文献速递神经康复

日常临床决策与神经康复技术采纳的质性研究

A day in the life: a qualitative study of clinical decision-making and uptake of neurorehabilitation technology.
PubMed 文献 · J Neuroeng Rehabil · 2021-07-28

本研究采用现象学质性方法,由3名作业治疗师和2名物理治疗师撰写临床决策片段,描述9例神经康复患者的治疗技术使用决策。经演绎编码与汇总内容分析,最突出的五个决定因素为相对优势、患者个人属性、临床医生知识信念、设备复杂性及组织准备度;治疗师认为康复技术常因缺乏功能训练相关性而相对不利,且设计未充分考虑患者多维度属性。

要点

  • 康复技术相对传统治疗缺乏功能训练相关性,被治疗师视为相对劣势
  • 设备设计常忽视患者诊断、目标及身体认知限制等多维个人属性
  • 设备复杂性与时间设置负担降低治疗师使用意愿,既往培训可提升舒适度

核心结论

  • 尽管数十年设计工作旨在创建临床有用的康复技术,许多技术仍缺乏与住院神经康复临床转化需求的兼容性。
  • 新技术继续妨碍以简单日常物品为媒介的手法治疗的即时性、多功能性和功能性。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用现象学质性方法,3名作业治疗师和2名物理治疗师在一家鼓励技术使用的大型康复医院工作。
  • 治疗师根据书面提示撰写片段,描述其与9例患者(4例卒中、2例创伤性脑损伤、1例脊髓损伤、1例多发性硬化)治疗会话中的康复技术使用决策。
  • 使用源自康复技术文献和整合实施研究框架(CFIR)的17个构念进行演绎质性分析编码,并采用汇总内容分析合成数据。

主要发现

  • 记录的构念中最突出的五个来自CFIR决定因素:相对优势、患者个人属性、临床医生对设备/干预的知识与信念、设备复杂性(包括时间和设置)、组织准备度。
  • 治疗师将候选康复技术描述为相比常规治疗具有相对劣势,因缺乏与功能训练的相关性。
  • 康复技术设计常未能考虑患者多方面的个人属性,包括诊断、目标以及身体和认知限制。
  • 临床医生对康复技术的舒适度因既往培训而增加,但因感知的设备复杂性而降低。
  • 治疗师收集、设置和使用康复技术的时间有限。

临床怎么用

  • 选择康复技术时应优先评估其与功能训练的相关性,避免因相对劣势而影响治疗即时性与功能性。
  • 使用前需综合考虑患者诊断、目标及身体认知限制等多维个人属性,个体化适配技术。
  • 通过既往培训提升临床医生对设备的知识与信念,同时简化设备设置以降低感知复杂性。
  • 合理安排治疗师收集、设置和使用技术的时间,并评估组织准备度以促进技术采纳。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Neurorehabilitation engineering faces numerous challenges to translating new technologies, but it is unclear which of these challenges are most limiting. Our aim is to improve understanding of rehabilitation therapists' real-time decision-making processes on the use of rehabilitation technology (RT) in clinical treatment. METHODS: We used a phenomenological qualitative approach, in which three OTs and two PTs employed at a major, technology-encouraging rehabilitation hospital wrote vignettes from a written prompt describing their RT use decisions during treatment sessions with nine patients (4 with stroke, 2 traumatic brain injury, 1 spinal cord injury, 1 with multiple sclerosis). We then coded the vignettes using deductive qualitative analysis from 17 constructs derived from the RT literature and the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR). Data were synthesized using summative content analysis. RESULTS: Of the constructs recorded, the five most prominent are from CFIR determinants of: (i) relative advantage, (ii) personal attributes of the patients, (iii) clinician knowledge and beliefs of the device/intervention, (iv) complexity of the devices including time and setup, and (v) organizational readiness to implement. Therapists characterized candidate RT as having a relative disadvantage compared to conventional treatment due to lack of relevance to functional training. RT design also often failed to consider the multi-faceted personal attributes of the patients, including diagnoses, goals, and physical and cognitive limitations. Clinicians' comfort with RT was increased by their previous training but was decreased by the perceived complexity of RT. Finally, therapists have limited time to gather, setup, and use RT. CONCLUSIONS: Despite decades of design work aimed at creating clinically useful RT, many lack compatibility with clinical translation needs in inpatient neurologic rehabilitation. New RT continue to impede the immediacy, versatility, and functionality of hands-on therapy mediated treatment with simple everyday objects.

来源:J Neuroeng Rehabil,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Celian C, Swanson V, Shah M, et al. A day in the life: a qualitative study of clinical decision-making and uptake of neurorehabilitation technology. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2021. PMID: 34321036. doi:10.1186/s12984-021-00911-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。