机器人辅助步态训练中自动调参与手动调参的对比研究
结果显示AT更快达到稳定辅助水平、辅助量更低且各亚任务表现良好;参与者对两种方式的安全性、舒适性、效果和辅助量无明确偏好。
要点
- AT算法比治疗师手动调参更快达到稳定辅助水平。
- MT提供的辅助量常高于AT,但MT偏离参考轨迹更大。
- 参与者对两种调参方式的安全性、舒适性等无明确偏好。
核心结论
- 自动调参相比手动调参具有调参更快、辅助水平更低、各亚任务独立调参且所有亚任务表现良好的优势。
- 这些表面优势能否转化为更好的临床结局尚需未来临床试验验证。
研究设计与样本
- 辅助按行走亚任务分别调整:重心转移、足部横向放置、后肢与前肢角度、预定位、站立期稳定性、足廓清。
- MT由经验丰富的治疗师调参,AT采用基于各亚任务表现的算法调参。
- 比较两种方式的调参时间、辅助水平和偏离参考轨迹程度,并由参与者评价安全性、舒适性、效果和辅助量。
主要发现
- AT算法比MT更快达到稳定辅助水平。
- 两种方式在各亚任务提供的辅助存在相当大差异,MT的辅助量更常高于AT。
- 尽管MT辅助量更高,最大参考轨迹偏差出现在MT算法。
- 参与者对两种方式在安全性、舒适性、效果和辅助量方面没有明确偏好。
临床怎么用
- 临床中可考虑采用基于亚任务表现的自动调参算法以缩短调参时间并降低辅助量。
- 自动调参可对各行走亚任务分别优化,但需注意其临床结局优势尚未证实。
局限性
- 研究为短期对比,未报告临床结局指标,优势需未来临床试验验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In clinical practice, therapists choose the amount of assistance for robot-assisted training. This can result in outcomes that are influenced by subjective decisions and tuning of training parameters can be time-consuming. Therefore, various algorithms to automatically tune the assistance have been developed. However, the assistance applied by these algorithms has not been directly compared to manually-tuned assistance yet. In this study, we focused on subtask-based assistance and compared automatically-tuned (AT) robotic assistance with manually-tuned (MT) robotic assistance. METHODS: Ten people with neurological disorders (six stroke, four spinal cord injury) walked in the LOPES II gait trainer with AT and MT assistance. In both cases, assistance was adjusted separately for various subtasks of walking (in this study defined as control of: weight shift, lateral foot placement, trailing and leading limb angle, prepositioning, stability during stance, foot clearance). For the MT approach, robotic assistance was tuned by an experienced therapist and for the AT approach an algorithm that adjusted the assistance based on performances for the different subtasks was used. Time needed to tune the assistance, assistance levels and deviations from reference trajectories were compared between both approaches. In addition, participants evaluated safety, comfort, effect and amount of assistance for the AT and MT approach. RESULTS: For the AT algorithm, stable assistance levels were reached quicker than for the MT approach. Considerable differences in the assistance per subtask provided by the two approaches were found. The amount of assistance was more often higher for the MT approach than for the AT approach. Despite this, the largest deviations from the reference trajectories were found for the MT algorithm. Participants did not clearly prefer one approach over the other regarding safety, comfort, effect and amount of assistance. CONCLUSION: Automatic tuning had the following advantages compared to manual tuning: quicker tuning of the assistance, lower assistance levels, separate tuning of each subtask and good performance for all subtasks. Future clinical trials need to show whether these apparent advantages result in better clinical outcomes.
引用
- Fricke SS, Bayón C, der Kooij HV, et al. Automatic versus manual tuning of robot-assisted gait training in people with neurological disorders. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2020. PMID: 31992322. doi:10.1186/s12984-019-0630-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。