在评估促进卒中后心理社会健康的复杂干预随机对照试验中,对照组感知到的研究诱导影响:一项过程评估
该过程评估基于一项多中心卒中康复随机对照试验,对对照组15名参与者进行叙事半结构化访谈,探讨评估访谈对对照组调整过程的感知影响。结果显示影响因人而异,部分参与者感到获得控制感和应对能力,部分依赖原有个人能力且访谈未产生影响。作者认为评估访谈可能影响调整过程,是复杂干预试验中随时间测量干预效果的严重问题,应充分评估和描述常规照护对照组。
要点
- 对照组15名参与者接受叙事半结构化访谈,分析采用Ricoeur的解释理论。
- 评估访谈对对照组调整过程的影响差异很大,部分参与者感到获得控制感和应对能力。
- 作者认为应充分评估和描述常规照护对照组,仅告知参与者所接受的治疗可能抵消稀释组间差异的潜力。
核心结论
- 随机对照试验的评估访谈可能影响调整过程,是康复研究中复杂干预试验随时间测量干预效果的严重问题。
- 为保持严谨性,应充分评估和描述常规照护对照组。
- 仅告知参与者所分配接受的治疗可能抵消稀释试验两组间差异的潜力。
研究设计与样本
- 一项多中心卒中康复随机对照试验的过程评估,该试验旨在检验基于对话的心理社会干预以促进卒中幸存者的心理社会健康和调整。
- 对照组15名参与者参与叙事半结构化访谈,分析以Ricoeur的解释理论为指导。
主要发现
- 评估访谈对对照组参与者调整过程的感知研究诱导影响差异很大。
- 评估访谈促进了部分参与者的控制感和应对能力。
- 其他参与者的陈述表明其依赖现有个人能力应对和调整,评估访谈对其应对能力或调整过程未产生任何影响。
- 识别出五个主题,说明评估访谈在对照组中起安全网作用、增强意识和理解、鼓励寻求支持、提供宣泄失望的机会,或无论如何都未产生任何影响。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,为保持严谨性,应充分评估和描述常规照护对照组。
- 作者认为,仅告知参与者所分配接受的治疗可能抵消稀释试验两组间差异的潜力。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A commonly applied control condition in trials evaluating complex interventions in rehabilitation research is "usual care." The main challenge is to ensure that the control group receives genuine usual care as delivered in everyday clinical practice. The assessment interviews and dialogues with the data collectors may influence the control group participants' reflections on their condition and adjustments. This represents a threat to the internal validity of the trial. Thus, the aim of this study was to explore the perceived study-induced influence of assessment interviews on the adjustment of the members of a control group in a randomized clinical trial. The aim of the trial was to test a dialogue-based psychosocial intervention aiming at promoting the psychosocial well-being and adjustment of stroke survivors. METHODS: Fifteen participants in the control group of a multicenter stroke rehabilitation trial participated in narrative semi-structured interviews. Ricoeur's interpretation theory guided the analysis. RESULTS: The perceived study-induced influence of the assessment interviews on the adjustment process of members of the control group varied considerably. The results demonstrated that the assessment interviews facilitated some participants' feelings of control and their ability to cope. Other participants' statements indicate that they relied on their existing personal capacity to cope and adjust and that the assessment interviews did not make any difference either on their coping ability or on their process of adjustment. Five themes were identified that described the perceived study-induced influence of the assessment interviews in the control group. The themes illustrated that the assessments served as a safety net, enhanced awareness and understanding, encouraged seeking support, allowed the opportunity to vent disappointment, or did not make any difference either way. CONCLUSIONS: RCT assessment interviews may influence the adjustment process and represent a serious problem in measuring interventions over time in trials of complex interventions in rehabilitation research. To uphold rigor and stringency, the usual care control conditions should be thoroughly assessed and described. Informing participants only about the treatment they were allocated to receive might counteract the potential to dilute the difference between the two arms of the trial. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02338869. Registered on October 4, 2014.
引用
- Mangset M, Kitzmüller G, Evju AS, et al. Perceived study-induced influence on the control group in a randomized controlled trial evaluating a complex intervention to promote psychosocial well-being after stroke: a process evaluation. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34838094. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05765-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。