社区过渡项目对创伤性脊髓损伤成人生活质量与再入院影响的系统综述
该系统综述检索7个数据库至2020年3月,纳入26项研究,评估社区过渡项目对18-65岁新发创伤性脊髓损伤成人生活质量与再入院的影响。中等水平证据支持同伴指导的正面效果,低水平证据支持远程医疗、教育、独立生活和作业治疗干预的正面效果;同伴指导在再入院结局上证据最强,4项研究中有3项显示统计学显著改善。总体高质量证据匮乏且结果不一。
要点
- 中等水平证据支持同伴指导改善创伤性脊髓损伤成人的生活质量与再入院结局。
- 低水平证据支持远程医疗、教育、独立生活和作业治疗干预的正面效果。
- 仅同伴指导、远程医疗和患者导航报告了再入院结局,其中同伴指导证据最强。
核心结论
- 总体高质量证据匮乏且特征不够相似,难以比较不同项目参与带来的获益。
- 同伴指导在各干预类型中支持证据最强,4项含再入院结局的研究中3项显示统计学显著改善。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索PubMed、Embase、CINAHL、Google Scholar、Joanna Briggs Institute数据库、OTseeker和PEDro共7个数据库及参考文献,检索至2020年3月。
- 初检识别4694项研究,最终纳入26项符合标准的研究。
- 两名评价者独立筛选和评估研究,分歧由第三名评价者解决,采用Let Evidence Guide Every Decision工具对每种干预类型的证据体进行分级。
主要发现
- 纳入研究按主要干预分组:同伴指导(n=8)、远程医疗(n=5)、教育(n=5)、独立生活(n=3)、作业治疗(n=1)、咨询(n=1)、患者导航(n=4)。
- 中等水平证据支持同伴指导的正面效果;低水平证据表明远程医疗、教育、独立生活和作业治疗干预具有正面效果。
- 仅同伴指导、远程医疗和患者导航报告了再入院结局,其中同伴指导证据最多,4项含再入院结局的研究中3项显示统计学显著改善。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准:评估旨在支持18-65岁新发创伤性脊髓损伤个体从亚急性期护理过渡到社区的干预措施,并报告生活质量或再入院结局数据。
- 证据分级:同伴指导为中等水平证据;远程医疗、教育、独立生活和作业治疗为低水平证据。
- 再入院结局:同伴指导4项研究中3项显示统计学显著改善。
临床怎么用
- 对18-65岁新发创伤性脊髓损伤成人从亚急性期过渡到社区时,可优先考虑同伴指导干预,因其证据水平最高且再入院结局改善最一致。
- 远程医疗、教育、独立生活和作业治疗可作为低水平证据支持的辅助过渡策略。
- 选择干预时需注意整体高质量证据不足且结果不一,应结合个体情况谨慎决策。
局限性
- 高质量证据匮乏,且各研究特征不够相似,难以比较不同项目的获益。
- 已开展的高质量研究结果不一。
- 需进一步研究明确对特定亚组最有效的干预成分。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effects of community transition programs for adults with traumatic spinal cord injury (tSCI) on hospital readmissions and quality of life (QOL). DATA SOURCES: Seven databases (PubMed, Embase, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Google Scholar, the Joanna Briggs Institute database, OTseeker, and PEDro) and reference lists of relevant articles were searched from inception through March 2020. STUDY SELECTION: Original research studies were included that (1) evaluated interventions designed to support individuals aged 18-65 years with newly acquired tSCI in navigating the transition from subacute care to the community and (2) reported data for QOL or hospital readmission outcomes. Searches identified 4694 studies, and 26 of these met the selection criteria. DATA EXTRACTION: Two reviewers independently screened and assessed all studies, extracting information about study type, methodological strengths and weaknesses, participant and intervention characteristics, comparator, and significant results. Any discrepancies were resolved by a third reviewer. DATA SYNTHESIS: Studies were grouped according to primary intervention: peer mentoring (n=8), telehealth (n=5), education (n=5), independent living (n=3), occupational therapy (n=1), counseling (n=1), and patient navigation (n=4). Reviewers used the Let Evidence Guide Every Decision appraisal tool rubric to grade the body of evidence for each intervention type. Moderate level evidence supports the positive effects of peer mentoring, and low level evidence indicates positive effects of telehealth, education, independent living, and occupational therapy interventions. Peer mentoring, telehealth, and patient navigation were the only intervention types that included hospital readmission outcomes. Of these, peer mentoring had the most evidence, with 3 of the 4 studies that included hospital readmission outcomes demonstrating statistically significant improvements. CONCLUSIONS: In general, there is a paucity of high-quality evidence with sufficiently similar characteristics to demonstrate and compare benefits from program participation. When high quality studies have been conducted, they have obtained mixed results. Of the different intervention types, peer mentorship has the strongest supporting evidence. Further research is needed to identify specific intervention components that are most effective in improving QOL and reducing hospital readmission for specific subgroups of individuals recovering from tSCI.
引用
- Tschoepe R, Benfield A, Posey R, et al. A Systematic Review of the Effects of Community Transition Programs on Quality of Life and Hospital Readmissions for Adults With Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2021. PMID: 34464608. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2021.08.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。