文献速递医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

开展临床试验参与者随访研究的方法学:范围综述与专家访谈

Methodological approaches for conducting follow-up research with clinical trial participants: a scoping review and expert interviews.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2021-12-27

该范围综述检索Medline、PsycInfo和Web of Science Core Collection,纳入1985至2018年发表、在高收入国家开展的涉及成年参与者的临床试验相关文献,结合2019年3月至5月的29次专家访谈,旨在识别、描述和评价获取试验参与者反馈的研究方法。共纳入23篇文章,其中12项采用定性方法、10项定量、1项混合方法;超过75%的工作在美国和英国开展。结果显示临床试验参与者视角与体验的研究严重不足。

要点

  • 共纳入23篇文章,12项定性、10项定量、1项混合方法,超过75%在美国和英国开展。
  • 招募参与者一般通过主要研究者或研究护士直接联系,或检索去标识患者数据库。
  • 作者使用调查、访谈或焦点小组讨论,工具基于现有验证工具或经专家或患者代表支持新开发验证。

核心结论

  • 据作者所知,这是首个将文献发现与专家访谈三角互证的研究临床试验参与者体验方法学综述。
  • 该综述涵盖多种适应证、试验阶段和研究环境,表明临床试验参与者视角与体验的研究严重不足,令人对现有试验参与者观点与体验认识的总体稳健性存疑。
  • 作者认为研究参与者意见、感知和体验的方法学应适应所关注的测量指标并符合研究人群。

研究设计与样本

  • 范围综述:检索Medline、PsycInfo(通过Ovid)和Web of Science Core Collection电子数据库。
  • 纳入标准:涉及成年参与者、在所选高收入国家开展、1985年至2018年发表于同行评审期刊的临床试验。
  • 2019年3月至5月进行29次专家访谈。
  • 从5994条识别记录中纳入23篇文章。

主要发现

  • 12项研究采用定性方法,10项为定量,1项研究采用混合方法设计。
  • 超过75%的工作在美国和英国开展。
  • 招募参与者一般通过主要研究者或研究护士直接联系,或通过检索去标识患者数据库完成。
  • 作者使用调查、访谈或焦点小组讨论。
  • 所用工具要么基于现有验证工具,要么在专家或患者代表支持下新开发并验证。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为研究参与者意见、感知和体验的方法学应适应所关注的测量指标并符合研究人群。
  • 作者认为使用有效的患者体验数据是评价现有人类受试者研究法律与监管框架从患者视角是否适当的基础。
  • 作者认为此类评价对赋能研究参与者至关重要。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Evidence-based establishment and implementation of best principles, laws and ordinances that regulate clinical research depend on the consultation and involvement of trial participants. Yet, guidance on methodological approaches to obtain trial participants' perspectives is currently missing. This scoping review therefore aimed at identifying, describing and evaluating research approaches to obtain trial participants' feedback on their views and experiences. METHODS: We searched the electronic databases Medline and PsycInfo via Ovid and the Web of Science Core Collection. Clinical trials were included that involved adult participants that were conducted in selected high-income countries and that were published in peer-reviewed journals between 1985 and 2018. In addition, 29 expert interviews were conducted between March and May 2019. RESULTS: Out of 5994 identified records, 23 articles were included in this review. Twelve studies used a qualitative approach, 10 were quantitative and one study used a mixed-method design. More than 75% of all work was conducted in the USA and the UK. The scoping review and the expert interviews highlighted that recruitment of participants was generally done through direct contact by principal investigators and/or study nurses or through searches in de-identified patient databases. Authors used surveys, interviews or focus group discussions. The tools used were either based on existing validated ones or developed and verified de novo with the support of experts and/or patient representatives. CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this is the first methodological literature review of approaches to researching experiences of clinical trial participants where findings were triangulated with expert interviews. Covering a range of indications, trial phases and study settings, it demonstrates that clinical trial participant perspectives and experience is heavily under-researched. This casts doubt on the overall robustness of available insight into trial participants' views and experiences. Our results demonstrate that the methodology for studying participant opinion, perception and experience should be adapted to the measure of interest and conform to the study population. Using valid patient experience data is the basis to evaluate existing legal and regulatory human subject research frameworks for their appropriateness from a patient perspective. Such an evaluation will be critical to empower research participants.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Signorell A, Saric J, Appenzeller-Herzog C, et al. Methodological approaches for conducting follow-up research with clinical trial participants: a scoping review and expert interviews. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34961543. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05866-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。