音乐与机器人结合:机器人辅助治疗中动机的前瞻性随机研究
该前瞻性随机单中心研究将音乐创作融入手臂治疗机器人ARMin的虚拟游戏环境,设置四种运动训练条件(是否促进创造力×是否有视觉显示),在16名健康受试者中评估创造力与视觉显示对动机的影响。结果显示促进创造力显著提高兴趣/愉悦感和感知选择,促进创造力的条件更受偏好,且创造力与省略视觉显示对训练时间和训练强度存在交互效应。
要点
- 促进创造力显著提高IMI兴趣/愉悦感(p=0.001)和感知选择(p=0.010)。
- 促进创造力的条件(无论有无视觉显示)比不促进创造力的条件更受偏好。
- 创造力与省略视觉显示对训练时间(p=0.013)和训练强度(p<0.001)存在交互效应。
核心结论
- 在视-听-触觉或听-触觉环境中促进创造力可提高机器人辅助治疗中的动机。
- 研究证明了执行听-触觉音乐创作任务的可行性,并建议在神经肌肉疾病患者中试用该系统。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机单中心研究,纳入16名健康受试者(10男6女,平均年龄27.2岁,标准差4.1岁),无已知运动或认知缺陷。
- 受试者被随机分配先玩四种训练条件中的两种(有或无视觉显示),第三轮重复前两轮中偏好条件并改变视觉显示条件。
- 每轮使用内在动机量表(IMI)的子量表兴趣/愉悦感、感知选择、价值/有用性和人机关系测量动机。
- 记录实际训练时间、自由运动时间、速度曲线,并用问卷测量感知训练时间和感知努力。
- 所有测量使用线性混合模型分析,并询问受试者是否愿意获得所创作的音乐片段。
主要发现
- 促进创造力(C+而非C-)显著提高IMI兴趣/愉悦感(p=0.001)和感知选择(p=0.010)。
- IMI人机关系和价值/有用性无显著效应。
- 促进创造力的条件(有或无视觉显示)比不促进创造力的条件更受偏好。
- 促进创造力与省略视觉显示的交互效应存在于训练时间(p=0.013)和训练强度(p<0.001)。
- 四种训练条件间相对感知训练时间、感知努力和感知价值无差异。
临床怎么用
- 在机器人辅助上肢运动治疗中可整合音乐创作任务以提升动机。
- 可考虑采用听-触觉音乐创作任务,并建议在神经肌肉疾病患者中试用该系统。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入16名健康受试者,非患者人群。
- 单中心设计。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Robots have been successfully applied in motor training during neurorehabilitation. As music is known to improve motor function and motivation in neurorehabilitation training, we aimed at integrating music creation into robotic-assisted motor therapy. We developed a virtual game-like environment with music for the arm therapy robot ARMin, containing four different motion training conditions: a condition promoting creativity (C+) and one not promoting creativity (C-), each in a condition with (V+) and without (V-) a visual display (i.e., a monitor). The visual display was presenting the game workspace but not contributing to the creative process itself. In all four conditions the therapy robot haptically displayed the game workspace. Our aim was to asses the effects of creativity and visual display on motivation. METHODS: In a prospective randomized single-center study, healthy participants were randomly assigned to play two of the four training conditions, either with (V+) or without visual display (V-). In the third round, the participants played a repetition of the preferred condition of the two first rounds, this time with a new V condition (i.e., with or without visual display). For each of the three rounds, motivation was measured with the Intrinsic Motivation Inventory (IMI) in the subscales interest/enjoyment, perceived choice, value/usefulness, and man-machine-relation. We recorded the actual training time, the time of free movement, and the velocity profile and administered a questionnaire to measure perceived training time and perceived effort. All measures were analysed using linear mixed models. Furthermore, we asked if the participants would like to receive the created music piece. RESULTS: Sixteen healthy subjects (ten males, six females, mean age: 27.2 years, standard deviation: 4.1 years) with no known motor or cognitive deficit participated. Promotion of creativity (i.e., C+ instead of C-) significantly increased the IMI-item interest/enjoyment (p=0.001) and the IMI-item perceived choice (p=0.010). We found no significant effects in the IMI-items man-machine relation and value/usefulness. Conditions promoting creativity (with or without visual display) were preferred compared to the ones not promoting creativity. An interaction effect of promotion of creativity and omission of visual display was present for training time (p=0.013) and training intensity (p<0.001). No differences in relative perceived training time, perceived effort, and perceived value among the four training conditions were found. CONCLUSIONS: Promoting creativity in a visuo-audio-haptic or audio-haptic environment increases motivation in robot-assisted therapy. We demonstrated the feasibility of performing an audio-haptic music creation task and recommend to try the system on patients with neuromuscular disorders. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT02720341. Registered 25 March 2016, https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02720341.
引用
- Baur K, Speth F, Nagle A, et al. Music meets robotics: a prospective randomized study on motivation during robot aided therapy. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2018. PMID: 30115082. doi:10.1186/s12984-018-0413-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。