多用户严肃游戏中游戏模式对卒中幸存者参与度与社会参与的影响
该研究采用受试者内随机试验设计,纳入21名卒中幸存者配对进行双人上肢康复游戏,比较竞争、共同激活和协作三种游戏模式对参与度和社会参与的影响。结果显示协作模式显著促进更多行为参与,竞争模式在认知表现较好、低外向性或运动技能较高的参与者中促进更多心流和挑战感,而认知缺陷较高的参与者在共同激活模式下报告更高的胜任感。
要点
- 协作模式在多用户康复中更适合促进社会参与。
- 竞争模式对认知好、低外向或运动技能高者提升心流。
- 认知缺陷高者在共同激活模式中报告更高胜任感。
核心结论
- 在多用户运动康复环境中,协作模式是促进社会参与的更合适游戏方式,具有提高治疗依从性和效果的潜力。
- 设计多人游戏任务时需考虑玩家的运动能力、认知能力和人格特质。
研究设计与样本
- 采用受试者内随机试验设计,纳入21名卒中幸存者配对进行双人上肢康复游戏。
- 使用有形物体和大屏幕交互桌实现竞争、共同激活和协作三种游戏模式。
主要发现
- 协作模式显著促进更多行为参与。
- 竞争模式在认知表现较好、低外向性或运动技能较高的参与者中促进更多心流和挑战感,优于共同激活模式。
- 认知缺陷较高的参与者在共同激活模式下报告更高的胜任感。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用游戏体验问卷核心模块评估参与度,社会临场感模块评估社会参与。
- 使用国际人格项目库简版评估人格,Fugl-Meyer上肢评估运动功能,改良Ashworth量表评估肌张力,蒙特利尔认知评估评估认知功能。
临床怎么用
- 在多用户康复中优先采用协作模式以增强社会参与。
- 根据患者的认知表现、外向性和运动技能个性化选择竞争或共同激活模式。
局限性
- 样本量较小(21名卒中幸存者),需更大样本验证。
- 研究为单次游戏体验,长期效果未知。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Serious games are promising for stroke rehabilitation, with studies showing a positive impact on reducing motor and cognitive deficits. However, most of the evidence is in the context of single-user rehabilitation, and little is known concerning the impact in multi-user settings. This study evaluates the impact that different game modes can have on engagement and social involvement during a two-user game. Specifically, we want to understand the benefits of game modalities based on competition, co-activation, and collaboration and analyze the influence of different motor and cognitive deficits and personality traits. METHODS: We developed a two-player setup-using tangible objects and a large screen interactive table-for upper limb rehabilitation purposes. We implemented a game that, while keeping the same basic mechanics, can be played in the three different modes (Competitive, Co-active, and Collaborative). We ran a within-person randomized study with 21 stroke survivors that were paired and played the game in its three versions. We used the Game Experience Questionnaire-Core Module to assess engagement and the Social Presence Module to assess Social Involvement. For personality, motor, and cognitive function, users answered the International Personality Item Pool (short version), Fugl-Meyer Assessment-Upper Extremity, Modified Ashworth Scale, and Montreal Cognitive Assessment, respectively. RESULTS: The Collaborative mode promoted significantly more Behavioral Involvement. The Competitive mode promoted more Flow and Challenge than the Co-active mode with participants with better cognitive performance, with low extraversion, or with higher motor skills. Participants with higher cognitive deficits reported more Competence with the Co-active mode. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that, for multi-user motor rehabilitation settings, the collaborative mode is the more appropriate gaming approach to promote social involvement, showing a high potential for increasing adherence and effectiveness of therapy. Additionally, we show that a player's motor and cognitive ability and personality should be considered when designing personalized tasks for multiplayer settings.
引用
- Pereira F, Bermúdez I Badia S, Jorge C, et al. The use of game modes to promote engagement and social involvement in multi-user serious games: a within-person randomized trial with stroke survivors. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2021. PMID: 33853609. doi:10.1186/s12984-021-00853-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。