卒中康复上肢循证评估的实施:从证据到临床实践
本研究针对急性与亚急性卒中康复中上肢评估的证据-实践差距,在Sahlgrenska大学医院通过五阶段流程制定并实施循证临床实践指南,并以44名临床医生(23名物理治疗师、21名作业治疗师)的问卷调查进行评估。结果显示多数医生对指南及实施过程满意,但对具体评估项目的依从性约为60%–90%,对约定时间点的依从性约为50%,综合量表比简短筛查量表更难实施。
要点
- 指南纳入6项主要标准化评估:SAFE、ARAT-2、FMA-UE、BBT、9HPT和握力(Jamar握力计)。
- 超过80%(35至42名)医生对指南及实施过程表示满意。
- 综合量表比简短筛查量表更难实施,人员轮转与首周优先其他评估阻碍实施。
核心结论
- 证据的稳健性、充分支持与接纳性环境促进了实施过程,指南使评估更结构化、基于知识且一致,从而支持临床决策与患者参与。
研究设计与样本
- 在Sahlgrenska大学医院开展的五阶段实施过程:映射临床实践、识别循证结局测量、制定指南、实施和评估,并以系统理论框架指导实施。
- 采用问卷调查评估,共44名临床医生作答(23名物理治疗师和21名作业治疗师)。
主要发现
- 超过80%(35至42名)医生报告对指南及实施过程感到满意。
- 约60%–90%的医生报告对特定评估项目依从良好,约50%报告对约定时间点依从良好。
- 综合量表比简短筛查量表更难实施;员工高频率轮转及卒中后第一周需优先其他评估阻碍了实施。
关键数值与推荐
- 指南包括6项主要标准化评估:肩外展/手指伸展(SAFE)、动作研究手臂测试2项(ARAT-2)、上肢Fugl-Meyer评估(FMA-UE)、Box and Block测试(BBT)、9孔钉测试(9HPT)和握力(Jamar握力计),在卒中后特定时间点进行。
临床怎么用
- 采用结构化、基于知识的指南可支持卒中后上肢评估的一致性与临床决策。
- 实施时需考虑综合量表难度高于简短筛查量表,并应对人员轮转和首周评估优先级问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: There is an evidence-practice gap in assessment of the upper extremities during acute and subacute stroke rehabilitation. The aim of this study was to target this gap by describing and evaluating the implementation of, and adherence to, an evidence--based clinical practice guideline for occupational therapists and physiotherapists. METHODS: The upper extremity assessment implementation process at Sahlgrenska University Hospital comprised 5 stages: mapping clinical practice, identifying evidence-based outcome measures, development of a guideline, implementation, and evaluation. A systematic theoretical framework was used to guide and facilitate the implementation process. A survey, answered by 44 clinicians (23 physiotherapists and 21 occupational therapists), was used for evaluation. RESULTS: The guideline includes 6 primary standard-ized assessments (Shoulder Abduction, Finger Extension (SAFE), 2 items of the Actions Research Arm Test (ARAT-2), Fugl-Meyer Assessment of Upper Extremity (FMA-UE), Box and Block Test (BBT), 9-Hole Peg Test (9HPT), and grip strength (Jamar hand dynamometer)) per-formed at specified time-points post-stroke. More than 80% (35 to 42) clinicians reported reported being content with the guideline and the implementation process. Approximately 60-90% of the clinicians reported good adherence to specific assessments, and approximately 50% report-ed good adherence to the agreed time-points. Comprehensive scales were more difficult to implement compared with the shorter screening scales. High levels of work rotation among staff, and the need to prioritize other assessments during the first week after stroke, hindered to implementation. CONCLUSION: The robustness of evidence, adequate support and receptive context facilitated the implementation process. The guideline enables a more structured, knowledge-based and consistent assessment, and thereby supports clinical decision-making and patient involvement.
引用
- Alt Murphy M, Björkdahl A, Forsberg-Wärleby G, et al. Implementation of evidence-based assessment of upper extremity in stroke rehabilitation: From evidence to clinical practice. J Rehabil Med. 2021. PMID: 33470413. doi:10.2340/16501977-2790
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。