肉毒毒素注射治疗痉挛的辅助治疗:文献综述
本文综述了肉毒毒素注射后辅助非药物治疗痉挛的文献,检索PubMed并筛选相关研究。结果显示贴扎与石膏固定可增强肉毒毒素效果,石膏固定优于贴扎;体外冲击波优于电刺激;电刺激注射肌肉可能增强毒素效果;全身振动可能减轻脑瘫痉挛。未来需研究最佳注射后治疗方案。
要点
- 贴扎和石膏固定可增强肉毒毒素对上下肢痉挛的效果。
- 石膏固定优于贴扎的证据等级为1级。
- 体外冲击波优于电刺激的证据等级为1级。
核心结论
- 贴扎和石膏固定可有效增强肉毒毒素效果,石膏固定优于贴扎。
- 体外冲击波优于电刺激改善痉挛和疼痛,电刺激注射肌肉可能增强毒素效果。
- 全身振动可能减轻脑瘫痉挛,未来需研究最佳注射后治疗方案。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为文献综述,检索PubMed数据库,使用MeSH词包括肉毒毒素、肌肉痉挛、物理治疗模式和康复。
- 纳入聚焦肉毒毒素相关辅助治疗痉挛的研究,排除不与A型肉毒毒素注射相关的非药物治疗痉挛的论文。
- 结合作者已知相关文献与补充检索作为综述基础。
主要发现
- 贴扎和石膏固定有效改善上下肢痉挛患者肉毒毒素效果。
- 石膏固定在痉挛、关节活动度和步态等结局上优于贴扎,证据等级为1级。
- 体外冲击波在痉挛和疼痛等注射后结局上优于电刺激,证据等级为1级。
- 电刺激注射肌肉可能增强毒素效果,但最佳刺激方案未定义。
- 全身振动治疗可能减轻脑瘫痉挛,证据等级为2b级。
关键数值与推荐
- 石膏固定优于贴扎的证据等级为1级,但关于最佳时机、持续时间、目标和材料缺乏共识。
- 体外冲击波优于电刺激的证据等级为1级。
- 全身振动可能减轻脑瘫痉挛的证据等级为2b级。
- 电刺激注射肌肉可能有用,但最佳刺激协议未定义。
临床怎么用
- 临床可考虑在肉毒毒素注射后联合贴扎或石膏固定以增强效果。
- 对于痉挛和疼痛结局,体外冲击波可能优于电刺激。
- 电刺激注射肌肉可作为增强毒素效果的辅助手段,但需个体化选择方案。
- 全身振动可考虑用于脑瘫患者减轻痉挛。
局限性
- 贴扎和石膏固定的最佳时机、持续时间、目标和材料缺乏共识。
- 电刺激的最佳刺激协议尚未定义。
- 未来研究应聚焦于针对每个目标的最适注射后治疗方案。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: A wide range of adjunct therapies after botulinum toxin administration have been proposed. The aim of the present paper is to provide an overview of major writings dealing with adjuvant (non-pharmacological) treatments associated with botulinum toxin for managing spasticity in order to provide some up-to-date information about the usefulness of the most commonly used procedures. METHODS: The literature in PubMed was searched with the MeSH terms botulinum toxins, muscle spasticity, physical therapy modalities, and rehabilitation. The results were limited to studies focusing on adjuvant treatments associated with botulinum toxin for managing spasticity. We excluded papers on the use of non-drug treatments for spasticity not associated with botulinum toxin serotype A (BoNT-A) injection. Relevant literature known to the authors along with this complementary search represented the basis for this overview of the literature. RESULTS: Adhesive taping and casting effectively improved the botulinum toxin effect in patients with upper- and lower-limb spasticity. There is level 1 evidence that casting is better than taping for outcomes including spasticity, range of motion and gait. However, consensus about their most appropriate timing, duration, target and material is lacking. In terms of physical modalities combined with botulinum toxin injection, we found level 1 evidence that extracorporeal shock wave therapy is better than electrical stimulation for some post-injection outcomes including spasticity and pain. Furthermore, electrical stimulation of injected muscles might be useful to boost the toxin effect. However, the best stimulation protocol has not been defined. In addition, we found level 2b evidence that whole-body vibration therapy might reduce spasticity with cerebral palsy. CONCLUSION: Future research in this field should focus on investigating the most appropriate post-injection treatment protocol for each goal to achieve.
引用
- Picelli A, Santamato A, Chemello E, et al. Adjuvant treatments associated with botulinum toxin injection for managing spasticity: An overview of the literature. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2018. PMID: 30219307. doi:10.1016/j.rehab.2018.08.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。