临床医生对脑机接口的认知:加拿大全国调查
该研究对加拿大神经科医生、康复科医生及部分发育儿科医生进行全国横断面调查,评估其对脑机接口(BCI)的认知与适用人群判断。922封有效邮件中137人(15%)回复,BCI知识评分普遍偏低,超过40%自认低于「模糊了解」,仅15%达到「有些熟悉」或更好。多数医生认为BCI对改善生活质量潜力高,但仅6名医生(4%)有患者使用BCI。
要点
- 加拿大临床医生对BCI认知普遍不足,超过40%自认低于「模糊了解」。
- 仅15%医生达到「有些熟悉」或更好,且知识水平无专科差异。
- 81%医生认为BCI对改善生活质量潜力高,但仅4%有患者实际使用。
核心结论
- 尽管BCI潜力高且可能有数千患者受益,但照护严重神经功能障碍患者的临床医生对BCI认知较差。
- BCI应用的功能优先级在医学专业人员与潜在使用者之间可能不同,提示医生对使用者需求理解不够准确。
研究设计与样本
- 加拿大全国、基于人群的横断面调查,对象为照护严重功能障碍患者的专科医生。
- 调查基于证据与经验设计,涵盖BCI知识、适用人群和潜在影响三个主题,并构建BCI知识指数评分。
- 联系加拿大成人及儿童神经科医生、康复科医生及部分发育儿科医生,通过安全网络软件经电子邮件施测并在线收集数据。
- 922封有效邮件(664名神经科医生、253名康复科医生)中137人(15%)回复。
主要发现
- 三分之一医生估计其患者中≥10%为保留认知能力的严重神经功能障碍者。
- BCI知识评分低,超过40%自认低于「模糊了解」,仅15%达到「有些熟悉」或更好,且知识水平无专科差异。
- 仅6名医生(4%)有患者正在使用BCI。
- 沟通和轮椅控制被评为最可能改善生活质量的BCI应用方向。
临床怎么用
- 康复医学科医生应主动提升对BCI的认知,以便识别可能受益的严重神经功能障碍但保留认知的患者。
- 在BCI应用方向选择上,沟通与轮椅控制被医生评为最优先,可作为临床沟通与转介讨论的参考。
- 鉴于医生对BCI知识普遍不足,可考虑开展针对临床医生的BCI教育与培训。
局限性
- 调查回复率仅15%(137/922),可能存在无应答偏倚。
- 仅纳入加拿大神经科、康复科及部分发育儿科医生,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Individuals with severe neurological disabilities but preserved cognition, including children, are often precluded from connecting with their environments. Brain computer interfaces (BCI) are a potential solution where advancing technologies create new clinical opportunities. We evaluated clinician awareness as a modifiable barrier to progress and identified eligible populations. METHODS: We executed a national, population-based, cross-sectional survey of physician specialists caring for persons with severe disability. An evidence- and experience-based survey had three themes: clinician BCI knowledge, eligible populations, and potential impact. A BCI knowledge index was created and scored. Canadian adult and pediatric neurologists, physiatrists and a subset of developmental pediatricians were contacted. Secure, web-based software administered the survey via email with online data collection. RESULTS: Of 922 valid emails (664 neurologists, 253 physiatrists), 137 (15%) responded. One third estimated that ≥10% of their patients had severe neurological disability with cognitive capacity. BCI knowledge scores were low with > 40% identifying as less than "vaguely aware" and only 15% as "somewhat familiar" or better. Knowledge did not differ across specialties. Only 6 physicians (4%) had patients using BCI. Communication and wheelchair control rated highest for potentially improving quality of life. Most (81%) felt BCI had high potential to improve quality of life. Estimates suggested that > 13,000 Canadians (36 M population) might benefit from BCI technologies. CONCLUSIONS: Despite high potential and thousands of patients who might benefit, BCI awareness among clinicians caring for disabled persons is poor. Further, functional priorities for BCI applications may differ between medical professionals and potential BCI users, perhaps reflecting that clinicians possess a less accurate understanding of the desires and needs of potential end-users. Improving knowledge and engaging both clinicians and patients could facilitate BCI program development to improve patient outcomes.
引用
- Letourneau S, Zewdie ET, Jadavji Z, et al. Clinician awareness of brain computer interfaces: a Canadian national survey. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2020. PMID: 31907010. doi:10.1186/s12984-019-0624-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。