指南与共识医学教育与科研方法

牙髓治疗方式核心结局指标集(COSET)开发方案:一项国际共识流程

A protocol for the Development of Core Outcome Sets for Endodontic Treatment modalities (COSET): an international consensus process.
指南 / 共识 · Trials · 2021-11-17

该方案拟通过系统综述筛选1990至2020年牙髓治疗结局相关临床研究,结合患者半结构化访谈与在线德尔菲法及虚拟共识会议,由患者、牙医、牙髓病专家、教师、研究者、学生和政策制定者等多方利益相关者共同制定包含患者报告结局与临床医生中心指标的牙髓治疗核心结局指标集。

要点

  • 拟制定涵盖患者报告结局与临床医生中心指标的牙髓治疗核心结局指标集。
  • 采用系统综述、患者访谈、在线德尔菲法与虚拟共识会议相结合的共识流程。
  • 利益相关者包括患者、牙医、牙髓病专家、教师、研究者、学生和政策制定者。

核心结论

  • 该共识流程旨在采用严谨方法制定与利益相关者相关的牙髓治疗核心结局指标集,结果将与参与者及核心结局指标集使用者分享,并积极分享给临床指南制定者、研究资助者及普通牙科与牙髓病学期刊编辑以提高采用率。

研究设计与样本

  • 拟定核心结局指标集的方案:系统综述筛选1990至2020年发表的牙髓治疗结局相关临床研究以识别报告结局(包括测量时间和方法)。
  • 共识流程包括患者半结构化访谈、在线德尔菲法(必要时进行第三轮)及交互式虚拟共识会议,邀请患者、全科牙医、牙髓病专家、牙髓病学教师、临床研究者、学生和政策制定者等异质性利益相关者参与。
  • 德尔菲法第一轮后参与者可补充其认为相关但未列入的结局,第二轮提供反馈并要求再次优先排序,若达成共识则在在线会议上讨论剩余结局并按既定共识规则确定纳入。
  • 试验注册号:COMET 1879,注册日期2021年5月21日。

关键数值与推荐

  • 核心结局指标集将包括患者报告结局和临床医生中心测量指标,用于各种牙髓治疗方式的临床研究和实践。
  • 患者通过交互式访谈确定其重视并认为应纳入核心结局指标集的结局。
  • 德尔菲法第一轮后参与者可添加其认为相关但未列入的结局;第二轮提供反馈并要求再次优先排序;若未达成共识则进行第三轮并随后召开在线会议。
  • 共识规则为定义的结局纳入共识规则,剩余结局在在线会议上讨论并达成一致。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The outcome of endodontic treatment is generally assessed using a range of patient and clinician-centred, non-standardised clinical and radiographic outcome measures. This makes it difficult to synthesise evidence for systematic analysis of the literature and the development of clinical guidelines. Core outcome sets (COS) represent a standardised list of outcomes that should be measured and reported in all clinical studies in a particular field. Recently, clinical researchers and guideline developers have focussed on the need for the integration of a patient-reported COS with clinician-centred measures. This study aims to develop a COS that includes both patient-reported outcomes and clinician-centred measures for various endodontic treatment modalities to be used in clinical research and practice. METHODS: To identify reported outcomes (including when and how they are measured), systematic reviews and their included clinical studies, which focus on the outcome of endodontic treatment and were published between 1990 and 2020 will be screened. The COSs will be defined by a consensus process involving key stakeholders using semi-structured interviews and an online Delphi methodology followed by an interactive virtual consensus meeting. A heterogeneous group of key 'stakeholders' including patients, general dental practitioners, endodontists, endodontic teachers, clinical researchers, students and policy-makers will be invited to participate. Patients will establish, via interactive interviews, which outcomes they value and feel should be included in a COS. In the Delphi process, other stakeholders will be asked to prioritise outcomes identified from the literature and patient interviews and will have the opportunity at the end of the first round to add outcomes that are not included, but which they consider relevant. Feedback will be provided in the second round, when participants will be asked to prioritise the list again. If consensus is reached, the remaining outcomes will be discussed at an online meeting and agreement established via defined consensus rules of outcome inclusion. If consensus is not reached after the second round, a third round will be conducted with feedback, followed by the online meeting. Following the identification of a COS, we will proceed to identify how and when these outcomes are measured. DISCUSSION: Using a rigorous methodology, the proposed consensus process aims to develop a COS for endodontic treatment that will be relevant to stakeholders. The results of the study will be shared with participants and COS users. To increase COS uptake, it will also be actively shared with clinical guideline developers, research funders and the editors of general dental and endodontology journals. TRIAL REGISTRATION: COMET 1879. 21 May 2021.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. El Karim IA, Duncan HF, Cushley S, et al. A protocol for the Development of Core Outcome Sets for Endodontic Treatment modalities (COSET): an international consensus process. Trials. 2021. PMID: 34789318. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05764-x

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。