营养研究中用于选择纳入荟萃分析结果的方法:一项元研究
该元研究检索2018年1月至2019年6月MEDLINE和Epistemonikos,随机抽取42篇食品/饮食与健康结局的系统综述(含325项研究,104项随机、221项非随机;14篇有方案),提取其首次荟萃分析中用于选择效应估计值的决策规则及原始研究中所有符合条件的结果。结果显示,29%的方案和69%的综述至少说明了一条选择规则;68%的研究存在至少一种结果多重性。作者建议在设计综述时明确处理多重性的方法。
要点
- 29%的综述方案和69%的综述至少指定了一条选择效应估计值的决策规则。
- 68%的纳入研究存在至少一种结果多重性。
- 作者建议系统综述设计时应明确处理多重性的方法。
核心结论
- 营养研究系统综述的作者应预期纳入的原始研究存在结果多重性,因此推荐在设计综述时明确处理多重性的方法。
研究设计与样本
- 检索MEDLINE和Epistemonikos(2018年1月至2019年6月),纳入食品/饮食与健康结局关联的系统综述与荟萃分析,随机抽样后提取首次(索引)荟萃分析的选择规则及原始研究中所有符合条件的结果。
- 共纳入42篇系统综述(含325项研究:104项随机、221项非随机),其中14篇有方案。
主要发现
- 在29%的综述方案和69%的综述中,作者至少指定了一条决策规则以在多个可用效应估计值中选择。
- 在索引荟萃分析纳入的研究中,68%存在至少一种类型的结果多重性。
关键数值与推荐
- 29%的综述方案至少指定了一条选择效应估计值的决策规则。
- 69%的综述至少指定了一条选择效应估计值的决策规则。
- 68%的纳入研究存在至少一种结果多重性。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议在设计综述时明确处理多重性的方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate how often review authors encounter multiple results from included studies that are eligible for inclusion in a particular meta-analysis, and how often methods to select results are specified. METHODS: MEDLINE and Epistemonikos were searched (January 2018-June 2019) to identify systematic reviews with meta-analysis of the association between food/diet and health-related outcomes. A random sample of these reviews was selected, and for the first presented (index) meta-analysis, rules used to select effect estimates to include in this meta-analysis were extracted from the reviews and their protocols. All effect estimates from the primary studies that were eligible for inclusion in the index meta-analyses were extracted (e.g., when a study report presented effect estimates for blood pressure at 3 weeks and 6 weeks, both unadjusted and adjusted for covariates, and all were eligible for inclusion in a meta-analysis of the effect of red meat consumption on blood pressure, we extracted all estimates, and classified the study as having "multiplicity of results"). RESULTS: Forty-two systematic reviews with 325 studies (104 randomized, 221 non-randomized) were included; 14 reviews had a protocol. In 29% of review protocols and 69% of reviews, authors specified at least one decision rule to select effect estimates when multiple were available. In 68% of studies included in the index meta-analyses, there was at least one type of multiplicity of results. CONCLUSIONS: Authors of systematic reviews of nutrition studies should anticipate encountering multiplicity of results in the included primary studies. Specification of methods to handle multiplicity when designing reviews is therefore recommended.
引用
- Kanukula R, McKenzie JE, Bero L, et al. Methods used to select results to include in meta-analyses of nutrition research: A meta-research study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021. PMID: 34780979. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.11.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。