脊髓损伤者选择与控制体验的定性元综合
该定性元综合系统检索1980年至2018年9月的多数据库文献,最终纳入29项定性研究,分析脊髓损伤者对于选择与控制的看法。归纳出「经历脆弱或安全」与「适应受限能力」两大主题,提示选择与控制受环境、人际和个人因素影响。建议健康专业人员回应患者的适应准备度,促进赋权并培养希望。
要点
- 选择与控制体验受环境、人际和个人因素交织影响。
- 脊髓损伤者存在适应准备度,包含情绪与认知能力变化的转折点。
- 健康专业人员应回应准备度,促进赋权并培养而非消除希望。
核心结论
- 脊髓损伤者对选择与控制的看法受相互关联的环境、人际和个人情境影响。
- 个人层面,参与者报告存在适应准备度,包含情绪和认知能力发生变化的转折点。
- 健康专业人员需回应这种准备度,促进赋权并培养而非消除希望。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究的元综合,系统检索Medline、Academic Search Premier、CINAHL、Cochrane、EMBASE、HealthSource、ProQuest、PsychInfo、SAGE和SCOPUS,检索时间1980年至2018年9月,涵盖所有语言。
- 筛选6706项研究的标题和摘要,全文审阅127项研究,最终纳入29项定性研究。
- 纳入标准为报告脊髓损伤者关于控制选择的观点的定性研究,排除包含其他利益相关群体观点的研究。
主要发现
- 一阶分析对每项研究的数据进行编码,二阶分析将编码数据段转化为更广泛的类别,三阶分析将类别浓缩为两个 overarching 主题。
- 两大主题为「经历脆弱或安全」和「适应受限能力」。
临床怎么用
- 健康专业人员应关注脊髓损伤者的适应准备度,包括情绪和认知能力变化的转折点。
- 在实践中促进赋权,并培养而非消除希望。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To systematically search the literature and construct a meta-synthesis of how choice and control are perceived by people with spinal cord injury (SCI). DATA SOURCES: Medline, Academic Search Premier, CINAHL, Cochrane, EMBASE, HealthSource, ProQuest, PsychInfo, SAGE, and SCOPUS were searched from 1980 until September 2018 including all languages. Reference lists of selected studies were also reviewed. STUDY SELECTION: Eligible qualitative studies included perspectives about choice of control as reported by people with an SCI. Studies were excluded if they included perspectives from other stakeholder groups. A total of 6706 studies were screened for title and abstract and full text of 127 studies were reviewed resulting in a final selection of 29. DATA EXTRACTION: Characteristics of the studies were extracted along with any data (author interpretations and quotes) relating to perspectives on choice and control. DATA SYNTHESIS: First-order analysis involved coding the data in each study and second-order analysis involved translating each segment of coded data into broader categories with third-order analysis condensing categories to 2 broad overarching themes. These themes were experiencing vulnerability or security and adapting to bounded abilities. CONCLUSIONS: Perspectives of choice and control are influenced by interrelated environmental, interpersonal, and personal contexts. From a personal perspective, participants reported a readiness for adaptation that included turning points where emotional and cognitive capacity to make choices and take control changed. Health professionals need to be responsive to this readiness, promote empowerment and foster, rather than remove, hope.
引用
- Murray CM, Van Kessel G, Guerin M, et al. Exercising Choice and Control: A Qualitative Meta-synthesis of Perspectives of People With a Spinal Cord Injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2019. PMID: 30794768. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2019.01.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。