文献速递真实世界研究与卫生经济临床试验与 GCP

两种诊断策略在乳牙修复体管理中的经济影响:基于试验的经济学评价健康经济分析计划

The economic impact of two diagnostic strategies in the management of restorations in primary teeth: a health economic analysis plan for a trial-based economic evaluation.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2021-11-12

该文为基于CARDEC-03试验(NCT03520309)的健康经济分析计划,拟纳入3至10岁儿童并随机分配至FDI或CARS诊断策略,从社会视角进行2年时间跨度的成本效果与成本效用分析,并利用马尔可夫模型外推至乳牙生命周期。目前主试验数据收集尚未完成,经济学评价尚未开始。

要点

  • 计划开展三项成本效果分析和一项成本效用分析,效果指标包括再干预次数、再干预时间、无需新干预的患者比例及口腔健康相关生活质量变化。
  • 成本效用分析的效果指标为牙相关质量调整生命年(QALYs),并采用5%的贴现率处理成本与效果。
  • 将进行确定性及概率敏感性分析,计算净效益并绘制不同支付意愿阈值下的可接受性曲线。

核心结论

  • 作者假设传统策略(基于FDI)与乳磨牙修复体需要更多替换相关,这些替换可能导致更多再干预,从而在2年后产生更高成本。
  • 微创策略在资源配置上是否比传统策略更高效,仍需考虑健康效果及患者/家长偏好和效用值后方能得出结论。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于CARDEC-03试验(NCT03520309)的经济学评价,纳入3至10岁儿童,随机分配至基于FDI或基于CARS的诊断策略。
  • 检查者使用随机分配的诊断策略评估儿童修复体,并按相同标准推荐治疗。
  • 研究时间跨度为2年,采用社会视角,计算每名儿童24个月的平均成本。
  • 将进行意向性治疗分析,以传统策略(基于FDI)为参照,计算微创策略的各项健康效果差值(∆效果)及相关成本差值(∆成本)。
  • 使用马尔可夫模型将试验结果外推至乳牙生命周期时间跨度,进行长期经济学评价。

主要发现

  • 原文为分析计划,尚未报告经济学评价结果。

关键数值与推荐

  • 三项成本效果分析的效果指标分别为:手术干预次数(主要成本效果分析)、至这些新干预的时间、随访期间无需新干预的患者百分比,以及儿童口腔健康相关生活质量的变化(次要分析)。
  • 成本效用分析的效果指标为牙相关质量调整生命年(QALYs)。
  • 对成本与效果采用5%的贴现率。
  • 将计算净效益,并使用不同支付意愿阈值绘制可接受性曲线。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 主试验仍在进行中,数据收集尚未完成,经济学评价尚未开始。
  • 患者的偏好及由此产生的效用值可能影响关于微创策略经济学方面的最终结论。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Different approaches have been used by dentists to base their decision. Among them, there are the aesthetical issues that may lead to more interventionist approaches. Indeed, using a more interventionist strategy (the World Dental Federation - FDI), more replacements tend to be indicated than using a minimally invasive one (based on the Caries Around Restorations and Sealants-CARS). Since the resources related to the long-term health effects of these strategies have not been explored, the economic impact of using the less-invasive strategy is still uncertain. Thus, this health economic analysis plan aims to describe methodologic approaches for conducting a trial-based economic evaluation that aims to assess whether a minimally invasive strategy is more efficient in allocating resources than the conventional strategy for managing restorations in primary teeth and extrapolating these findings to a longer time horizon. METHODS: A trial-based economic evaluation will be conducted, including three cost-effectiveness analyses (CEA) and one cost-utility analysis (CUA). These analyses will be based on the main trial (CARDEC-03/ NCT03520309 ), in which children aged 3 to 10 were included and randomized to one of the diagnostic strategies (based on FDI or CARS). An examiner will assess children's restorations using the randomized strategy, and treatment will be recommended according to the same criteria. The time horizon for this study is 2 years, and we will adopt the societal perspective. The average costs per child for 24 months will be calculated. Three different cost-effectiveness analyses (CEA) will be performed. For CEAs, the effects will be the number of operative interventions (primary CEA analysis), the time to these new interventions, the percentage of patients who did not need new interventions in the follow-up, and changes in children's oral health-related quality of life (secondary analyses). For CUA, the effect will be tooth-related quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). Intention-to-treat analyses will be conducted. Finally, we will assess the difference when using the minimally invasive strategy for each health effect (∆effect) compared to the conventional strategy (based on FDI) as the reference strategy. The same will be calculated for related costs (∆cost). The discount rate of 5% will be applied for costs and effects. We will perform deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses to handle uncertainties. The net benefit will be calculated, and acceptability curves plotted using different willingness-to-pay thresholds. Using Markov models, a longer-term economic evaluation will be carried out with trial results extrapolated over a primary tooth lifetime horizon. DISCUSSION: The main trial is ongoing, and data collection is still not finished. Therefore, economic evaluation has not commenced. We hypothesize that conventional strategy will be associated with more need for replacements of restorations in primary molars. These replacements may lead to more reinterventions, leading to higher costs after 2 years. The health effects will be a crucial aspect to take into account when deciding whether the minimally invasive strategy will be more efficient in allocating resources than the conventional strategy when considering the management of restorations in primary teeth. Finally, patients/parents preferences and consequent utility values may also influence this final conclusion about the economic aspects of implementing the minimally invasive approach for managing restorations in clinical practice. Therefore, these trial-based economic evaluations may bring actual evidence of the economic impact of such interventions. TRIAL REGISTRATION: NCT03520309 . Registered May 9, 2018. Economic evaluations (the focus of this plan) are not initiated at the moment.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Freitas RD, Moro BLP, Pontes LRA, et al. The economic impact of two diagnostic strategies in the management of restorations in primary teeth: a health economic analysis plan for a trial-based economic evaluation. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34772437. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05722-7

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。