixation for loss of fracture position in the first six weeks compared with one revision surgery in the K-wire group (odds ratio 0.02, 95% confidence interval 0.001 to 0.10). CONCLUSIONS: Among patients with a dorsally displaced distal radius fracture that needed manipulation, surgical fixation with K-wires did not improve patients' wrist function at 12 months compared with a cast. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN registry ISRCTN11980540.
引用
- Costa ML, Achten J, Ooms A, et al. Surgical fixation with K-wires versus casting in adults with fracture of distal radius: DRAFFT2 multicentre randomised clinical trial. BMJ. 2022. PMID: 35045969. doi:10.1136/bmj-2021-068041
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。