指南的挑战:脑性瘫痪照护临床指南系统综述的评论
本文是对《脑性瘫痪患者照护相关临床指南的系统综述》的受邀评论。作者作为盲审审稿人,反思临床指南可能因基于过时研究和旧概念框架而存在过时风险,并以20世纪对痉挛的关注为例说明。作者提出应翻转指南制定过程,利用最佳有效数据构建以问题为中心的情境化方法。
要点
- 指南可能因基于早期研究和旧概念框架而存在过时风险。
- 指南可能过于规定性和限制性。
- 建议翻转指南制定过程,用最佳有效数据构建情境化问题导向方法。
核心结论
- 指南可能因基于过时研究和旧概念框架而存在过时风险,且可能过于规定性和限制性。
- 应翻转指南制定过程,利用最佳有效数据构建针对脑性瘫痪个体、家庭和服务提供者的情境化问题导向方法。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为受邀评论,针对已发表的脑性瘫痪照护临床指南系统综述,作者曾担任原稿和修订稿的盲审审稿人。
主要发现
- 作者以20世纪对痉挛的关注为例,说明指南可能基于早期研究和不同概念框架而制定。
- 作者认为指南可能过于规定性和限制性,并提出应翻转指南制定过程。
临床怎么用
- 临床使用指南时需警惕其可能过时和限制性,并考虑以最佳有效数据构建情境化问题导向的康复方法。
局限性
- 本文为个人评论,观点仅代表作者本人,不代表所评论文章的作者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This essay is an invited commentary on the report "Systematic Review of Clinical Guidelines Related to Care of Individuals With Cerebral Palsy as Part of the World Health Organization Efforts to Develop a Global Package of Interventions for Rehabilitation" published in this journal. As a blinded reviewer of the original and revised versions of this interesting article, I was stimulated to reflect on several ideas about "clinical guidelines" and to take the opportunity to share concerns I have long held and that this article identified. Having said that, the thoughts expressed are mine alone and should not be ascribed to the authors of the article that provoked them. The case I offer is that guidelines may in some ways risk being outdated, insofar as they are crafted based on what we already know from research done in "earlier" times and with different conceptual frameworks than we now apply. I use the example of 20th century concerns about spasticity to illustrate my argument. I also suggest that they may be too prescriptive and restrictive. Instead, I raise for consideration the idea that we should turn the guidelines process on its head and use best available valid data to build toward contextualized problem-focused approaches to issues that are relevant to the individuals for whom they are meant to be useful- in this case, individuals with cerebral palsy, their families, and the service providers who work with them. It is my hope that these ideas stimulate discussion and reflection.
引用
- Rosenbaum P. Challenges of Guidelines: A Look at the Systematic Review of Clinical Guidelines Related to the Care of Individuals With Cerebral Palsy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2020. PMID: 33373598. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2020.12.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。