心脏风险分层方案能否预测心脏康复中的简单并发症?
该观察性纵向队列研究纳入76例心血管疾病患者,评估七种心脏风险分层方案对心血管康复活动中简单并发症的预测能力。仅AACVPR方案的风险分级与简单并发症存在统计学显著关联(P=0.046),但灵敏度0.53、特异度0.52、准确度0.53均较低,其他方案均无显著关联。结论认为AACVPR方案虽有关联但不具实用预测价值。
要点
- AACVPR方案风险分级与简单并发症显著相关(P=0.046),但灵敏度0.53、特异度0.52、准确度0.53均低。
- 其余六种方案(ACSM、巴西心脏病学会、AHA、Pashkow、法国心脏病学会、西班牙心脏病学会)均无显著关联。
- 现有心脏风险分层方案对心脏康复中简单并发症的预测能力不足,不宜单独用于临床决策。
核心结论
- AACVPR方案风险分级与简单并发症存在显著关联(P=0.046),但灵敏度0.53、特异度0.52、准确度0.53均低,不具实用预测价值。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性纵向队列研究,纳入76例确诊心血管疾病和/或存在危险因素的患者,在心血管康复门诊接受评估。
主要发现
- AACVPR方案风险分级与简单并发症显著相关(P=0.046),灵敏度0.53、特异度0.52、准确度0.53。
- ACSM方案无显著关联(P=0.801),巴西心脏病学会方案无显著关联(P=0.734)。
- AHA方案无显著关联(P=0.957),Pashkow方案无显著关联(P=0.790)。
- 法国心脏病学会方案无显著关联(P=0.314),西班牙心脏病学会方案无显著关联(P=0.078)。
关键数值与推荐
- 简单并发症包括心绞痛、血压异常变化、心律失常、疲劳、肌肉疼痛、苍白。
- 统计方法为卡方检验,显著时进一步计算灵敏度、特异度和准确度。
- AACVPR方案:P=0.046,灵敏度0.53,特异度0.52,准确度0.53。
- ACSM方案P=0.801,巴西心脏病学会方案P=0.734,AHA方案P=0.957。
- Pashkow方案P=0.790,法国心脏病学会方案P=0.314,西班牙心脏病学会方案P=0.078。
临床怎么用
- 现有心脏风险分层方案对心脏康复中简单并发症的预测能力有限,临床不宜仅凭风险分级判断安全性。
- AACVPR方案虽与简单并发症相关,但灵敏度和特异度均接近随机水平,需结合其他评估手段。
局限性
- 样本量仅76例,可能影响统计效能和结果外推。
- 原文未报告其他局限性信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study evaluated the capacity of cardiac risk stratification protocols on simple complications that occur during activities of a cardiovascular rehabilitation program. DESIGN: Observational longitudinal cohort study. SETTING: Outpatient clinic of cardiovascular rehabilitation. SUBJECT: Patients diagnosed with cardiovascular disease and/or risk factors. INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN MEASURES: The relationship between the cardiac risk classes of seven risk stratification protocols and the occurrence of simple complications (such angina, abnormal changes in blood pressure, arrhythmias, fatigue, muscle pain, pallor) was assessed using the chi-square test, and when statistical significance was observed, sensitivity, specificity and accuracy were determined. RESULTS: About 76 patients were analyzed. The American Association of Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Rehabilitation (AACVPR) protocol showed a statistically significant relationship between simple complications and cardiac risk classes (P-value = 0.046), however the results of sensitivity (0.53), specificity (0.52), and accuracy (0.53) were not significant. The other protocols analyzed were not significant: American College of Sports Medicine (P-value = 0.801), Brazilian Society of Cardiology (P-value = 0.734), American Heart Association (P-value = 0.957), Pashkow (P-value = 0.790), Society French Cardiology (P-value = 0.314), and Spanish Society of Cardiology (P-value = 0.078). CONCLUSION: The AACVPR protocol showed a significant relationship between the risk classes and the occurrence of simple complications, however, the low values obtained for sensitivity, specificity and accuracy show that it is not useful for this purpose. CLINICAL TRIALS REGISTRATION: NCT03446742.
引用
- Ribeiro F, Takahashi C, Vanzella LM, et al. An investigation into whether cardiac risk stratification protocols actually predict complications in cardiac rehabilitation programs? Clin Rehabil. 2020. PMID: 33292000. doi:10.1177/0269215520978499
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。