指南与共识神经康复儿童康复

脑性瘫痪临床指南系统综述:WHO康复干预包制定基础

Systematic Review of Clinical Guidelines Related to Care of Individuals With Cerebral Palsy as Part of the World Health Organization Efforts to Develop a Global Package of Interventions for Rehabilitation.
指南 / 共识 · Arch Phys Med Rehabil · 2021-01-13

作为WHO康复2030 initiative的一部分,本研究系统综述了10年内发表的英文脑性瘫痪临床实践指南,最终纳入5部指南的339条推荐,并映射至ICF功能分类。多数推荐针对身体功能层面的移动功能,缺乏聚焦活动与参与的身体或作业治疗干预,且指南制定中未明确使用ICF框架。

要点

  • 最终纳入5部脑性瘫痪临床指南,共提取339条推荐。
  • 多数推荐针对身体功能层面的移动功能,活动与参与层面干预指南缺乏。
  • 指南制定过程中缺乏对ICF框架的明确使用。

核心结论

  • 脑性瘫痪高质量临床指南数量有限,干预范围狭窄,且制定中未明确使用ICF框架。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索6个科学数据库、Google Scholar、指南数据库及专业学会网站,筛选10年内发表的英文脑性瘫痪临床实践指南。
  • 初始识别13部指南,经AGREE II工具评估排除5部,WHO进一步排除3部,最终纳入5部指南。

主要发现

  • 最终5部指南共提取339条推荐,每条推荐标注类型(评估、干预或服务)、推荐强度、证据质量及ICF功能分类。
  • 大多数指南涉及移动功能,并包含共病条件和全生命周期考量,但多数推荐停留在身体功能层面。
  • 没有指南专门聚焦于改善活动和参与的身体治疗或作业治疗,尽管这些治疗在康复中很普遍。

关键数值与推荐

  • AGREE II工具用于评估指南质量,并设定了纳入阈值或标准。
  • 共提取339条推荐,每条推荐均分配了ICF功能分类。

临床怎么用

  • 康复医学科智能体医生应知晓现有脑性瘫痪指南多关注身体功能层面的移动功能,对活动和参与层面的身体或作业治疗推荐有限。
  • 临床决策时可参考已纳入指南的339条推荐,但需注意指南未明确采用ICF框架,应结合ICF理念综合评估患者。

局限性

  • 指南数量有限且干预范围狭窄,缺乏聚焦活动和参与的身体或作业治疗指南。
  • 指南制定中缺乏对ICF框架的明确使用。
  • 缺乏指南并不一定意味着缺乏证据,需进一步证据审查和基于差距与利益相关者优先事项的开发。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: The World Health Organization's (WHO) Rehabilitation 2030 initiative is working to develop a set of evidence-based interventions selected from clinical practice guidelines for Universal Health Coverage. As an initial step, the WHO Rehabilitation Programme and Cochrane Rehabilitation convened global content experts to conduct systematic reviews of clinical practice guidelines for 20 chronic health conditions, including cerebral palsy. DATA SOURCES: Six scientific databases (Pubmed, EMBASE, Scopus, Web of Science, PEDro, CINAHL), Google Scholar, guideline databases, and professional society websites were searched. STUDY SELECTION: A search strategy was implemented to identify clinical practice guidelines for cerebral palsy across the lifespan published within 10 years in English. Standardized spreadsheets were provided for process documentation, data entry, and tabulation of the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II) tool. Each step was completed by 2 or more group members, with disagreements resolved by discussion. Initially, 13 guidelines were identified. Five did not meet the AGREE II established threshold or criteria for inclusion. Further review by the WHO eliminated 3 more, resulting in 5 remaining guidelines. DATA EXTRACTION: All 339 recommendations from the 5 final guidelines, with type (assessment, intervention, or service), strength, and quality of evidence, were extracted, and an International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health Functioning (ICF) category was assigned to each. DATA SYNTHESIS: Most guidelines addressed mobility functions, with comorbid conditions and lifespan considerations also included. However, most were at the level of body functions. No guideline focused specifically on physical or occupational therapies to improve activity and participation, despite their prevalence in rehabilitation. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the great need for high quality guidelines, this review demonstrated the limited number and range of interventions and lack of explicit use of the ICF during development of guidelines identified here. A lack of guidelines, however, does not necessarily indicate a lack of evidence. Further evidence review and development based on identified gaps and stakeholder priorities are needed.

来源:Arch Phys Med Rehabil,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Damiano DL, Longo E, Carolina de Campos A, et al. Systematic Review of Clinical Guidelines Related to Care of Individuals With Cerebral Palsy as Part of the World Health Organization Efforts to Develop a Global Package of Interventions for Rehabilitation. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2021. PMID: 33453191. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2020.11.015

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。