改善卒中康复研究的开发、监测与报告:卒中恢复与康复圆桌会议共识核心推荐
卒中恢复与康复圆桌会议组织国际专家通过多次电话会议和2016年5月费城为期两天的会议,制定15条共识核心推荐,以解决卒中康复研究在干预开发、监测和报告方面的局限。小组回顾2015年发表的182篇卒中康复试验论文,发现多数出版物未清晰描述干预如何开发或监测,干预的理论依据和组成成分报告不足,即使报告推荐也多数未充分描述。
要点
- 卒中康复试验中干预的理论依据和组成成分报告不足,影响疗效证据的可信度。
- 15条共识推荐涵盖干预开发、监测和报告三个领域,需研究界采纳。
- 2015年182篇论文中,报告干预的推荐被采纳多于开发或监测的推荐,但多数仍未充分描述。
核心结论
- 为推进卒中康复研究和确保患者获得最佳循证临床照护,研究界应采纳本共识推荐。
研究设计与样本
- 国际卒中康复专家合作,通过多次电话会议和2016年5月费城两天会议制定共识推荐。
- 小组回顾2015年发表的182篇卒中康复试验论文以验证推荐的必要性。
主要发现
- 多数2015年发表的卒中康复试验论文未清晰描述干预如何开发或监测。
- 干预的理论依据和组成成分报告不足,使许多疗效评估的干预受到质疑。
- 涉及报告干预推荐的试验多于涉及开发或监测推荐的试验,但多数报告推荐仍未充分描述。
关键数值与推荐
- 共制定15条共识核心推荐,涵盖干预开发、监测和报告三个领域。
临床怎么用
- 卒中康复试验应严格开发、监测并完整报告干预,以提供稳健、有意义且可实施的证据。
- 研究界应认可并采纳本共识推荐,以推进卒中康复研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Recent reviews have demonstrated that the quality of stroke rehabilitation research has continued to improve over the last four decades but despite this progress, there are still many barriers in moving the field forward. Rigorous development, monitoring and complete reporting of interventions in stroke trials are essential in providing rehabilitation evidence that is robust, meaningful and implementable. An international partnership of stroke rehabilitation experts committed to develop consensus-based core recommendations with a remit of addressing the issues identified as limiting stroke rehabilitation research in the areas of developing, monitoring and reporting stroke rehabilitation interventions. Work exploring each of the three areas took place via multiple teleconferences and a two-day meeting in Philadelphia in May 2016. A total of 15 recommendations were made. To validate the need for the recommendations, the group reviewed all stroke rehabilitation trials published in 2015 (n=182 papers). Our review highlighted that the majority of publications did not clearly describe how interventions were developed or monitored during the trial. In particular, under-reporting of the theoretical rationale for the intervention and the components of the intervention call into question many interventions that have been evaluated for efficacy. More trials were found to have addressed the reporting of interventions recommendations than those related to development or monitoring. Nonetheless, the majority of reporting recommendations were still not adequately described. To progress the field of stroke rehabilitation research and to ensure stroke patients receive optimal evidence-based clinical care, we urge the research community to endorse and adopt our recommendations.
引用
- Walker MF, Hoffmann TC, Brady MC, et al. Improving the Development, Monitoring and Reporting of Stroke Rehabilitation Research: Consensus-Based Core Recommendations from the Stroke Recovery and Rehabilitation Roundtable. Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2017. PMID: 29233072. doi:10.1177/1545968317732686
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。