职业康复中手功能分类问卷最小临床重要差异的确定
本研究纳入225例因上肢慢性疼痛住院接受多学科康复的法语患者,在入院和出院时采集HFS-F与DASH评分,出院时采集PGIC,采用锚定法和分布法估计MCID。结果显示HFS-F的MCID为+26(SD 35),DASH为-13(SD 13),ROC曲线下面积分别为0.726和0.768,作者建议HFS-F的MCID取26,约对应评分10%的改善。
要点
- HFS-F的MCID为26分,约对应评分10%的进展。
- DASH的MCID为-13分,ROC法为-7.5至-5分。
- 低于测量标准误(HFS-F为16.2)的数值应被拒绝。
核心结论
- 建议HFS-F的MCID取26分,约对应评分10%的进展,低于SEM(16.2)的数值应被拒绝。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入225例因上肢慢性疼痛住院接受多学科康复项目的法语患者,入院和出院时采集HFS-F与DASH评分,出院时采集PGIC(7级)。
- 采用锚定法(ROC曲线、Δ均值)和基于评分分布的客观法(测量标准误SEM)估计MCID。
主要发现
- 锚定法得出HFS-F的MCID为+26(SD 35)(P<10-4),DASH为-13(SD 13)(P<10-4)。
- ROC曲线法得出Δ-HFS-F的MCID为+10至+12,Δ-DASH为-7.5至-5。
- Δ-HFS-F的ROC曲线下面积为0.726 [0.638-0.781],Δ-DASH为0.768 [0.701-0.83]。
- 锚定指标与变化评分之间的相关系数>0.38(P<10-4)。
- HFS-F的SEM为16.2,DASH的SEM为-4.3。
关键数值与推荐
- HFS-F的MCID:锚定法+26(SD 35),ROC法+10至+12。
- DASH的MCID:锚定法-13(SD 13),ROC法-7.5至-5。
- HFS-F的SEM为16.2,DASH的SEM为-4.3;低于SEM的数值应被拒绝。
临床怎么用
- 在职业康复中评估上肢功能变化时,HFS-F评分改善达到26分可视为具有临床意义。
- 解释HFS-F评分变化时应参考SEM(16.2),低于该值的差异不应视为真实变化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To estimate the Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID) of the French version of the Hand Function Sort questionnaire (HFS-F). As a comparison, the MCID of the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) was also estimated. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We included French-speaking patients hospitalized in a multidisciplinary rehabilitation program for chronic pain of the upper limb after an accident. HFS-F and DASH scores were collected at admission and discharge; the Patient Global Impression of Change measure (PGIC; 7 levels) was collected at discharge. The MCID was estimated by 2 methods: the anchor-based method (receiver operating characteristic [ROC], delta (Δ) mean of scores) and the objective method based on the distribution of scores (standard error of measurement, SEM). RESULT: We included 225 patients. By the anchor-based method, the MCID for the HFS-F and DASH was +26 (SD 35) (P<10-4) and -13 (SD 13) (P<10-4), respectively, and by the ROC curve, it was +10 to +12 for the Δ-HFS-F and -7.5 to -5 for the Δ-DASH. The area under the ROC curve (AUC) was 0.726 [0.638-0.781] for Δ-HFS-F and 0.768 [0.701-0.83] for Δ-DASH. The correlations between the anchor and delta scores were>0.38 (P<10-4). The SEM was 16.2 for the HFS-F and -4.3 for the DASH. CONCLUSIONS: Values below the SEM must be rejected. Our anchor was significantly correlated with the outcome. Therefore, we propose an MCID for the HFS-F of 26, corresponding to approximately 10% progression of the score.
引用
- Benhissen Z, Konzelmann M, Vuistiner P, et al. Determining the minimal clinically important difference of the hand function sort questionnaire in vocational rehabilitation. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2018. PMID: 30562576. doi:10.1016/j.rehab.2018.11.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。