儿童肉毒毒素注射后的辅助治疗:系统综述
该系统综述检索了1980年至2018年的平行组试验,评估儿童痉挛肉毒毒素注射后辅助治疗的整体效果。共纳入20篇文献662例参与者,结果显示石膏/体位固定联合肉毒毒素在改善关节活动度和降低痉挛方面优于单用肉毒毒素,抗阻训练可增强肌肉质量与表现而不增加痉挛,电刺激证据不明确,康复方案研究较少。
要点
- 石膏/体位固定联合肉毒毒素改善被动与主动活动度及痉挛优于单用,随访1年。
- 抗阻训练可增强肌肉质量与表现而不增加痉挛,但研究数量少。
- 电刺激证据不明确,康复方案研究仅3项,需进一步评估。
核心结论
- 儿童下肢石膏/体位固定联合肉毒毒素注射有高级别证据支持,但短腿石膏的长期疗效需评估。
- 抗阻训练可能是有前景的辅助治疗,尤其有助于避免肉毒毒素注射后肌力下降。
- 电刺激数据不明确,康复方案及不同石膏模式比较仍需研究。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索Medline、Cochrane和Embase数据库1980年1月至2018年3月15日的平行组试验(随机对照试验和非随机对照试验)。
- 纳入评估儿童痉挛肉毒毒素注射后辅助治疗的报告,共20篇文献662例参与者。
- 两名独立评审者提取数据,随机对照试验用PEDro量表、非随机对照试验用Downs and Black量表评估偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 16项随机对照试验平均质量良好(平均PEDro评分7.4,SD 1.6),4项非随机对照试验质量差至中等(D&B评分9至17)。
- 9项研究显示石膏联合肉毒毒素注射改善被动和主动活动度并降低痉挛优于单用肉毒毒素,随访1年。
- 抗阻训练增强肌肉质量和表现而不增加痉挛。
- 仅3项康复方案研究,对活动结果有鼓励性结果。
关键数值与推荐
- 石膏联合肉毒毒素注射在儿童下肢有高级别证据。
- 短腿石膏的长期疗效需评估,不同石膏模式间比较缺失。
- 肉毒毒素注射后至石膏固定的延迟时间不明确。
- 电刺激数据不明确。
- 抗阻训练研究数量少但结果有前景。
临床怎么用
- 儿童痉挛肉毒毒素注射后可考虑联合石膏/体位固定以改善活动度和痉挛。
- 抗阻训练可作为辅助治疗以增强肌肉表现并避免肌力下降。
- 电刺激和康复方案的应用需谨慎,因证据不明确或研究有限。
局限性
- 非随机对照试验质量差至中等。
- 短腿石膏长期疗效未评估,不同石膏模式比较缺失。
- 肉毒毒素注射后至石膏固定的延迟时间不明确。
- 电刺激数据不明确。
- 康复方案研究仅3项,需进一步评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Botulinum toxin (BTX) injection alone is not sufficient to treat spasticity in children, notably those with cerebral palsy; thus, there is an emerging trend for adjunct therapies to offer greater outcomes than BTX alone. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this systematic review was to evaluate the general effectiveness of adjunct therapies regardless of their nature in children with spasticity. METHODS: Medline, Cochrane and Embase databases were searched from January 1980 to March 15, 2018 for reports of parallel-group trials (randomized controlled trials [RCTs] and non-RCTs) assessing adjunct therapies after BTX injection for treating spasticity in children. Two independent reviewers extracted data and assessed the risk of bias by using the PEDro scale for RCTs and Downs and Black scale (D&B) for non-RCTs. RESULTS: Overall, 20 articles involving 662 participants met the inclusion criteria. The average quality was good for the 16 RCTs (mean PEDro score 7.4 [SD 1.6]) and poor to moderate for the 4 non-RCTs (D&B score 9 to 17). Adjunct therapies consisted of casting/posture, electrical stimulation, resistance training and rehabilitation programmes. Casting associated with BTX injection improved the range of passive and active motion and reduced spasticity better than did BTX alone (9 studies), with a follow-up of 1 year. Resistance training enhanced the quality and performance of muscles without increasing spasticity. Only 3 rehabilitation programmes were studied, with encouraging results for activities. CONCLUSION: Lower-limb posture with casting in children has a high level of evidence, but the long-term efficacy of short-leg casting needs to be evaluated. A comparison between the different modalities of casting is missing, and studies specifically devoted to testing the different kinds of casting are needed. Moreover, the delay to casting after BTX injection is not clear. Data on electrical stimulation are not conclusive. Despite the small number of studies, resistance training could be an interesting adjunct therapy notably to avoid loss of strength after BTX injection. Rehabilitation programmes after BTX injection still need to be evaluated.
引用
- Mathevon L, Bonan I, Barnais JL, et al. Adjunct therapies to improve outcomes after botulinum toxin injection in children: A systematic review. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2018. PMID: 30063979. doi:10.1016/j.rehab.2018.06.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。