儿童脑瘫患儿功能性前伸试验姿势控制表现:Kids-BESTest标准效度研究
本研究评估Kids-BESTest临床标准中功能性前伸试验(FRT)向前和侧向在脑瘫(CP)儿童中的效度,纳入58名7-18岁儿童(CP 17名,典型发育41名)。结果显示FRT向前具有表面、同时和内容效度;FRT侧向(偏好侧和非偏好侧)具有同时效度,但表面和内容效度部分成立。为改善效度,评分标准中增加了描述条目以量化观察到的前伸策略。
要点
- Kids-BESTest的FRT向前标准在CP儿童中显示表面、同时和内容效度。
- FRT侧向(偏好侧和非偏好侧)显示同时效度,但表面和内容效度仅部分成立。
- 新增评分描述条目有助于临床量化观察到的前伸策略。
核心结论
- FRT向前标准具有表面、同时和内容效度;FRT侧向(偏好侧和非偏好侧)具有同时效度,但表面和内容效度仅部分成立。
研究设计与样本
- 心理测量学研究,评估表面效度、同时效度和内容效度,在临床实验室进行。
- 纳入58名7-18岁儿童,其中脑瘫17名,典型发育41名。
主要发现
- 表面效度:CP组FRT向前得分低于TD组(P<.001),FRT侧向非偏好侧得分低于TD组(P=.03),FRT侧向偏好侧得分两组相等(P=.12)。
- 同时效度:Kids-BESTest评分与数字衍生评分的一致性,FRT侧向(偏好侧和非偏好侧)为良好至优秀(88%-100%),FRT向前为良好(86%-88%),两组均如此。
- 内容效度:CP组Kids-BESTest评分与FRT向前时压力中心前后范围相关(ρ=0.68),与FRT侧向非偏好侧时压力中心侧向范围相关(ρ=0.57)。
- kinematics:FRT向前时Kids-BESTest评分与髋屈曲范围(ρ=0.51)和踝跖屈范围(ρ=0.75)呈中高相关,FRT侧向非偏好侧时与躯干侧屈相关(ρ=0.66)。
关键数值与推荐
- FRT向前:CP组与TD组比较P<.001;评分与数字衍生评分一致性86%-88%;与压力中心前后范围ρ=0.68,与髋屈曲范围ρ=0.51,与踝跖屈范围ρ=0.75。
- FRT侧向非偏好侧:CP组与TD组比较P=.03;评分与数字衍生评分一致性88%-100%;与压力中心侧向范围ρ=0.57,与躯干侧屈ρ=0.66。
- FRT侧向偏好侧:CP组与TD组比较P=.12;评分与数字衍生评分一致性88%-100%。
- 为改善效度,在评分标准下增加了额外描述条目以量化观察到的前伸策略。
临床怎么用
- 临床可使用Kids-BESTest的FRT向前标准评估脑瘫儿童姿势控制,结果与实验室测量一致。
- FRT侧向标准可用于同时效度评估,但需注意其表面和内容效度部分成立。
- 新增的描述条目有助于临床医生量化观察到的前伸策略,提高评估的实用性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Evaluate the validity of the Kids-Balance Evaluation Systems Test (Kids-BESTest) clinical criteria for the Functional Reach Test (FRT) forward and lateral with laboratory measures of postural control in children with cerebral palsy (CP). DESIGN: Psychometric study of face, concurrent, and content validity. SETTING: Clinical laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Children (N=58) aged 7-18 years (ambulant CP n=17, typically developing [TD] n=41). INTERVENTION: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Stability limits in standing were assessed using the Kids-BESTest items for FRT forwards (FRTFORWARD), FRT lateral preferred (FRTLATERAL(P)), and FRT lateral nonpreferred (FRTLATERAL(NP)). Force platforms and kinematic markers were used to collect information on center of pressure (CoP) and joint movement during reach. Analyses included face validity (Kids-BESTest scores compared between CP and TD groups), concurrent validity (agreement between Kids-BESTest scores and digitally derived scores), and content validity (relations between Kids-BESTest scores with kinematic and CoP data). RESULTS: Face validity of Kids-BESTest criteria was demonstrated with lower scores for CP compared to TD groups for FRTFORWARD (P<.001) and FRTLATERAL(NP) (P=.03) and equal scores for FRTLATERAL(P) (P=.12). For concurrent validity, agreement between Kids-BESTest scores and digitally derived scores was good to excellent for FRTLATERAL(both P/NP) (88%-100%) and good for FRTFORWARD (86%-88%) for both groups. For content validity, the CP group Kids-BESTest scores were correlated with CoP-RangeFORWARD during FRTFORWARD (ρ=0.68) and CoP-RangeLATERAL during FRTLATERAL(NP) (ρ=0.57). For kinematic data, correlations were moderate-high between Kids-BESTest scores and range of hip flexion (ρ=0.51) and ankle plantar flexion (ρ=0.75) during FRTFORWARD, and trunk lateral flexion (ρ=0.66) during FRTLATERAL(NP). CONCLUSION: The FRTFORWARD demonstrated face, concurrent, and content validity. The FRTLATERAL(P/NP) demonstrated concurrent validity, but partial face and content validity. To improve validity of Kids-BESTest FRT criteria, additional descriptors have been added under the scoring criteria to enable clinicians to quantify observed reach strategies.
引用
- Dewar RM, Tucker K, Claus AP, et al. Postural Control Performance on the Functional Reach Test: Validity of the Kids-Balance Evaluation Systems Test (Kids-BESTest) Criteria. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2021. PMID: 33508337. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2020.12.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。