创伤性脊髓损伤中AIS与Frankel分类诊断稳定性的比较
该回顾性分析纳入2011至2018年SCIMS数据库中804例创伤性脊髓损伤患者,比较Frankel与AIS两种分类系统在1年随访时的诊断稳定性。结果显示,Frankel系统下入院时诊断为不完全性损伤者1年后退化为完全性损伤的比例高于AIS系统(9.4%对2.0%),提示基于骶段保留的AIS分类更为稳定。
要点
- Frankel系统下不完全性损伤1年退化为完全性的比例为9.4%,高于AIS的2.0%。
- Frankel B级退化为A级的比例为19.7%,高于AIS B级退化为A级的5.4%。
- 基于骶段保留的AIS分类在创伤性脊髓损伤中稳定性优于Frankel分类。
核心结论
- 使用Frankel系统时,入院诊断为神经学不完全性脊髓损伤的患者在1年时退化为完全性状态的比例高于使用基于骶段保留的AIS分类系统。
- 这一结果进一步支持「骶段保留」定义在创伤性脊髓损伤中是更稳定的分类标准。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2011至2018年脊髓损伤模型系统(SCIMS)数据库中的登记个体。
- 共纳入804例创伤性脊髓损伤患者,入组条件包括受伤时至少16岁、30天内进入康复、入院时AIS分级A-D且入院时与1年时均有完整神经学数据。
主要发现
- 入院时Frankel系统诊断为不完全性损伤(B-D级)者1年时退化为完全性状态的比例为9.4%,而AIS系统为2.0%。
- Frankel B级患者退化为A级的比例为19.7%,AIS B级患者退化为A级的比例为5.4%。
- Frankel C或D级患者退化为Frankel A级的比例为5.0%,AIS C或D级患者退化为AIS A级的比例为1.1%。
临床怎么用
- 在创伤性脊髓损伤的神经学评估与随访中,采用基于骶段保留的AIS分类有助于更稳定地判定损伤完全性。
- 解读Frankel分类下的不完全性损伤诊断时,需注意其向完全性损伤退化的比例较高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the "sacral sparing" definition for completeness of traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) is a more stable definition than the previously used Frankel Classification. DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of individuals enrolled in the Spinal Cord Injury Model Systems (SCIMS) database between 2011 and 2018. SETTING: SCIMS centers. PARTICIPANTS: Individuals (N=804) with traumatic SCI who were at least 16 years old at time of injury, were admitted to rehabilitation within 30 days, had American Spinal Injury Association Impairment Scale (AIS) grades A-D at admission, and had complete neurologic data at the time of admission and 1 year. INTERVENTION: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Frankel and AIS scores were computed for a cohort of 804 eligible cases. Stability was compared between the 2 classification systems by calculating the proportions of cases in which regression (conversion to a more severe impairment level) was observed. RESULTS: A larger proportion of individuals classified with "incomplete" injuries (grades B-D) at the time of admission using the Frankel system regressed to complete status at 1 year compared with the AIS criteria (9.4% vs 2.0%). Those with grade B injuries regressed to grade A more often using the Frankel system compared with the AIS system (19.7% to 5.4%). A larger proportion of people diagnosed as Frankel grade C or D regressed to Frankel grade A compared with individuals diagnosed as AIS grade C or D who regressed to AIS grade A (5.0% to 1.1%). CONCLUSIONS: More individuals diagnosed with neurologically incomplete SCI regressed to complete status at 1 year when using the Frankel system compared with AIS classification, which is based on sacral sparing. This reinforces the finding that the "sacral sparing" definition is a more stable classification in traumatic SCI.
引用
- Kirshblum S, Botticello A, Benedetto J, et al. A Comparison of Diagnostic Stability of the ASIA Impairment Scale Versus Frankel Classification Systems for Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2020. PMID: 32531222. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2020.05.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。