基于网络的直接面向用户转移训练项目的有效性:一项随机对照试验
本研究为随机对照试验,纳入72名能够独立完成侧向挪动转移的脊髓损伤或疾病全职轮椅使用者,比较即时网络转移训练与等待名单对照组的转移质量。结果显示,重复TAI-Q自评可能改善转移质量,网络训练具有附加效应,训练前TAI-Q评分较低和肩痛较多者最可能获益。
要点
- 重复TAI-Q自评可能改善转移质量,网络训练具有附加效应
- 训练前TAI-Q评分较低和肩痛较多者最可能从训练中获益
- 网络转移训练可在家庭环境中进行,有望降低损伤风险并避免面对面训练障碍
核心结论
- 重复TAI-Q自评可能有助于改善转移质量,基于网络的训练具有附加效应。
- 轮椅使用者可能从家庭环境中的转移训练和转移质量自评中获益。
- 这有可能在避免面对面训练障碍的同时降低损伤风险。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,参与者随机分为即时干预组(IIG)或等待名单对照组(WLCG),后者在延迟6个月后接受训练。
- 便利样本为全职轮椅使用者共72人,其中IIG组34人、WLCG组38人用于组间分析,48人用于组内合并分析。
- 参与者为能独立完成侧向挪动转移的脊髓损伤或疾病患者。
- 干预为自定进度的基于网络的转移训练模块。
- 主要结局为基线、基线后1个月和6个月(仅WLCG)、训练后即刻及训练后1个月的TAI-Q评分,该问卷为18项自评,覆盖转移质量的多个方面。
主要发现
- IIG组TAI-Q评分从基线6.91±0.98显著提高至训练后1个月的7.79±1.12(P<.001)。
- WLCG组从基线至基线后1个月评估也从6.52±1.13提高至7.00±1.09(P=.014),可能源于TAI-Q自评的学习效应。
- 从基线至1个月,IIG与WLCG之间随时间变化的程度无显著差异(P=.169)。
- WLCG组在训练后仍可见TAI-Q评分的显著改善(P<.001)。
- 训练前TAI-Q评分较低和肩痛较多者最可能从训练中获益。
关键数值与推荐
- TAI-Q为18项自评问卷,覆盖转移质量的多个方面。
- IIG组TAI-Q评分从6.91±0.98提高至7.79±1.12(P<.001)。
- WLCG组TAI-Q评分从6.52±1.13提高至7.00±1.09(P=.014)。
- IIG与WLCG从基线至1个月的变化程度无显著差异(P=.169)。
- WLCG组训练后TAI-Q评分仍有显著改善(P<.001)。
临床怎么用
- 可考虑为能独立完成侧向挪动转移的脊髓损伤或疾病全职轮椅使用者提供基于网络的转移训练。
- 可在家庭环境中结合TAI-Q自评进行转移质量评估与训练。
- 对训练前TAI-Q评分较低和肩痛较多的轮椅使用者可优先考虑转移训练。
局限性
- WLCG组基线至1个月的改善可能源于TAI-Q自评的学习效应。
- 从基线至1个月,IIG与WLCG之间随时间变化的程度无显著差异(P=.169)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the effectiveness of a web-based, direct-to-user transfer training program in improving transfer quality and maintaining improvements for up to 1 month after training as compared with a control group. DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial with participants randomized to an immediate intervention group (IIG) or waitlist control group (WLCG) that received the training after a 6-month delay. SETTING: Wherever the participants accessed the web-based training, likely the home environment. PARTICIPANTS: Convenience sample of full-time wheelchair users (N=72; IIG, n=34; WLCG, n=38 for between-group analysis, n=48 for combined within-group analysis) with spinal cord injury or disorder who were able to independently perform a lateral scoot transfer. INTERVENTIONS: Self-paced, web-based transfer training module. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Transfer Assessment Instrument Questionnaire (TAI-Q) score at baseline, 1 month, and 6 months postbaseline (WLCG only), immediately posttraining, and 1 month posttraining. The TAI-Q is an 18-item self-assessment that covers several aspects of a quality transfer. RESULTS: The IIG significantly increased particpants' baseline TAI-Q score from 6.91±0.98 to 7.79±1.12 (P<.001) by 1 month posttraining. The WLCG also increased from baseline to the 1-month postbaseline assessment (from 6.52±1.13 to 7.00±1.09; P=.014), potentially from learning effects secondary to self-assessment with the TAI-Q. The extent of change over time did not differ significantly between the IIG and WLCG from baseline to 1 month (P=.169). However, significant improvements in TAI-Q scores were still evident after the training for the WLCG (P<.001). Those with a lower pretraining TAI-Q score and more shoulder pain were most likely to benefit from the training. CONCLUSIONS: Repeated TAI-Q self-assessments likely contributed to improved transfer quality, with web-based training having an additive effect. Wheelchair users are likely to benefit from transfer training and self-assessment of transfer quality in their home environments. This has the potential to decrease injury risk while avoiding barriers to in-person training.
引用
- Rigot SK, DiGiovine KM, Boninger ML, et al. Effectiveness of a Web-Based Direct-to-User Transfer Training Program: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2021. PMID: 34090854. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2021.05.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。