机器人运动训练对不完全性脊髓损伤患者24周康复期心血管指标的影响:随机对照预试验
该随机对照预试验纳入16例慢性创伤性运动不完全性四肢瘫患者,比较机器人运动训练(RLT)与活动基础训练(ABT)24周对心血管指标的影响。结果显示两组在静息血压、踝臂指数和心率变异性上无差异,但ABT组24周站立心率显著高于RLT组(95.58±12.61 vs 75.14±14.96次/分,P=.05),RLT组6分钟步行试验的心血管效率从基线11.1±2.6改善至6周7.5±2.8次/米并维持至24周。
要点
- RLT组6分钟步行试验心血管效率从基线11.1±2.6改善至6周7.5±2.8次/米并维持至24周。
- 24周站立心率ABT组(95.58±12.61次/分)显著高于RLT组(75.14±14.96次/分),P=.05。
- 两组静息血压、踝臂指数及心率变异性未见组间或时间差异。
核心结论
- 预试验中大效应量和组间显著差异支持RLT和ABT在康复6周至24周内改变心血管指标临床有效。
- RLT可能比ABT更有效改善心脏对直立应激的反应。
- 基于心率变异性指标,站立刺激对副交感神经系统的影响与RLT相当。
- 外骨骼步行的心血管效率改善,尤其在前6周。
- RLT和ABT对肱动脉和踝动脉血压的影响均有限。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照预试验,纳入16例慢性创伤性运动不完全性四肢瘫患者,居住于南非西开普省。
- 干预为机器人运动训练(Ekso GT)与活动基础训练,持续24周。
- 主要结局包括4种生理体位下的肱动脉和踝动脉血压、心率、心率变异性及心血管效率。
主要发现
- 两组静息收缩压和舒张压、踝收缩压、踝臂血压指数及心率变异性未见组间或时间差异。
- 24周站立心率ABT组为95.58±12.61次/分,显著高于RLT组的75.14±14.96次/分(P=.05)。
- RLT组站立与6分钟步行试验生理体位间的心率变异性指标(R-R间期标准差和相邻R-R间期差值均方根)在整个干预期间无显著变化。
- RLT组6分钟步行试验心血管效率从基线11.1±2.6改善至6周7.5±2.8次/米,并维持至24周。
关键数值与推荐
- 24周站立心率ABT组95.58±12.61次/分 vs RLT组75.14±14.96次/分,P=.05。
- RLT组6分钟步行试验心血管效率基线11.1±2.6次/米,6周7.5±2.8次/米,维持至24周。
临床怎么用
- RLT和ABT均可考虑用于不完全性脊髓损伤患者改善心血管指标,早期(6周)即可见效并维持至24周。
- 若目标是改善心脏对直立应激的反应,RLT可能优于ABT。
- 两种训练对肱动脉和踝动脉血压的影响有限,血压管理需结合其他措施。
局限性
- 本研究为预试验,样本量小(N=16),需更大样本随机对照试验进一步验证。
- 研究对象为慢性创伤性运动不完全性四肢瘫患者,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe the effect of robotic locomotor training (RLT) and activity-based training (ABT) on cardiovascular indices during various physiological positions in individuals with spinal cord injury. DESIGN: Randomized controlled pilot study. SETTING: Private practice: Therapy & Beyond Centre - Walking with Brandon Foundation, Sports Science Institute of South Africa, Cape Town, South Africa. PARTICIPANTS: Participants with chronic traumatic motor incomplete tetraplegia (N=16) who resided in the Western Cape, South Africa. INTERVENTION: Robotic locomotor training (Ekso GT) and activity-based training over a 24-week intervention. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Brachial and ankle blood pressure, heart rate, heart rate variability, and cardiovascular efficiency during 4 physiological positions. RESULTS: No differences between groups or over time were evident in resting systolic and diastolic blood pressure, ankle systolic pressure, ankle brachial pressure index, and heart rate variability. Standing heart rate at 24 weeks was significantly higher in the ABT group (95.58±12.61 beats/min) compared with the RLT group (75.14±14.96 beats/min) (P=.05). In the RLT group, no significant changes in heart rate variability (standard deviation R-R interval and root mean square of successive differences) was found between the standing and 6-minute walk test physiological positions throughout the intervention. Cardiovascular efficiency in the RLT group during the 6-minute walk test improved from 11.1±2.6 at baseline to 7.5±2.8 beats per meter walked at 6 weeks and was maintained from 6 to 24 weeks. CONCLUSIONS: Large effect sizes and significant differences between groups found in this pilot study support the clinical effectiveness of RLT and ABT for changing cardiovascular indices as early as 6 weeks and up to 24 weeks of rehabilitation. RLT may be more effective than ABT in improving cardiac responses to orthostatic stress. Based on heart rate variability metrics, the stimulus of standing has comparable effects to RLT on the parasympathetic nervous system. Cardiovascular efficiency of exoskeleton walking improved, particularly over the first 6 weeks. Both the RLT and ABT interventions were limited in their effect on brachial and ankle blood pressure. A randomized controlled trial with a larger sample size is warranted to further examine these findings.
引用
- Evans RW, Shackleton CL, West S, et al. Robotic Locomotor Training Leads to Cardiovascular Changes in Individuals With Incomplete Spinal Cord Injury Over a 24-Week Rehabilitation Period: A Randomized Controlled Pilot Study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2021. PMID: 33839105. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2021.03.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。