脊髓损伤者与对照组对仿生与非仿生行走的急性代谢反应差异
该研究比较了10名慢性脊髓损伤者与10名非损伤对照者在坐位休息、站立及长时间仿生行走或双足行走时的能量消耗,并测试仿生行走后血糖效应。结果显示仿生行走工作强度低于心肺适能训练阈值但高于坐位休息和被动站立,且未在血糖正常的体能良好参与者中促进血糖获益。
要点
- 仿生行走45分钟平均工作强度低于40%峰值摄氧量,稳态后漂移可忽略。
- 仿生与非仿生行走绝对能量消耗在组间无差异,但对照组步行速度高565%,SCI组每米千卡高3.3倍。
- 仿生行走后糖耐量曲线下面积降低9%不显著,所需胰岛素比休息时少20%。
核心结论
- 长时间仿生行走的工作强度低于心肺适能训练阈值但高于坐位休息和被动站立。
- 仿生行走代谢与低主观用力感及燃料分配与坐位休息相比无变化相一致。
- 仿生行走未在体能良好、血糖正常的参与者中促进血糖获益。
研究设计与样本
- 两项独立的组间比较,纳入10名慢性脊髓损伤者(C7-T1,AIS A-C)和10名对照者(N=20)。
- 干预为商用仿生外骨骼,主要结局包括绝对和相对峰值摄氧量、主观用力感、碳水化合物/脂肪氧化、能量消耗及仿生行走后血浆葡萄糖/胰岛素。
主要发现
- 45分钟户外仿生行走平均工作强度<40%峰值摄氧量,达到稳态后漂移可忽略。
- 主观用力感评分组间无差异,反映低用力。
- 仿生行走和非仿生行走的绝对能量消耗组间无差异,尽管对照组步行速度高565%,SCI组每米千卡高3.3倍。
- 燃料分配组间相似,组内碳水化合物和脂肪氧化相同。
- 仿生行走后糖耐量曲线下面积降低9%不显著,所需胰岛素比休息时少20%。
关键数值与推荐
- 45分钟户外仿生行走平均工作强度<40%峰值摄氧量。
- 对照组步行速度高565%,SCI组每米千卡高3.3倍。
- 仿生行走后糖耐量曲线下面积降低9%不显著,胰岛素需求少20%。
临床怎么用
- 该仿生外骨骼长时间行走强度不足以达到心肺适能训练阈值,但高于坐位休息和被动站立。
- 在体能良好、血糖正常的脊髓损伤者中,仿生行走未显示血糖获益。
- 对体能较差或糖耐量受损的脊髓损伤者,观察到的有利趋势值得进一步测试。
局限性
- 结论可能不适用于体能较差或糖耐量受损的脊髓损伤者。
- 样本量较小(N=20),且为慢性脊髓损伤特定节段(C7-T1)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To (1) compare energy expenditure during seated rest, standing, and prolonged bionic ambulation or bipedal ambulation in participants with spinal cord injury (SCI) and noninjured controls, respectively, and (2) test effects on postbionic ambulation glycemia in SCI. DESIGN: Two independent group comparison of SCI and controls. SETTING: Academic Medical Center. PARTICIPANTS: Ten participants with chronic SCI (C7-T1, American Spinal Injury Association Impairment Scale A-C) and 10 controls (N=20). INTERVENTIONS: A commercial bionic exoskeleton. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Absolute and relative (to peak) oxygen consumption, perceived exertion, carbohydrate/fat oxidation, energy expenditure, and postbionic ambulation plasma glucose/insulin. RESULTS: Average work intensity accompanying 45 minutes of outdoor bionic ambulation was <40% peak oxygen consumption, with negligible drift after reaching steady state. Rating of perceived exertion (RPE) did not differ between groups and reflected low exertion. Absolute energy costs for bionic ambulation and nonbionic ambulation were not different between groups despite a 565% higher ambulation velocity in controls and 3.3× higher kilocalorie per meter in SCI. Fuel partitioning was similar between groups and the same within groups for carbohydrate and fat oxidation. Nonsignificant (9%) lowering of the area under a glucose tolerance curve following bionic ambulation required 20% less insulin than at rest. CONCLUSION: Work intensity during prolonged bionic ambulation for this bionic exoskeleton is below a threshold for cardiorespiratory conditioning but above seated rest and passive standing. Bionic ambulation metabolism is consistent with low RPE and unchanged fuel partitioning from seated rest. Bionic ambulation did not promote beneficial effects on glycemia in well-conditioned, euglycemic participants. These findings may differ in less fit individuals with SCI or those with impaired glucose tolerance. Observed trends favoring this benefit suggest they are worthy of testing.
引用
- Maher JL, Baunsgaard CB, van Gerven J, et al. Differences in Acute Metabolic Responses to Bionic and Nonbionic Ambulation in Spinal Cord Injured Humans and Controls. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2019. PMID: 31465760. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2019.07.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。