体能和轮椅移动能力与脊髓损伤手动轮椅使用者环境障碍遭遇、回避及感知的关系
横断面病例系列研究纳入50例慢性脊髓损伤手动轮椅使用者(62%为截瘫),评估体能、移动能力与环境障碍行为及感知的关系。截瘫者体能、移动能力、障碍遭遇率更高而每次遭遇回避率更低;仅四肢瘫者中体能和移动能力与遭遇频率正相关、与每次遭遇回避率负相关;两组体能和移动能力均与环境障碍感知无关。
要点
- 截瘫者体能、移动能力及障碍遭遇率高于四肢瘫者,每次遭遇回避率更低。
- 仅四肢瘫者中,体能和移动能力越高,障碍遭遇越频繁、每次遭遇回避越少。
- 两组体能和移动能力均与环境障碍感知无关,感知亦不因损伤平面而异。
核心结论
- 体能和移动能力与四肢瘫者的环境障碍行为(遭遇和回避)相关,但与截瘫者无关。
- 四肢瘫者障碍回避率更高,但并未感知到比截瘫者更多的环境障碍。
- 两组中体能和移动能力均与环境障碍感知无关。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面病例系列研究,纳入50例慢性脊髓损伤手动轮椅使用者,其中62%为截瘫。
- 在学术医学实验室完成体能、移动能力、环境障碍行为及感知评估。
主要发现
- 截瘫者体能、移动能力和环境障碍遭遇率均高于四肢瘫者,每次遭遇回避率低于四肢瘫者(均P≤.05)。
- 仅四肢瘫者中,体能和移动能力增加与多个EAMQ领域遭遇频率增加、每次遭遇回避率降低相关(均P≤.05)。
- 环境障碍感知在损伤平面间无差异(P=.79),两组中体能和移动能力与环境障碍感知均无关(均P>.17)。
关键数值与推荐
- 体能评估采用分级运动试验(有氧)和Wingate试验(无氧)。
- 移动能力评估采用6分钟推轮椅试验和30秒冲刺试验。
- 环境障碍行为采用EAMQ中环境特征遭遇评估,感知采用CHIEF环境障碍领域评估。
临床怎么用
- 对四肢瘫手动轮椅使用者,提升体能和移动能力可能增加环境障碍遭遇并减少每次遭遇的回避。
- 不能仅凭体能和移动能力推断患者对环境障碍的主观感知,需单独评估障碍感知。
- 康复干预可针对障碍感知、行为或两者进行定制,以促进参与,但需更多研究验证。
局限性
- 原文为横断面设计,无法推断因果关系。
- 原文未报告样本的详细人口学特征和具体损伤病程。
- 原文未报告EAMQ和CHIEF各领域的具体数值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess (1) if fitness and mobility are related to behavior and perception of physical barriers and (2) if behavior and physical barrier perception are related. DESIGN: Cross-sectional case series. SETTING: Academic Medical Laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Manual wheelchair users (N=50) with chronic spinal cord injury (62% paraplegia). INTERVENTION: None. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Participants completed the following assessments: (1) fitness: graded exercise test (aerobic) and Wingate (anaerobic); (2) mobility: 6-minute push test and 30-second sprint test; (3) physical barrier behavior: Encounters of Environmental Features in the Environmental Aspects of Mobility Questionnaire (EAMQ); (4) physical barrier perception: Craig Hospital Inventory of Environmental Factor (CHIEF) Environmental Barriers domain. RESULTS: Individuals with paraplegia had higher fitness, mobility, and environmental barrier encounter rates and lower avoidance per encounter rates vs tetraplegia (all P≤.05). For individuals with tetraplegia only, as mobility and fitness increased, frequencies of (1) encounters increased; (2) avoidances per encounter decreased, in multiple EAMQ domains (all P≤.05). Perception of barriers did not differ between lesion levels (P=.79). Mobility and fitness were not related to environmental barriers perception in both groups (all P>.17). CONCLUSIONS: Fitness and mobility are associated with barrier behaviors (ie, encounters and avoidances) among individuals with tetraplegia, but not paraplegia. Despite a greater barrier avoidance rate, persons with tetraplegia do not perceive more physical barriers than persons with paraplegia. Surprisingly, fitness and mobility were not related to perception of barriers in either group. More research is required on if barrier perception, behavior, or both influence participation, to enable rehabilitation programs to tailor interventions to enhance participation.
引用
- Callahan MK, Cowan RE. Relationship of Fitness and Wheelchair Mobility With Encounters, Avoidances, and Perception of Environmental Barriers Among Manual Wheelchair Users With Spinal Cord Injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2018. PMID: 29981312. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2018.06.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。