Kids-BESTest与Kids-Mini-BESTest在脑瘫儿童中的可重复性
该心理测量学研究纳入18例8-17岁可步行脑瘫儿童(GMFCS I-II级),评估Kids-BESTest与Kids-Mini-BESTest的评定者内、评定者间及重测信度与一致性。结果显示Kids-BESTest信度优异(ICC 0.96-0.99),最小可检测变化为5%-9%;Kids-Mini-BESTest信度稍差(ICC 0.79-0.98),最小可检测变化为9%-16%。
要点
- Kids-BESTest在脑瘫儿童中评定者内、评定者间及重测信度优异(ICC 0.96-0.99)。
- Kids-BESTest最小可检测变化为5%-9%,适合作为干预前后结局指标。
- Kids-Mini-BESTest节省5-10分钟,但可重复性较差且仅关注跌倒相关平衡。
核心结论
- Kids-BESTest能优异地区分脑瘫儿童姿势控制能力,最小可检测变化低,适合作为干预前后结局指标。
- Kids-Mini-BESTest虽节省5-10分钟,但可重复性较差且仅关注跌倒相关平衡,遗漏2个姿势控制领域。
研究设计与样本
- 心理测量学研究,评估评定者内、评定者间及重测信度与一致性。
- 便利样本纳入18例8-17岁可步行脑瘫儿童(GMFCS I-II级,痉挛型或共济失调型)。
- 由经验丰富的物理治疗师实时评估并录像,同一治疗师间隔至少2周两次观看录像评分以评估评定者内信度,另一治疗师评分同一录像以评估评定者间信度。
主要发现
- Kids-BESTest的ICC为0.96-0.99,Kids-Mini-BESTest的ICC为0.79-0.98。
- Kids-BESTest所有一致性分析的最小可检测变化为5%-9%(好至优异)。
- Kids-Mini-BESTest的一致性分析最小可检测变化为9%-16%(差至好)。
关键数值与推荐
- Kids-BESTest的ICC 0.96-0.99,最小可检测变化5%-9%。
- Kids-Mini-BESTest的ICC 0.79-0.98,最小可检测变化9%-16%。
- Kids-Mini-BESTest比Kids-BESTest节省5-10分钟。
临床怎么用
- 对学龄期可步行脑瘫儿童,推荐使用Kids-BESTest评估姿势控制,其信度高且最小可检测变化低,适合干预前后对比。
- 若需缩短评估时间可选Kids-Mini-BESTest,但需注意其可重复性较差且仅覆盖跌倒相关平衡领域。
局限性
- 仅纳入GMFCS I-II级痉挛型或共济失调型脑瘫儿童。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the reproducibility, including reliability and agreement, of the Kids Balance Evaluation Systems Test (Kids-BESTest) and the short form of Kids-BESTest (Kids-Mini-BESTest) for measuring postural control in school-aged children with cerebral palsy. DESIGN: Psychometric study of intrarater, interrater, and test-retest reliability and agreement. SETTING: Clinical laboratory and home. PARTICIPANTS: Convenience sample of children (N=18) aged 8 to 17 years with ambulant cerebral palsy (CP) (Gross Motor Function Classification System I-II) with spastic or ataxic motor type. INTERVENTION: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Postural control was assessed using the Kids-BESTest and the Kids-Mini-BESTest. An experienced physiotherapist assessed all children in real time and the testing session was videotaped. The same physiotherapist viewed and scored the video twice, at least 2 weeks apart, to assess intrarater reproducibility. Another experienced physiotherapist scored the same video to determine interrater reproducibility. Thirteen children returned for a repeat assessment with the first physiotherapist within 6 weeks and their test-retest performance was rated in real time and with video. RESULTS: Excellent reliability was observed for both the Kids-BESTest (intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC] 0.96-0.99) and Kids-Mini-BESTest (ICC 0.79-0.98). The smallest detectable change was good to excellent for all Kids-BESTest agreement analyses (5%-9%), but poor to good for Kids-Mini-BESTest analyses (9%-16%). CONCLUSION: The Kids-BESTest shows an excellent ability to discriminate postural control abilities of school-aged children with CP and it has a low smallest detectable change, suitable for use as a preintervention and postintervention outcome measure. Although the Kids-Mini-BESTest is 5 to 10 minutes shorter to administer, it has poorer reproducibility and focuses only on falls-related balance, which excludes 2 domains of postural control.
引用
- Dewar R, Claus AP, Tucker K, et al. Reproducibility of the Kids-BESTest and the Kids-Mini-BESTest for Children With Cerebral Palsy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2019. PMID: 30639271. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2018.12.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。