腰椎手术后的康复:法国临床实践推荐
该法国指南由SOFMER方法制定,针对无神经损伤的腰椎手术患者,围绕术前术后康复价值、时机、类型、监督下康复、仪器康复、患者教育及椎间盘切除、融合、椎间盘置换的补充干预提出推荐。文献综述仅找到60篇文章,部分问题无文献支持,经e-Delphi后最终保留20条专家共识推荐。
要点
- 推荐适用于无神经损伤的腰椎手术患者,不涵盖椎管狭窄减压。
- 部分康复问题缺乏文献证据,推荐主要基于专家意见。
- 最终形成20条多学科专家共识推荐,供临床决策参考。
核心结论
- 该指南为腰椎手术康复提供重要共识知识,尽管许多推荐仅基于专家意见而非已发表证据。
研究设计与样本
- 采用SOFMER方法制定推荐:指导委员会定义手术类型和主要问题,科学委员会进行文献综述并分级证据,提出首版推荐,经全国物理与康复医学大会讨论,再用跨专业专家e-Delphi法最终确定推荐并达成多学科共识。
主要发现
- 文献综述识别了60篇文章,但部分问题无文献涉及。
- 科学委员会提出23条推荐初版,大会未能回答所有问题或达成全部共识。
- 经三步e-Delphi后,保留20条达成专家共识的推荐。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐仅适用于无神经损伤的患者。
- 最终保留20条推荐,专家共识达成。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生可参考这20条共识推荐,对无神经损伤的腰椎手术患者进行康复决策。
- 需注意部分推荐基于专家意见,应用时应结合具体临床情况。
局限性
- 许多推荐仅依赖专家意见,而非已发表的证据。
- 文献综述中部分问题无文章涉及,证据基础有限。
- 推荐不适用于有神经损伤的患者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Indications and techniques of rehabilitation differ widely across types of lumbar surgery, including timing (before or after surgery) and prescriptions (surgeons but also medical or paramedical professionals). OBJECTIVES: This project aimed to build consensual recommendations for practice in this context. METHODS: The SOFMER methodology was used to establish recommendations for physical medicine and rehabilitation: a steering committee defined the types of lumbar surgery involved and developed the main questions to be addressed; a scientific committee performed a literature review for grading evidence and proposed the first version of recommendations, which were discussed during a dedicated session at the national Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine congress; then an e-Delphi method with cross-professional experts was used to finalise recommendations and reach a multidisciplinary consensus. RESULTS: The main questions developed were the value of rehabilitation before and after surgery, timing and type of rehabilitation, benefit of supervision and instrumental rehabilitation, value of patient education, and complementary interventions concerning rehabilitation for discectomy, fusion, and disc prosthesis (excluding decompression for spinal stenosis). The literature review identified 60 articles, but for several of the questions, no article in the literature addressed the issue. The multidisciplinary scientific committee analysed the literature and addressed the questions to propose the first version of a set of 23 recommendations. The congress session failed to answer all questions or to reach consensus for all items. After a three-step e-Delphi, 20 recommendations were retained, for which consensus among experts was reached. The recommendations are applicable only to patients without a neurological lesion. CONCLUSIONS: These recommendations provide important and consensual knowledge to assist clinicians in decision-making for rehabilitation in lumbar surgery. Despite many of the recommendations relying exclusively on expert opinion rather than published evidence, this approach is an important advance to improve concordance among healthcare professionals.
引用
- Dupeyron A, Ribinik P, Rannou F, et al. Rehabilitation and lumbar surgery: the French recommendations for clinical practice. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2021. PMID: 34192564. doi:10.1016/j.rehab.2021.101548
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。