中低收入国家身心残疾者康复服务模式的系统综述
中等至高质量证据支持:重性抑郁在初级保健中行心理干预、严重致残新发病例入住多学科专科康复病房、较轻病症行社区/医院/居家多学科门诊康复;但含早期出院的模式不推荐用于老年严重卒中、慢阻肺、髋部骨折及全关节置换患者。
要点
- 多学科专科康复病房可降低严重新发病例的死亡率和机构化照护需求。
- 初级保健心理干预适用于重性抑郁患者。
- 早期出院模式不推荐用于老年严重卒中、慢阻肺、髋部骨折和全关节置换患者。
核心结论
- 住院多学科专科康复单元推荐用于严重新发病症,可降低死亡率和机构化照护需求,尤其对老年人、卒中或慢性背痛患者。
- 结果预期可推广至脑/脊髓损伤和复杂骨折。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索CINAHL、EMBASE、MEDLINE、CENTRAL、PsycINFO、Business Source Premier、HINARI、CEBHA和PubMed。
- 纳入比较2种以上康复照护模式的系统综述、随机对照试验和观察性研究,不限语言。
- 使用AMSTAR评估方法学质量,GRADE评估证据质量。
主要发现
- 中等至高质量证据支持:重性抑郁在初级保健中行心理干预。
- 中等至高质量证据支持:严重致残新发病例入住多学科专科康复病房。
- 中等至高质量证据支持:较轻病症行社区、医院或居家的多学科门诊康复。
- 含早期出院的康复模式不推荐用于老年严重卒中、慢阻肺、髋部骨折和全关节置换患者。
关键数值与推荐
- 住院多学科专科康复单元:推荐用于严重新发病症,可降低死亡率和机构化照护需求。
- 初级保健心理干预:推荐用于重性抑郁患者。
- 门诊多学科康复:推荐用于较轻病症,场所为社区、医院或居家。
- 早期出院模式:不推荐用于老年严重卒中、慢阻肺、髋部骨折和全关节置换患者。
临床怎么用
- 严重新发致残病症应优先安排多学科专科康复病房住院。
- 重性抑郁可在初级保健中开展心理干预。
- 较轻病症可采用社区、医院或居家的多学科门诊康复。
- 老年严重卒中、慢阻肺、髋部骨折和全关节置换患者应避免早期出院模式。
局限性
- 证据主要来自系统综述,部分领域以4项原始研究补充。
- 研究在不同国家完成,结果外推需结合当地情境。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare models of rehabilitation services for people with mental and/or physical disability in order to determine optimal models for therapy and interventions in low- to middle-income countries. DATA SOURCES: CINAHL, EMBASE, MEDLINE, CENTRAL, PsycINFO, Business Source Premier, HINARI, CEBHA and PubMed. STUDY SELECTION: Systematic reviews, randomized control trials and observational studies comparing >2 models of rehabilitation care in any language. Date extraction: Standardized forms were used. Methodological quality was assessed using AMSTAR and quality of evidence was assessed using GRADE. DATA SYNTHESIS: Twenty-four systematic reviews which included 578 studies and 202,307 participants were selected. In addition, four primary studies were included to complement the gaps in the systematic reviews. The studies were all done at various countries. Moderate- to high-quality evidence supports the following models of rehabilitation services: psychological intervention in primary care settings for people with major depression, admission into an inpatient, multidisciplinary, specialized rehabilitation unit for those with recent onset of a severe disabling condition; outpatient rehabilitation with multidisciplinary care in the community, hospital or home is recommended for less severe conditions; However, a model of rehabilitation service that includes early discharge is not recommended for elderly patients with severe stroke, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, hip fracture and total joints. CONCLUSION: Models of rehabilitation care in inpatient, multidisciplinary and specialized rehabilitation units are recommended for the treatment of severe conditions with recent onset, as they reduce mortality and the need for institutionalized care, especially among elderly patients, stroke patients, or those with chronic back pain. Results are expected to be generalizable for brain/spinal cord injury and complex fractures.
引用
- Furlan AD, Irvin E, Munhall C, et al. Rehabilitation service models for people with physical and/or mental disability living in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review. J Rehabil Med. 2018. PMID: 29616278. doi:10.2340/16501977-2325
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。