指南与共识神经康复

痉挛成人肉毒毒素注射后的辅助治疗:系统综述与SOFMER推荐

Adjunct therapies after botulinum toxin injections in spastic adults: Systematic review and SOFMER recommendations.
指南 / 共识 · Ann Phys Rehabil Med · 2021-11-13

该系统综述纳入32项研究(1202例痉挛成人),评估肉毒毒素注射后非药物辅助治疗的疗效,并由25名法国专家通过两轮Delphi流程制定推荐。结果显示关节姿势操作和主动辅助治疗可能改善损伤和活动,而物理因子不推荐;因异质性未能进行Meta分析。

要点

  • 连续姿势(胶带或石膏)推荐使用, discontinuous姿势(矫形器)在主动功能患者中可能更优。
  • 无设备或设备辅助的主动辅助治疗可能中期(>3个月)有益,尤其高强度(>3小时/周)如约束诱导运动疗法。
  • 物理因子不推荐使用;自我康复研究不足但专家强调其兴趣。

核心结论

  • 关节姿势操作和主动辅助治疗(设备辅助或无设备)可能在肉毒毒素注射后进一步改善损伤和活动。
  • 物理因子不推荐使用;需要进一步研究以根据个体治疗目标、参与和生活质量定义最佳辅助治疗策略。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述检索4个电子数据库至2020年5月,纳入比较试验报告非药物辅助治疗在痉挛成人肉毒毒素注射后的效果。
  • 25名法国专家参与两轮Delphi流程制定推荐;纳入32项研究(1202名参与者,中位数32/研究)。

主要发现

  • 纳入研究评估物理因子(n=9)、关节姿势操作(JPPs,n=11)和主动辅助治疗(n=14),主要在中风后。
  • 随机对照试验平均质量良好(PEDro中位数[IQR]=7[6-8]),非随机对照试验质量中等(n=2)或差(n=2)。
  • 因辅助治疗、对照组和结局测量的异质性,未能进行Meta分析。

关键数值与推荐

  • 有证据支持使用关节姿势操作,但低剂量手动牵伸和软组织姿势技术除外。
  • 推荐连续姿势(通过胶带或石膏);不连续姿势(通过矫形器)在主动功能患者中可能更优。
  • 无设备或设备辅助的主动辅助治疗可能中期(>3个月)有益,尤其高强度(>3小时/周)如约束诱导运动疗法。
  • 物理因子不推荐使用。

临床怎么用

  • 临床可考虑在肉毒毒素注射后使用连续姿势(胶带或石膏)或矫形器(主动功能患者)作为辅助治疗。
  • 可考虑无设备或设备辅助的主动辅助治疗,尤其高强度(>3小时/周)方案,以改善中期结局。
  • 不推荐使用物理因子作为肉毒毒素注射后的辅助治疗。
  • 自我康复在局灶治疗后研究不足,但专家强调其兴趣。

局限性

  • 因辅助治疗、对照组和结局测量的异质性,无法进行Meta分析。
  • 非随机对照试验质量中等或差;需要进一步研究定义最佳辅助治疗策略。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Adjunct therapies (ATs) may further improve outcomes after botulinum toxin injections in spastic patients, but evidence was unclear in previous systematic reviews. OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of non-pharmacological ATs in spastic adults according to the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health and build an expert consensus-based on a Delphi process. METHODS: Four electronic databases were searched up to May 2020 for reports of comparative trials of non-pharmacologic ATs after botulinum toxin injections in spastic adults. Then, 25 French experts participated in a two-round Delphi process to build recommendations on the use of ATs. RESULTS: We included 32 studies (1202 participants, median 32/study) evaluating the effects of physical agents (n=9), joint posture procedures (JPPs, n=11), and active ATs (n=14), mainly after stroke. The average quality of articles was good for randomised controlled trials (median [interquartile range] PEDro score=7 [6-8]) but moderate (n=2) or poor (n=2) for non-randomised controlled trials (Downs & Black checklist). Meta-analysis was precluded owing to the heterogeneity of ATs, control groups and outcome measures. There is evidence for the use of JPPs except low-dose manual stretching and soft posture techniques. Continuous postures (by taping or casting) are recommended; discontinuous postures (by orthosis) may be preferred in patients with active function. Device-free or device-assisted active ATs may be beneficial in the mid-term (>3months after botulinum toxin injections), particularly when performed at a high-intensity (>3h/week) as in constraint-induced movement therapy. Self-rehabilitation remains understudied after a focal treatment, but its interest is highlighted by the experts. The use of physical agents is not recommended. CONCLUSIONS: JPPs and active ATs (device-assisted or device-free) may further improve impairments and activities after botulinum toxin injections. Further studies are needed to better define the best strategies for ATs as a function of the individual treatment goals, participation and quality of life. REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO (CRD42018105856).

来源:Ann Phys Rehabil Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Allart E, Mazevet D, Idée S, et al. Adjunct therapies after botulinum toxin injections in spastic adults: Systematic review and SOFMER recommendations. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2021. PMID: 34091058. doi:10.1016/j.rehab.2021.101544

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。