基于Rasch验证与共识方法修订的慢性卒中和多发性硬化患者运动活动日志(MAL-18)
该验证队列研究纳入149例慢性轻度至中度上肢偏瘫的卒中或多发性硬化成人,采用Rasch测量理论从MAL-28中筛选出18个条目形成MAL-18。MAL-18拟合模型良好,无天花板效应,地板效应为12.08%,信度PSI为0.84,重测信度ICC为0.86,条目难度层级不受性别、年龄、患侧、诊断或干预类型影响。
要点
- MAL-18在慢性卒中和多发性硬化上肢偏瘫患者中具有内容和结构效度。
- MAL-18信度PSI为0.84,重测信度ICC(1,1)为0.86。
核心结论
- Rasch-based MAL-18在慢性卒中和多发性硬化阶段建立了内容和结构效度。
- 基于Rasch的转换表可使MAL-18用于临床。
研究设计与样本
- 验证队列研究,回顾性连续纳入149例社区居住的慢性轻度至中度上肢偏瘫成人,病因包括卒中或多发性硬化。
- 参与者在基线和上肢康复后接受MAL-28评估。
- 采用Rasch测量理论评估评分类别阈值排序、拟合、差异条目功能、 targeting、响应依赖、局部依赖和信度(PSI)。
- 由经验丰富的检查者评定各条目的内容效度,并计算修订版的重测信度。
主要发现
- MAL-18针对目标人群,地板效应为12.08%,天花板效应为0%。
- 信度可接受(PSI=0.84),重测信度良好(ICC(1,1)=0.86)。
- 条目难度层级独立于性别、年龄、患侧、诊断或所用干预类型。
- 存在3对条目的局部依赖;后续测试的响应依赖于先前测试的响应,提示响应依赖,并提出了校正方法。
关键数值与推荐
- 地板效应12.08%,天花板效应0%。
- 信度PSI=0.84;重测信度ICC(1,1)=0.86。
- 存在局部依赖的条目为3对。
- 响应依赖校正后治疗反应增加15%。
临床怎么用
- MAL-18可用于慢性卒中和多发性硬化上肢偏瘫患者的上肢运动活动质量评估。
- 临床可使用基于Rasch的转换表对MAL-18评分进行解释。
- 评估时需注意响应依赖,并采用提出的校正方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objectives. To derive a shorter version of the Motor Activity Log Quality-of-Movement Scale (MAL-28) with enhanced content and construct validity. Design. Validation cohort. Setting. Outpatient rehabilitation within an academic laboratory. Participants. Retrospective consecutive sample of 149 community-dwelling adults with chronic mild/moderate upper-extremity hemiparesis caused by stroke or multiple sclerosis (MS). Intervention. Not applicable. Methods. Participants received the MAL-28 at baseline and following upper-extremity rehabilitation. Rasch Measurement Theory informed threshold ordering of scoring categories, tests of fit, differential item functioning, targeting, response dependency, local dependency, and reliability (person separation index [PSI]). Seasoned examiners rated the content validity of each item. Test-retest reliability of the revised scale was calculated. Results. We established content and construct validity for 18 items. The resultant 18-item MAL fit the model (χ2 = 77.93; df = 72; P = .30) and targeted the population-that is, minimal floor (12.08%) or ceiling effects (0%), with acceptable reliability (PSI = 0.84) and good test-retest reliability [ICC(1, 1) = 0.86]. The hierarchy of item difficulty was independent of sex, age, affected side, diagnosis, or intervention type used, and there was local dependency in 3 pairs of items. Responses from a subsequent testing session were dependent on the responses from prior testing, indicating response dependency, for which a correction was proposed. Once response dependency was neutralized, there was a 15% greater treatment response. Conclusions. Content and construct validity are established for Rasch-based MAL-18 for chronic stages of stroke and MS. A Rasch-based conversion table enables clinical use of the MAL-18.
引用
- Van de Winckel A, Gauthier L. A Revised Motor Activity Log Following Rasch Validation (Rasch-Based MAL-18) and Consensus Methods in Chronic Stroke and Multiple Sclerosis. Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2019. PMID: 31423899. doi:10.1177/1545968319868717
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。