生物反馈辅助吞咽治疗对成人吞咽障碍的疗效:系统综述与荟萃分析
该系统综述纳入23项研究共448例成人吞咽障碍患者,评估生物反馈辅助吞咽治疗的效果。荟萃分析显示生物反馈可显著增加舌骨位移(WMD=0.22cm,95%CI[0.04,0.40],P=.02),但功能性经口摄食和管饲依赖无显著改善。证据质量有限,需更多大型RCT验证。
要点
- 生物反馈辅助吞咽治疗可显著增加舌骨位移,但功能改善不明确。
- 功能性经口摄食和管饲依赖在生物反馈组与对照组间无显著差异。
- 研究存在高偏倚风险和显著异质性,证据质量有限。
核心结论
- 使用表面肌电和加速度计的生物反馈辅助吞咽治疗可增强舌骨位移,但吞咽功能改善不明显。
主要发现
- 五项对照研究纳入荟萃分析,包括卒中95例、头颈癌33例、混合病因10例。
- 生物反馈组舌骨位移显著大于对照组(3项研究,WMD=0.22cm,95%CI[0.04,0.40],P=.02)。
- 功能性经口摄食无显著差异(WMD=1.10,95%CI[-1.69,3.89],P=.44)。
- 管饲依赖无显著差异(OR=3.19,95%CI[0.16,62.72],P=.45)。
- 吞咽功能和管饲人数指标存在显著统计异质性(I2 70%-94%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 生物反馈类型包括加速度计、表面肌电和舌压测压法。
- 训练包括唾液吞咽、手法和力量练习,剂量为6至72次,每次20-60分钟。
- 偏倚风险高,使用多种未验证的结果测量工具。
临床怎么用
- 临床可考虑使用表面肌电或加速度计生物反馈辅助吞咽治疗以改善舌骨位移。
- 但不应期望生物反馈能显著改善功能性经口摄食或减少管饲依赖。
局限性
- 纳入研究偏倚风险高,异质性显著(I2 70%-94%)。
- 使用多种未验证的结果测量工具。
- 研究数量少,无法进行亚组分析。
- 数据极其有限,需更大规模精心设计的随机对照试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe and systematically review the current evidence on the effects of swallow therapy augmented by biofeedback in adults with dysphagia (PROSPERO 2016:CRD42016052942). DATA SOURCES: Two independent reviewers conducted searches that included MEDLINE, EMBASE, trial registries, and gray literature up to December 2016. STUDY SELECTION: Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and non-RCTs were assessed, including for risk of bias and quality. DATA EXTRACTION: Data were extracted by 1 reviewer and verified by another on biofeedback type, measures of swallow function, physiology and clinical outcome, and analysed using Cochrane Review Manager (random effects models). Results are expressed as weighted mean difference (WMD) and odds ratio (OR). DATA SYNTHESIS: Of 675 articles, we included 23 studies (N=448 participants). Three main types of biofeedback were used: accelerometry, surface electromyography (sEMG), and tongue manometry. Exercises included saliva swallows, maneuvers, and strength exercises. Dose varied between 6 and 72 sessions for 20-60 minutes. Five controlled studies (stroke n=95; head and neck cancer n=33; mixed etiology n=10) were included in meta-analyses. Compared to control, biofeedback augmented dysphagia therapy significantly enhanced hyoid displacement (3 studies, WMD=0.22cm; 95% confidence interval [CI] [0.04, 0.40], P=.02) but there was no significant difference in functional oral intake (WMD=1.10; 95% CI [-1.69, 3.89], P=.44) or dependency on tube feeding (OR =3.19; 95% CI [0.16, 62.72], P=.45). Risk of bias was high and there was significant statistical heterogeneity between trials in measures of swallow function and number tube fed (I2 70%-94%). Several nonvalidated outcome measures were used. Subgroup analyses were not possible due to a paucity of studies. CONCLUSIONS: Dysphagia therapy augmented by biofeedback using sEMG and accelerometry enhances hyoid displacement but functional improvements in swallowing are not evident. However, data are extremely limited and further larger well-designed RCTs are warranted.
引用
- Benfield JK, Everton LF, Bath PM, et al. Does Therapy With Biofeedback Improve Swallowing in Adults With Dysphagia? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2018. PMID: 29859178. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2018.04.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。