文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

给科学竖中指——第二至第四指指长比(2D:4D)是好运的生物标志物吗?一项横断面研究

Giving science the finger-is the second-to-fourth digit ratio (2D:4D) a biomarker of good luck? A cross sectional study.
PubMed 文献 · BMJ · 2021-12-15

该横断面研究在美国高校运动表现实验室纳入176名无影响指长疾病的成年人(74名女性、102名男性),以随机扑克牌牌型作为好运的替代指标,检验2D:4D与好运及体成分的关联。结果发现男性右手经X线测量的2D:4D与扑克牌牌型等级相关性最强(rs=0.28,P=0.004)。作者认为该关联仅由随机机会导致,并据此说明医学与科学研究中的可重复性危机。

要点

  • 2D:4D与部分体成分参数显著相关,但相关性随性别、测量手及测量方法(复印或X线)而变。
  • 男性右手经X线测量的2D:4D与扑克牌牌型等级相关性最强(rs=0.28,P=0.004)。
  • 作者认为2D:4D与好运的关联仅由随机机会导致,并非2D:4D是万能生物标志物的确证证据。

核心结论

  • 作者认为,以较低2D:4D估计的产前睾酮暴露较高会显著增加成年期好运,并在较小程度上调节体成分。
  • 作者指出这些关联仅由随机机会导致,是医学与科学研究可重复性危机的一个「顺手」示例,并非2D:4D是几乎所有事物通用生物标志物的确证证据。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面研究,设置于美国一所大学运动表现实验室,数据收集时间为2015年5月至2017年2月。
  • 纳入176名成年人(74名女性、102名男性),包括大学生、教师和职员,均无影响指长的损伤、疾病或医学状况史。

主要发现

  • 2D:4D与部分体成分参数显著相关(Spearman rs范围-0.26至0.23;P<0.05),但相关性随性别、测量手及2D:4D测量方法(复印或X线)而变化。
  • 观察到的相关性最强的是男性右手经X线测量的2D:4D与扑克牌牌型等级(rs=0.28,P=0.004)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 主要结局指标为2D:4D、可能受雄激素影响的体成分参数(骨矿物质含量、骨密度、体脂百分比)以及好运(以随机抽取扑克牌的牌型作为替代指标)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To explore whether random chance, weak research methodology, or inappropriate reporting can lead to claims of statistically significant (yet, biologically meaningless) biomarker associations, using as a model the relation between a common surrogate of prenatal testosterone exposure, second-to-fourth digit ratio (2D:4D), and a random indicator of good luck. DESIGN: Cross sectional study. SETTING: University sports performance laboratory in the United States. Data were collected from May 2015 to February 2017. PARTICIPANTS: 176 adults (74 women, 102 men), including university students, faculty, and staff with no history of injuries, disease, or medical conditions that would affect digit length. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: 2D:4D, body composition parameters potentially influenced by androgens (bone mineral content, bone mineral density, body fat percentage), and good luck (using poker hands from randomly selected playing cards as a surrogate). RESULTS: 2D:4D significantly correlated with select body composition parameters (Spearman's r s range -0.26 to 0.23; P<0.05), but the correlations varied by sex, participant hand measured, and the method of measuring 2D:4D (by photocopy or radiography). However, the strongest correlation observed was between right hand 2D:4D in men measured by radiograph and poker hand rank (r s=0.28, P=0.004). CONCLUSIONS: Greater prenatal exposure to testosterone, as estimated by a lower 2D:4D, significantly increases good luck in adulthood, and also modulates body composition (albeit to a lesser degree). While these findings are consistent with a wealth of research reporting that 2D:4D is related to many seemingly disparate outcomes, they are not meant to provide confirmatory evidence that 2D:4D is a universal biomarker of nearly everything. Instead, the associations between 2D:4D and good luck are simply due to chance, and provide a "handy" example of the reproducibility crisis within medical and scientific research. Biologically sound hypotheses, pre-registration of trials, strong methodological and statistical analyses, transparent reporting of negative results, and unbiased interpretation of data are all necessary for biomarker studies and other areas of clinical research.

来源:BMJ,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Smoliga JM, Fogaca LK, Siplon JS, et al. Giving science the finger-is the second-to-fourth digit ratio (2D:4D) a biomarker of good luck? A cross sectional study. BMJ. 2021. PMID: 34911738. doi:10.1136/bmj-2021-067849

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。