让图书馆员与信息专家参与系统综述同行评审:一项随机对照试验方案
该方案计划以投稿至BMJ和BMJ Open的150篇系统综述稿件为随机化单位,开展实用性随机对照试验,评估增加图书馆员/信息专家作为方法学同行评审员对检索报告质量(PRISMA-S 4个条目)和偏倚风险(ROBIS领域2的4个信号问题)的影响。主要结局为干预组与对照组首次修回稿中充分报告检索的比例差异,以及高、低、不明确偏倚风险稿件比例的差异。
要点
- 以150篇系统综述稿件为随机化单位,评估图书馆员/信息专家作为方法学评审员的效果。
- 主要结局为首次修回稿中充分报告检索的比例及高、低、不明确偏倚风险稿件比例的组间差异。
- 若干预显示对检索报告或偏倚有影响,可能提示期刊编辑需与图书馆员和信息专家合作开展方法学同行评审。
核心结论
- 若干预显示对检索报告或偏倚有影响,可能提示期刊编辑需与图书馆员和信息专家合作开展方法学同行评审。
研究设计与样本
- 实用性随机对照试验,以150篇投稿至BMJ和BMJ Open的系统综述稿件为随机化单位。
- 纳入报告已完成系统综述及相关综述类型并已送同行评审的稿件。
- 干预组每篇稿件按各期刊标准做法额外邀请一名图书馆员/信息专家作为同行评审员。
主要发现
- 主要结局为首次修回稿中充分报告检索的比例在干预组与对照组间的差异。
- 主要结局还包括首次修回稿中高、低、不明确偏倚风险稿件比例在干预组与对照组间的差异。
- 评估采用PRISMA-S的4个条目依从性和ROBIS领域2的4个信号问题的评估者判断,双人重复评估。
- 评估前去除稿件的识别信息。
关键数值与推荐
- 报告质量以PRISMA-S的4个条目依从性评估。
- 偏倚风险以ROBIS领域2的4个信号问题评估。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Problems continue to exist with the reporting quality and risk of bias in search methods and strategies in systematic reviews and related review types. Peer reviewers who are not familiar with what is required to transparently and fully report a search may not be prepared to review the search components of systematic reviews, nor may they know what is likely to introduce bias into a search. Librarians and information specialists, who have expertise in searching, may offer specialized knowledge that would help improve systematic review search reporting and lessen risk of bias, but they are underutilized as methodological peer reviewers. METHODS: This study will evaluate the effect of adding librarians and information specialists as methodological peer reviewers on the quality of search reporting and risk of bias in systematic review searches. The study will be a pragmatic randomized controlled trial using 150 systematic review manuscripts submitted to BMJ and BMJ Open as the unit of randomization. Manuscripts that report on completed systematic reviews and related review types and have been sent for peer review are eligible. For each manuscript randomized to the intervention, a librarian/information specialist will be invited as an additional peer reviewer using standard practices for each journal. First revision manuscripts will be assessed in duplicate for reporting quality and risk of bias, using adherence to 4 items from PRISMA-S and assessors' judgements on 4 signaling questions from ROBIS Domain 2, respectively. Identifying information from the manuscripts will be removed prior to assessment. DISCUSSION: The primary outcomes for this study are quality of reporting as indicated by differences in the proportion of adequately reported searches in first revision manuscripts between intervention and control groups and risk of bias as indicated by differences in the proportions of first revision manuscripts with high, low, and unclear bias. If the intervention demonstrates an effect on search reporting or bias, this may indicate a need for journal editors to work with librarians and information specialists as methodological peer reviewers. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Open Science Framework. Registered on June 17, 2021, at https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/W4CK2 .
引用
- Rethlefsen ML, Schroter S, Bouter LM, et al. Improving peer review of systematic reviews by involving librarians and information specialists: protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34763714. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05738-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。